AITA for preventing my daughter from having a princess moment?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

On a brisk weekend at a large family reunion, excitement filled the air amid shared laughter, nostalgic chatter, and a few unexpected surprises. The scene was set for an unforgettable day as relatives from far and wide gathered to celebrate togetherness. Amid the joyful chaos, one particular moment turned unexpectedly charged with conflicting views.

In the midst of the festivities, a wild deer unexpectedly emerged from the nearby woods. While most of the family eagerly crowded around the animal, one father’s instinct to protect his young daughter set him on a collision course with tradition, sparking a debate over safety versus the allure of a “princess moment.”

‘AITA for preventing my daughter from having a princess moment?’

Last weekend my wife’s family had a huge reunion with many people (including us) coming from out of state. During the reunion, they had several cookouts and during one of these cookouts, a deer came out of the woods and walked right up to the group. Almost everyone was ecstatic and crowded around the deer to pet and take pictures with it. I was the lone exception.

I’ve never seen a deer before and have no experience with them but I thought it was odd that a wild animal would just walk up to a group of people. I also didn’t trust that it wouldn’t get spooked and start kicking. When my wife picked up our very young daughter to go pet the deer, I told her that it was dangerous and she shouldn’t.

She told me that it’s alright but I was persistent. We ended up arguing while walking toward the deer and when we were close to it, I snatched our daughter out of her arms and walked off. That pretty much ruined the rest of the reunion because her entire family spent the rest of it criticizing me and calling me an ahole for being dramatic. My wife said that I ruined a Snow White moment for our daughter.

We didn’t talk to each other on the flight home and have barely spoken since then. Admittedly I know nothing about deers outside of what I’ve seen on TV and movies and even then I tend to ignore them in those settings so I could have overreacted. But I think it’s better to be safe than sorry when it comes to our daughter but obviously everyone else disagree.

A brief remark on the tale reminds us that parenting decisions in unexpected situations can quickly divide opinions. The father’s instinct to shield his daughter from a wild encounter serves as a reminder of the fine line between caution and letting natural experiences unfold. His action, though seen by some as overly dramatic, underscores a commitment to safety.

Analyzing the situation, the father’s refusal to allow his daughter to approach the deer is rooted in valid concerns. Wild animals—even those appearing docile—can become unpredictable, posing real risks such as injury or exposure to diseases. The criticism from his family illustrates a common societal debate: should every magical moment be pursued even if it jeopardizes wellbeing?

Broadening the discussion, this incident touches on a larger issue of how we interact with nature in modern society. Many wildlife authorities stress that even a seemingly benign encounter can turn hazardous in an unmonitored environment. Maintaining a safe distance not only protects humans but also minimizes undue stress on the animal. This perspective reminds us that nature deserves both admiration and respect.

According to wildlife expert Dr. Jim Steele from the University of Kentucky, “Wild animals are unpredictable and even a calm creature can become dangerous if startled, so keeping a safe distance is essential for both human and animal safety.” His words, as reported in discussions on wildlife safety, emphasize that safeguarding our loved ones sometimes means making unpopular choices.

By prioritizing caution and educating others on wildlife behavior, parents can better navigate these unpredictable encounters. For further details, interested readers may check reputable sources such as the U.S. Forest Service guidelines.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

Here are some hot takes from the Reddit community – candid, humorous, and unabashed. The diverse opinions range from staunch approval of cautious parenting to light-hearted jabs at chasing social media moments. The comments not only add color to the debate but also highlight a collective shift towards safety in nature versus the lure of a picture-perfect moment.

MariContrary − You're 100% correct. Even with deer that are used to humans, approaching a loud group of humans is unusual behavior. Unusual behavior in a wild animal is concerning. That usually means it's sick. Not only that, but deer carry ticks. The name "deer tick" is accurate. Oh, and those ticks carry the bacteria that cause: Lyme disease, anaplasmosis, babesiosis, among others.

We're not talking about 1 in 1000 ticks carrying disease either. It's about half, depending on season/ location. Even more likely when they're from a deer that's acting wrong. But wait, there's more! Deer can and will front strike. That means they get up on their back legs and strike with their front legs. They look delicate, but those legs pack a punch.

Enough to seriously injure your kid, or worse. And no, your wife is not faster than a spooked deer reflex. Thing is, deer aren't predators. They're prey. So when they get spooked, their response is to get the f**k away, and if that means charging through you, that's a you problem. Don't f**k with wildlife.

Sand_and_sky − If your wife wants your daughter to have a princess moment, she needs to either secure an arranged marriage to cement alliances with another country, or take her to Disneyland.. NTA for leaving the wildlife alone, as they should be.

Holiday_Horse3100 − I have deer and elk in my yard regularly. Some of them won’t move even when I walk outside. I love to watch them but I never attempt to pet them or feed them. They are completely unpredictable. You did the right thing

SewRuby − Deer have INSANELY sharp hooves, they rear up on their hind legs and kick with them. Deer are wild animals, that deer had a crowd of people around it. There is NO telling of this deer was going to rear and kick. You protected your child, when all the other adults were hell bent on their social media moments. Kudos to you.. Your daughter can play Snow White when she's old enough to understand the dangers of approaching wild animals.

Agoraphobe961 − NTA. Country girl here, it’s very rare for a wild animal to be that docile. It usually means it’s sick, rabies is one that jumps to mind. Even if it was “healthy”, deer often have ticks and other insects on them. You describe your daughter as very young, so she would be very susceptible to anything. If you can, reach out to the area’s animal control or DNR department (google is your friend) and report the deer’s behavior. You can also ask if they have a reported outbreak

stdnormaldeviant − her entire family spent the rest of it criticizing me and calling me an ahole for being dramatic. My wife said that I ruined a Snow White moment for our daughter. Eeeeeeverybody's friends and family just suck. Why. NTA and please don't bring your children near wild animals because some moron says it's a "snow white moment." For f**k's sake.

Cybermagetx − Nta at all. I grew up with deer coming to my backyard. They almost never come near humans. And the only time I've heard them coming to loud groups of people is when something was wrong it it.

[Reddit User] − Uh yeah. General rule of thumb is you never touch wildlife. Deer are known to carry ticks. I don't know that all the drama was necessary, but your young child should definitely not be touching deer.

1000thatbeyotch − Looking at many wildlife sites, you will see that the first “rule” is to stay at least 50 feet away if possible. Human interaction and interference causes them harm. Plus, they’re wild animals. You have no idea what could alarm the deer and cause it to bolt or lash out. NTA. You are also teaching your daughter to respect Mother Nature who can be very unpredictable.

UnluckyYou3574 − NTA - from a person that has lifelong issue from Lyme Disease. I would never let a child try to pet a deer!

In wrapping up, the incident raises important questions about balancing child safety with once-in-a-lifetime experiences. While some advocate for embracing life’s enchanting moments, others emphasize caution above all. What would you do if you found yourself in a similar situation? Share your thoughts and experiences, and let’s explore how we can respectfully interact with both nature and our loved ones.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *