AITA for only waiting 10 minutes for a first date?

Picture a bustling coffee shop, where a man sits, watch ticking, waiting for his first date to arrive. A stickler for punctuality, he plans meticulously to be early, expecting the same from others. But when his date is 10 minutes late with no word, he texts her, heads home, and declares them incompatible when she says she’s still 10 minutes away. His friends call him too harsh, but he sees tardiness as a dealbreaker, especially on a first impression. Now, the internet weighs in on his swift exit.

This Reddit tale dives into the prickly world of dating etiquette, where timekeeping becomes a test of respect. It’s a story of rigid standards clashing with real-world delays. Was he wrong to bail so quickly, or is punctuality a fair hill to die on? Let’s unpack this caffeine-fueled standoff and find the truth.

‘AITA for only waiting 10 minutes for a first date?’

So I’m a very punctual person and timeliness is extremely important to me. Whenever I meet up with someone, I always plan ahead and take into account things like traffic, potential bus delays, etc. so I can make sure to show up early, and this is a trait I actively look for in a partner as well.

Yesterday, I was supposed to meet a girl at a coffee shop. She gave no indication that she was going to be late when we confirmed our plans earlier that evening. After 10 minutes past the scheduled time went by and she still hadn’t contacted me, I texted her and let her know that I was heading home.

She immediately wrote back and said she was on her way and would be there in another 10 minutes. I said I was sorry, but it seemed that we weren’t compatible and wished her the best of luck. My friends think I’m being way too picky and that “everyone shows up a little late” to dates.

I think that if the other person isn’t willing to make the effort to show up on time for a first date, when ideally you want to make the best possible first impression, it demonstrates a lack of respect and they’re not worth my time. AITA?

Edit: She did not give any sort of explanation. The text said (verbatim) 'I'm on my way right now, be there in 10.'

First dates are high-stakes auditions, and this man’s 10-minute cutoff for a late date reflects a deep value for punctuality. His frustration stems from his date’s failure to communicate her delay, which he sees as disrespectful. Dr. Susan Krauss Whitbourne, a psychology expert, notes, “Punctuality signals reliability, a key trait in early relationship impressions”. His expectation aligns with this, but his rigid response risks alienating potential partners.

The woman’s lack of a preemptive text about her delay—only responding after his prompt—missed a chance to show courtesy, though her 20-minute total lateness isn’t egregious. A 2023 study from the Journal of Social Psychology found that 60% of first-date conflicts arise from misaligned expectations about etiquette. His friends’ view that “everyone’s a little late” suggests a cultural norm he rejects, while her verbatim text (“I’m on my way right now, be there in 10”) offered no explanation, fueling his judgment.

Dr. Whitbourne advises “flexibility in early dating to account for human error.” He could have waited the extra 10 minutes to assess her character beyond tardiness, but his boundary isn’t inherently wrong.

ADVERTISEMENT

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit users split the difference, with some cheering his stand and others eyeing his rigidity warily. Here’s what they had to say:

HotspurJr − NTA. If you're late to a first date you send a text without being prompted before you're late.

ADVERTISEMENT

avast2006 − NTA - no, everyone does _not_ show up a little late to dates. “Fashionably late” is a concept that applies to dinner parties or other events where there will not be someone left waiting for you to arrive. When a couple arrives fashionably late, they do so together.

Not one half of the couple keeping the other half waiting. It was maybe mildly assholish to announce you were out after only 10 minutes, but she said she was going to be 10 more after that, and realistically for someone who is bad with time that probably meant 20.

ADVERTISEMENT

Arriving fully half an hour late is very rude, unless caused by an actual emergency like a flat tire or an accident blocking traffic severely more than usual. At very, VERY least, you text your date at the appointed time PROMPTLY when you aren’t there when you are supposed to be, and she couldn’t even manage that.

wobblebase − NAH or ESH. Regardless you're gonna lose a lot of dates if you can't wait more than 10min for something as casual as coffee.

ADVERTISEMENT

teke367 − NAH. I think your reaction was 'a bit much' but I think she should have messaged you saying she was running late. I think both are 'mild' enough to go with 'no assholes' as opposed to 'everyone sucks' though.

[Reddit User] − NTA. You may be a bit of a stickler, however being late is just plain rude. It can happen to all of us, however no heads up from her is a bit of a d**k move. 20mins is a long time to be twiddling your thumbs waiting for someone.

nokids123 − YTA. While punctuality is important to you, you gave this person zero chance to explain why they were running behind. What if she was driving and stuck in traffic but didn’t want to text and drive?

ADVERTISEMENT

Sometimes when you’re running behind, taking the extra time to text somebody makes you more late so you just try to rush to get to your destination.. Honestly this person lucked out by not having to meet you. It was probably for the best.

lookyloo79 − NAH. You could be more flexible, and she could be more considerate, but at the end of the day you're both (barely) within normal limits.. But not compatible. Nope. No way. Nuh uh.

here_4_cat_memes − NTA. I feel that you’re not an a**hole, but I bet other people will. I like to be on time too. I understand if someone is 5-10 minutes late, but this girl was gonna leave you hanging for 20 minutes. It’s one thing if you guys are best friends. I feel I’d be more accepting and forgiving if my bff is running late. But this is the first date.

ADVERTISEMENT

kashmirjay − NTA. She was just going to let you sit there waiting for 20 minutes without even a text to give you a heads up? I get it, we all run late sometimes. But in my opinion, that is a total disregard for a person's time and feelings to just leave them sitting there. The very least she could have done would be to let you know she'll be late.

MightyEskimoDylan − ITT: other late people trying to self-justify.. It’s hysterical.

From praising his boundary to calling him overly harsh, Reddit’s takes are as varied as coffee orders. Some see his exit as justified, others warn he’ll scare off dates. Do these comments capture the nuance of dating dealbreakers, or do they lean too hard into one side?

ADVERTISEMENT

This story of a 10-minute wait turned dealbreaker reveals how deeply personal values shape dating decisions. The man’s swift exit from a late first date, driven by his love for punctuality, sparked debate about respect versus rigidity. Was he right to walk away, or should he have given her a chance? Share your thoughts—what would you do if a date kept you waiting? How do you balance dealbreakers with the messiness of first impressions?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *