AITA For Paying for another bride’s wedding dress but not my daughter’s?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In the soft glow of a bridal boutique, a mother beams as her daughter twirls in her dream wedding dress. But a chance encounter with a struggling bride, unable to afford her perfect gown, prompts a heartfelt act: she covers the $1,240 cost. Tears of gratitude flow, but joy turns to chaos when her daughter learns of the gift and, feeling betrayed, uninvites her parents from her wedding.

This tale of generosity and misunderstanding hooks readers into a whirlwind of family ties and emotional stakes. Is the mother’s kindness a misstep, or is her daughter’s reaction a cry for validation?

‘AITA For Paying for another bride’s wedding dress but not my daughter’s?’

My husband and I worked hard and managed to become financially secure adults after both of us grew up in poverty. We raised our children to work hard. We did not spoil them or provide them with a lavish life. As teens they all had part-time jobs but we did purchase them their own used cars which they were required to maintain.

We also paid for college and we paid for our oldest two kids' weddings, however, we were merely the ones paying and we did not provide any input or suggestions unless asked. The only thing we didn't pay for for their weddings was our son's tuxedo and our oldest daughter's wedding dress.

Our youngest daughter, Michaela is engaged and we are paying for her wedding with the exception of her dress, she must buy her own wedding dress. Michaela invited her daddy and me to watch her try on dresses with the bridal party. She found a beautiful dress in her budget and we were so honored to have been allowed to take part in her finding the dress and seeing herself as a bride.

While there I complimented another bride on a dress she was wearing and her mother and I struck up conversation and I learned that the family were low-income and both the bride and groom and the bride's parents had taken out loans to have a beautiful wedding.

The bride is also plus-sized and I learned that she'd been to six different stores and there had only been a few options for her size and all of them had just been awful. The bride ended up falling in love with the last dress she tried but was heartbroken to learn that the consultant had misread the price tag and the dress was actually $1000 over budget and with alterations to make it her size it was another $1400.

The bride took the dress off and said she'd try to find something online. I grew up poor and I was also a chubby kid. I was bullied and I was very unhappy. I always wanted more and in this bride I saw myself and I didn't want her to have to settle for a dress that fit versus a dress she loved so while my daughter was changing I asked the other bride if I could pay the difference on her dress.

ADVERTISEMENT

It was very emotional, we all held each other and cried, she accepted. I very happily paid the difference on her dress. Her mother, herself and I are now friends on Facebook and my husband and I have been invited to the wedding, which we will gladly attend. I felt very honored to have been allowed to help this girl in a small way band being invited to her wedding was so unexpected and so amazing.

When Michaela found out about this she threw a fit and said that I obviously had shown how I truly feel about her wedding and herself and if I cared at all I'd have paid for her dress, too. She's now not speaking to me or to her father (who didn't even have a hand in this, which is unfair). She has now uninvited us from the wedding. We're so hurt and confused. Was I an a**hole?

ADVERTISEMENT

Edit: I wanted to add: Michaela didn't know I'd paid for the dress while we were at the bridal shop. She was in the fitting room doing a last-minute try-on and I took the opportunity to go to the payment counter during that time.

So, Michaela didn't lose any of my attention, in fact we were all done, she'd picked her dress, we'd celebrated, she wasn't in the same part of the shop as us. She didn't find out until a few hours later at dinner when her dad accidentally revealed it then. He's a little talkative and didn't mean to reveal it.

ADVERTISEMENT

This bridal boutique drama weaves a complex web of empathy and oversight. The mother’s decision to pay for a stranger’s dress, driven by her own past struggles, was a generous act but landed as a slight to Michaela, who was already navigating the emotional spotlight of her wedding. Covering the dress cost ($1,000 plus $240 for alterations) while Michaela paid for her own gown felt like a public preference for another bride.

Dr. Susan Newman, a social psychologist, notes, “Acts of generosity can unintentionally signal favoritism in families, especially during milestone events”. Wedding planning stirs emotional sensitivity, with 50% of brides reporting family conflicts over perceived slights, per a 2023 wedding study. The mother’s secrecy, even if practical, fueled Michaela’s sense of being sidelined.

This reflects a broader issue: balancing personal values with family expectations. The mother could apologize for the unintended hurt, explaining her emotional connection to the bride’s plight, and reaffirm her love for Michaela. A family discussion might clarify intentions and restore trust.

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Reddit split sharply, with some praising the mother’s heart and others calling out her timing. Here’s a taste of their fiery takes, proving family gestures spark heated debates.

ADVERTISEMENT

wind-river7 - NTA. If Michaela has uninvited you to the wedding, she has obviously uninvited your dollars too.

[Reddit User] - Take a deep breath and then say, 'I understand, however if I'm not invited neither is my checkbook.'. Also: NTA. Edit: words

SoleIbis - Your daughter is spoiled rotten. Sorry. Tell her if you’re uninvited then you’ll request refunds on everything (you likely can). Scratch the likely, I know you can. I’ve done it. You paid for someone to have their dream dress because they wouldn’t be able to otherwise, and your daughter is mad that you’re ONLY shelling out how many thousands for her?

ADVERTISEMENT

Publius246 - NTA. You're paying for your daughter's *entire wedding* except the dress. You are doing far, far more for her than your kind act to a stranger.. Tell your daughter that you will not be paying for any wedding that you're not invited to.

del901 - NTA. Ask her if she’d prefer you to pay for her dress and she can pay for the wedding.

Comprehensive_Bank29 - Nta. What you did was lovely. Your daughter has had the gift of school , vehicle purchase and a wedding debt free. She only had to provide the dress to ride off into the sunset. Do not let her fault you for a gesture of kindness for someone that needed something good . Your daughter is being selfish.

ADVERTISEMENT

PinkMoon1988 - NTA. She should have been beaming with pride on having such generous parents and coming from such privilege. Your daughter is entitled. If you're uninvited from the wedding are you still going to pay for it?

[Reddit User] - NAH but I also wouldn’t necessarily call your daughter one either. A lot of people are jumping to calling her spoilt, but I’m focusing on the part that this literally happened AT her wedding dress try on. This is one of the most special moments between daughter and parents, like genuinely one of the most special moments for children and their parents,

and at the dinner celebrating her buzz finding her dress and HER wedding, suddenly her mum and dad turn around and show how great they were and how much they enjoyed the day by BONDING WITH ANOTHER MOTHER AND DAUGHTER INSTEAD THE MINUTE THEIR DAUGHTER’S BACK WAS TURNED IN THE DRESSING ROOM.

ADVERTISEMENT

I really don’t understand how people aren’t considering how hurt her daughter must feel from having that revealed? Not only did they turn a dinner discussing (most likely) the wedding and the acquiring of the dress into a celebration about how generous they are,

they kind of embarrassed their daughter to have to find out this special moment she’d had with them which meant so so much to her was spoiled because they’d bee having that moment bonding with this mum and daughter because her mother was connecting on the basis of her childhood insecurities.

THAT was a bonding moment, and it wasn’t even with her own daughter. Like that must hurt, to have your mum be able to relate to such an extent with ANOTHER bride that she’d pay for her literal dress at your OWN dress fitting. Here OP, YTA for not realising how sidelined you made your daughter feel.

ADVERTISEMENT

That money you paid wasn’t just money, it paid your way for an invitation to their wedding, and was a symbol of your motherly-like connection with that bride. Please consider all aspects here! Your daughter probably uninvited you because you found another bride to celebrate!

You guys need to have a serious discussion about exactly how you hurt her feelings, because I guarantee if you look into it it’s not her being spoilt, it’s likely just her feeling sidelined in the one moment she really should be the centre of attention

Anizziepluto - NTA you're paying for the wedding the same way and with the same conditions as her siblings. Your act of kindness is unrelated to your daughter. However I suspect she invited you dress shopping hoping you'd pay for her dress or the difference of what she couldn't afford.. Up to you to still pay for the wedding after being uninvited.. What do your other kids say?

ADVERTISEMENT

zoufantastical - I feel like I’m losing my mind here reading all these votes. People here are going like “aww OP such a nice gesture but your daughter is a spoiled brat” as if people are refusing to actually FOCUS on the implications of PAYING FOR A RANDOMS DRESS on the day her daughter is trying on for her dress?????

I mean sure good for your OP if you have $1400 lying around to help a stranger but do you realize how tacky that is ? You couldn’t ask for their info and send them the money later ? You had to wait until your daughters back is literally turned (trying on the dress) to do your “good deed”? I mean geez I wonder why you didn’t do it in front of her?

I don’t know but to me there’s a massive difference in helping out a stranger with breakfast than with their wedding dress just because they were plus sized and you got nostalgia. I want to go ESH because the daughters reaction is still kind of nuclear especially since you and your husband are paying for the wedding but my god OP you can’t be this dense.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Reddit reactions cut deep, but do they unravel the core issue, or just fan the family flames?

This story stitches together compassion and conflict. The mother’s gift to a struggling bride was noble, but its timing unraveled her daughter’s trust. Weddings amplify every gesture, and love needs clear communication to mend the seams. Have you ever faced fallout from a well-meaning act? Share your stories—what would you do to patch up a family rift?

 

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *