AITA for not reprimanding my daughter for a video she posted about my stepdaughter even though what she said was true?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A quiet family gathering turned into a digital storm when a teenager’s fleeting TikTok comment unraveled years of unspoken tension. In a cozy suburban home, where family photos line the shelves, a 15-year-old’s frustration with her distant half-sister spilled onto social media, sparking a firestorm of opinions. The mother, caught between loyalty to her daughter and her husband’s plea to mend his bond with his eldest, faces a dilemma: is truth worth the chaos it caused?

The Reddit post that captured this saga reveals a tangle of emotions—hurt, loyalty, and the weight of blended family dynamics. Readers are left wondering: should a teen’s honest cry be punished, or is the real issue the fractured bonds left unaddressed for years? This story pulls us into a relatable struggle, where love and distance collide in the age of viral posts.

‘AITA for not reprimanding my daughter for a video she posted about my stepdaughter even though what she said was true?’

Brief history my husband has a daughter, 'Edith' (27F) from his first marriage. He divorced his ex when Edith was 7, but she apparently had a hard time with the split, and moving houses, etc. He and I met and married when Edith was 10. Together, we now have 'Cecilee' (15F) and 'Peter' (10M)..

Edith has always been aloof with our children. She was never particularly interested in them, although both kids, Cecilee especially, would've loved a closer relationship with her. I did bring up to my husband a few times that I was worried about Edith not being closer to her siblings.

He responded that her ambivalence was better than he expected, given how hard she took the divorce, and he did not want to rock the boat. I was not happy with this but I let it rest. He and Edith are pretty close, but she barely speaks to me, Cecilee or Peter..

Cecilee has mostly gotten over her desire to be close to Edith. I used to see her perk up when she saw her at family functions a few years ago, making a point to sit close to her, or talk to her. She does not do that anymore, and is polite but not super eager when we see Edith now..

​So to the current situation- Cecilee recently discovered a tik tok account of Edith's cousin. Apparently Edith has her sleepover in her condo (she lives in a big, 'fun' city), and they go to events. They seem to be very close. This opened up a whole lot of feelings for Cecilee and she got upset and responded to the video saying 'That's my sister.

And she barely talks to me'.. ​Literally, that's all she said. But she got quite a response with people giving opinions for both sides. Apparently, someone figured out Edith's instagram, and were sending her harassing messages.

I definitely feel awful about that. However, I refused to reprimand or punish my daughter. She only said the truth. My husband is upset as Edith skipped thanksgiving at our place this year, and he thinks punishing Cecilee will help his and Edith's relationship.. So AITA?. ​. ​

Family dynamics in blended households can feel like navigating a maze blindfolded. The Reddit user’s story highlights the delicate balance of fostering sibling bonds across age gaps and past traumas. The mother’s refusal to punish her daughter, Cecilee, for her TikTok comment reflects a clash of priorities—truth versus harmony. Meanwhile, her husband’s push for punishment to appease Edith suggests unresolved guilt from past family fractures.

This situation mirrors broader challenges in blended families. According to a 2019 study by the American Psychological Association, nearly 60% of stepfamilies face tension due to differing expectations of closeness (apa.org). Edith’s aloofness, likely rooted in her childhood divorce trauma, contrasts with Cecilee’s yearning for connection, creating a rift neither parent fully addressed.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Patricia Papernow, a renowned stepfamily expert, notes, “Step-relationships require intentional effort to build trust, especially when children feel displaced by new family structures” (stepfamilies.info). In this case, Edith’s distance may stem from unresolved feelings about her father’s remarriage, while Cecilee’s public venting reflects unguided emotional expression. Both need empathy, not blame.

To move forward, the family could benefit from open communication. The mother might initiate a calm discussion with Cecilee about the impact of online actions, emphasizing accountability without punishment. Couples therapy for the parents could align their approaches, ensuring Edith feels respected while addressing Cecilee’s hurt. Setting realistic expectations for sibling bonds, given the 12-year age gap, is key to healing.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit’s hot takes on this family saga are as spicy as a holiday dinner gone wrong! Here’s what the community had to say:

ADVERTISEMENT

anneg1312 − YTA. You seem to harbor resentment toward Edith and that only makes things worse for everyone. What your daughter posted might be the truth, but knowing people were now harassing Edith needed to be addressed right away by her.

So… not punishment, but accountability. The family dynamic should have been addressed and expectations outlined 10 years ago, but it’s never too late. Y’all just let things fester/unfold unguided. Fix that. YOU and your husband are the adults.

Edith was only 10 years old and was deeply affected by the split and then thrust into having siblings all while likely feeling replaced/unimportant/to blame …who knows! I just don’t understand adults who go and ‘combine’ families and don’t help ALL the kids to feel wanted and loved equally. Instead they emphasize the STEP and get stingy, egotistical and possessive. YUUUCK.

ADVERTISEMENT

no-onwerty − NAH But - you gotta talk to your daughter about leaving comments with identifying info on social media sites and the unintended consequences of that. You need to explain to your daughter that her comment led to her sister being harassed and even though that isn’t what your daughter likely intended that is what happened.

But seriously, do you WANT your 15 year old hitting the town with a 27 year old?. Also - What type of sibling relationship were you expecting with a 12 year age difference? Edit - you all I’m not saying you can’t have a good relationship with a much older sibling. I just think it will be closer to a cool aunt/uncle than typical sibling dynamics.

I’d also guess that it might not become mutually close until later in life when you there isn’t such a gap in life experience/maturity. I don’t know what a 15 year old and three year old would have in common. But 25 and 37 might have more to talk about. Note I just pulled random ages out here.

ADVERTISEMENT

EmpressJainaSolo − YTA. I understand Cecilee is hurt. However, the only reason she made that post was because she was jealous and wanted to publicly shame Edith. The whole point of the post was for people to see it and harass Edith for her choices. The harsh reality is that Edith does not see your children as her siblings.

Yes, they are technically biologically related, but it doesn’t sound like Edith ever played the role of a sister to her siblings. This isn’t even someone going no contact with a loved one. There was never love there. You and your husband can (and should) unpack his part in that but at the end of the day all you can ask from Edith is basic respect.

Since you give no examples of her acting unkindly I am assuming she reached that benchmark. You are judging Edith for not wanting what you want. In turn, your expectations have affected how Cecilee views the situation. I imagine part of her hurt stems from you enforcing the idea that she should still feel a connection to her siblings.

ADVERTISEMENT

A fifteen year old has a general idea of online harassment. Your daughter understood her words would cause problems for Edith even if she didn’t understand the consequences. Your daughter needs to understand that fairly or unfairly what she did could cause drastic consequences to Edith.

Online shaming doesn’t stop just because someone wants it to stop, and it doesn’t stay within expected or hoped for perimeters. If your daughter continues to use this method of speaking her truth she will continue to place herself in toxic and potentially dangerous situations online.

Give Cecilee consequences for *that*, not because your husband wants her punished to mend his relationship with Edith, and then work out your issues with your husband. There’s clearly something deep feelings there when it comes to the kids that will only keep bubbling to the surface if you never address it.

ADVERTISEMENT

BigBlueHood − YTA. Your step-daughter does no owe your daughter anything, with their age gap it is very normal for them to be virtual strangers. Your daughter harassed someone online leading to this person being bullied, she deserves at the very least a strict talking to and explaining why what she did was wrong and why she should leave Edith alone.

theabsolutegayest − ESH - Edith doesn't owe Cecilee a relationship, your daughter accidentally doxxed her half-sister, and you and your husband are so emotionally incompetent that all you can do is play punishment whack a mole rather than actually **parent**.

Your daughter owes Edith an apology - she initiated a personal conflict in a public setting, with no way to protect anonymity, and now Edith is being harassed by internet trolls and is so upset that she skipped Thanksgiving with her father. Cecilee made a mistake, and while she didn't intend for all this fallout, she DID try to shame Edith for not being closer to her on a post that had nothing to do with her.

ADVERTISEMENT

But the real assholes here are you and your husband, for being so consumed in what *you* want for your children that you've neglected the reality of your family. You've both allowed your children to become less than they could be, because you centered your hurts and fears and resentments.

Your husband wants to punish Cecilee not for her actions, but as a performance to placate Edith. You refuse to punish Cecilee, even though her actions hurt someone else, because you resent the person she hurt. I bet your husband was so afraid of Edith's pain and anger over the divorce that he refused to even engage with it, hence her not processing all those feelings before he remarried or had more kids.

I also bet that while you 'let it rest,' you still carried resentment towards your then-teenage stepdaughter for not playing happy family with you. The reality of Edith and Cecilee's behavior and emotions was an inconvenience, when it should have been your first concern.

ADVERTISEMENT

You have all wronged each other. You have all failed each other. But you're also all family. That doesn't mean you have to see or like or even love each other, but if you *do*, it means you have something to fight for together. I hope you and your family can come to truly apologize to each other, and heal and grow from there.

ejdjd − YTA - Your step-daughter is 12 years older than your daughter and 17 years old than your son. There is literally NO common ground other than the fact that they have the same father. Trying to push a relationship with such age differences will never end well. What your daughter did was intrusive and demeaning because her 'feelings' were hurt her step-sister is friendly with someone closer in age and compatible in interests, and that someone wasn't her.

Daktari2018 − Why aren’t more people picking up on husband’s plan to punish Cecilee as a way to help the relationship??!! WTF

ADVERTISEMENT

redhead9390 − YTA. Your daughter just made the whole thing worse. Edith doesn’t owe you or your daughter a relationship. Your daughter has the right to be upset but she doesn’t have the right to cause unnecessary problems which resulted in Edith getting harassed. How would you feel if Edith made a comment on your daughter’s TikTok that got her harassed would you feel the same way?

ZookeepergameOk1354 − Info what was the point of the post? Have you talked to your daughter to find out why she did that.

facinationstreet − *he thinks punishing Cecilee will help his and Edith's relationship*. WTF?! Here's the thing: Edith doesn't have to like any of you. She can hang out with whomever she chooses. This post is just a small insight into why she would chose NOT to hang out with her father and you.. Cecilee would know no different if it weren't for *someone* putting this vitriol into her head.. NTA for not reprimanding her but you are leaving out an awful lot.

ADVERTISEMENT

These opinions range from fiery defenses of personal boundaries to calls for family unity. But do they capture the full picture, or are they just keyboard warriors tossing out quick judgments?

This tale of family tension and social media fallout shows how a single comment can ripple through relationships. The mother’s stance—backing her daughter’s truth while navigating her husband’s loyalty to his eldest—leaves us pondering where accountability lies. Blended families are complex, and this story reminds us that empathy and communication are vital to mend frayed bonds. What would you do if you were caught in this family tug-of-war? Share your thoughts below—how would you handle a teen’s viral vent or a distant sibling’s pain?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *