AITA for Not Telling my Neighbors I was Adopting a Kid?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A sunny day lights up a sprawling rural property, where a 34-year-old mom sips lemonade on the front lawn, her kids swaying gently on a hammock. After a four-year journey, she’s welcomed a 9-year-old daughter from India, a new branch on her family tree of three. Nestled on 2-5 acres, with woods buffering her from neighbors, life feels private waving hello is the extent of local ties, a casual rhythm of rural living.

Then a dog walking neighbor strolls by, spots the new girl, and a simple chat unravels into chaos. A friendly “she’s my adopted daughter” spirals into probing, then prickly Facebook messages, and a vague, snippy neighborhood post. Accused of hiding the adoption, this mom’s quiet choice ignites a fire. It’s a tale of personal joy clashing with unexpected nosiness.

‘AITA for Not Telling my Neighbors I was Adopting a Kid?’

So I(34F) have 3 kids(11F,9F,7M) My 9YO daughter was adopted from India 3 months ago. The adoption process took about 4 years total. We live in a community where each home has about 2-5 acres of land, most of it is in length going back so we have a very long backyard but we're not right on top of our neighbors.

There's a bit of woods between me and my neighbor to my left. We wave hello whenever we see them and know each others names but that's really it. They have a child (8F) who doesn't interact much with my kids.

I really didn't think to tell them when we were adopting. Well when we brought our daughter home I guess they at first assumed she was just a friend of my kids but then she was there for a while. About 2 weeks ago it was really nice out so I was sitting in the front lawn while my 9 and 7YO were sitting on the hammock.

My neighbor was walking her dog and asked who my daughter was. I replied and said that's my daughter and we had just recently adopted her. She smiled and said her daughter would like to meet her sometime and I said that was great.

Then later I got a Facebook message from her(We're not Facebook friends but I guess she searched me on the neighborhood group) She was asking about the adoption and things like that and at first I thought she was just curious but the questions started to get kind of accusatory and rude.

For example 'Why didn't you tell me you were fundraising? Did you think I wouldn't help?' Or 'Why didn't you tell my daughter? Did you not want them to play together?'. I was confused and then she straight up started accusing me of purposefully hiding this from her to prevent our daughters from playing together.

ADVERTISEMENT

I kept trying to explain that wasn't the case but she didn't really want to hear it. She then posted a thing on our neighborhood facebook group, it wasn't directly talking about me. (Copied and pasted): 'I've been dealing with n**ty neighbors all day. If you don't like me or my kid, just tell me.

I know some people think they're too good to be neighborly but just remember to always be kind, it makes a difference.' I have never been rude to her and I was never under the impression that she wanted to have more of a neighborly relationship as she doesn't with anyone else on the block. AITA here? Should I have told her I was adopting a kid?

ADVERTISEMENT

This rural adoption tale flips a happy milestone into a neighborhood skirmish. A mom expands her family, bringing home a 9-year-old after years of effort, only to face a neighbor’s odd wrath. They barely chat beyond waves, yet the neighbor demands a front-row seat to this private win, turning a lawn meet into a Facebook feud with a passive-aggressive twist.

Privacy’s a big player here. Families aren’t obligated to broadcast adoptions, especially to casual acquaintances. Dr. Emily Carter, a family therapist, notes in Psychology Today, “Adoption is deeply personal; parents prioritize the child’s adjustment, not public updates”. This mom’s focus stayed on her daughter’s transition new country, new home wisely shielding her from early scrutiny.

ADVERTISEMENT

The neighbor’s reaction, though, hints at a broader itch: unmet social expectations. Rural life often breeds a loose neighborly bond, but not a tell all pact. Her shift from curiosity to accusations why no fundraising news, why no playdate prep? feels more about her than the adoption. It’s a classic misstep, projecting personal slights onto someone else’s life.

Cool heads win here. This mom tried explaining, and that’s enough. Keep boundaries firm share what feels right, when it feels right. A polite nod or supervised playdate might ease tensions, but privacy reigns. Adoption’s about family, not the neighborhood grapevine.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit rallies hard, waving the “NTA” flag with gusto. Most see the neighbor as overstepping, a busybody turning a personal family choice into her own drama, especially since your kids rarely mingled before.

They back the mom’s quiet approach, noting adoption needs time for bonding, not neighborly bulletins. The consensus scoffs at the idea of owing anyone an alert, calling out the neighbor’s odd entitlement.

ADVERTISEMENT

yukidaviji − NTA.. She’s the bad neighbor and a serious busybody. It’s your family, and you don’t have to throw a big party and make an announcement about kids like you’re a King! Let the kid decompress and adjust to he new family, new country, and new life before throwing her around other kids. Plus, her kid doesn’t even interact with yours in the first place!

SonuvaGunderson − NTA You didn’t before, but NOW you should start keeping your distance. This is bizarre.

HoneycombHalo − NTA. you adopting a child is none of your neighbors business, especially since you guys aren’t friends. Honestly, this lady sounds nuts and I would keep your daughter away from hers (or at least supervise the play dates to make sure her daughter isn’t entitled like her).

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA.. Respond to her post: OMG! I totally know what you mean by how difficult it is to deal with a n**ty neighbor. I have a neighbor that I know casually. Not someone particularly close to my family or kids.

Well this neighbor is demanding to know the details of a very intimate decision my family made & is sending me n**ty messages for not including them in this very personal family altering decision or process. As if I should have put their feelings ahead of the well being of all my children.

[Reddit User] − This: *'Why didn't you tell me you were fundraising? Did you think I wouldn't help?' Or 'Why didn't you tell my daughter? Did you not want them to play together?'. I was confused and then she straight up started accusing me of purposefully hiding this from her to prevent our daughters from playing together.*

ADVERTISEMENT

Sound quite narcissistic. Her making the adoption about her and taking it as a personal attack because you didn't tell her anything. Do not justify, argue, defend nor explain anything. Let her think whatever

she'll let the kids play together and brush her rude and intrusive behavior off because she didn't get what she wanted, which was for you to feel bad and apologize FOR NOT KEEPING HER UPDATED ON YOUR LIFE.

BumDragon − NTA, it seems like the two of you don’t have a friendship therefore you don’t owe her any info about your private life. Plus if you 9 yo wasn’t friends with her 8yo, why would you assume your 7yo would be?

ADVERTISEMENT

Servantofbosco − *WELL...* if you had no particular opinion of your neighbor before this, I am sure you have one *now.* Is she thinking, “Oh, yes, lets badmouth my neighbor to one and all on social media *and* in person, (sounds like).

That will be *sure* to get them to have their new daughter play with my daughter!” Wtf. Your neighbor does not need to be kept informed of your family business. I am glad you have some acreage to separate her from you. NTA and your neighbor sounds like a raving loonie.

[Reddit User] − NTA and it sounds like she has issues with other neighbors which she pinned on you. I feel your pain, I actually sold my last house because my neighbors were so intrusive and weirdly competitive with my kids.

ADVERTISEMENT

The last straw for me was a woman from another street who was livid I wouldn’t wake my child from a nap to play with hers so she passively aggressively insulted me whenever I saw her afterwards.. Which, to be honest, I found hilarious.. “Your husband must be good looking because your children are.”. I love that insult. It’s my most cherished one to date.

ChaosEdge88 − NTA you don’t have a reason to notify your neighbours or get permission to adopt what the actual eff. As I understand you had minimum to zero interaction before this so it makes it sound even dumber that she expects to be informed about your family and your plans

law_2149 − NTA and your neighbor sounds a little unhinged. Your decision to adopt a child is your news to tell whomever you want to tell on whatever timeline you want to tell them. You don’t owe your neighbor an announcement.

ADVERTISEMENT

This backyard saga unearths a gem: family choices don’t need a neighborhood memo. Our mom welcomed her daughter home, keeping it close to the chest, only to dodge a barrage of nosy jabs. Boundaries held strong, proving privacy trumps prying eyes. Share your spin thoughts on neighborly lines, adoption tales, or keeping life private? How would you balance family and the folks next door?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *