AITA For not letting people stay at my house after they traveled over 10 hours to stay here?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine waking up to the gentle lapping of lake waves, surrounded by towering trees and chirping birds—a personal paradise. For one homeowner, this dream home became a hot commodity among friends craving a free vacation. But when a college buddy pulled a bait-and-switch, sending two strangers to crash at this idyllic retreat, things took a turn. The sting of betrayal hit hard as the doorbell rang, revealing uninvited guests expecting a week-long stay.

This Reddit saga dives into a clash over boundaries and trust, with a homeowner standing firm against unexpected visitors. It’s a tale of friendship tested by assumptions, leaving readers wondering: how far would you go to protect your sanctuary? The drama unfolds with a mix of audacity and awkward confrontations, pulling you into a story that’s as relatable as it is wild.

‘AITA For not letting people stay at my house after they traveled over 10 hours to stay here?’

I have a very well paying job which requires me to mostly work from home with the occasional travel(Usually once a month for a few days) to certain locations as a result I could choose to live wherever I want and I chose a lovely big home next to a lake with a ton of nature surrounding it, I am not even kidding, sometimes I have to pinch myself when I just woke up because I feel so blessed I got to live here.

Now I am from a big city which is where most of my old friends and family still live and as a result on a monthly basis I get at least one person asking me if they can 'come to see me' which is a different way of saying they need a vacation and want to stay with me. I'll be short, mostly my answer is a simple no especially if I need to travel during their stay as I don't trust anyone but my dad and girlfriend to be alone at my house.

However on occasion I say yes, especially if I want to see someone. So my college friend 'Brian' contacted me asking if he and a buddy could vacation at my place for a week as they really need a break and he wanted to hang out like the old days. I agreed, I haven't seen Brian in ages but still actively talk to him, so why not?

And before some of you start about covid, you can have people over here and there hasn't been an outbreak here or in the city they live in months. So we agree when he will arrive and he'd bring another of his college buddies. Well the day comes, I prepare the guest rooms and an hour before they are supposed to arrive Brian messages me that something came up and he can't come,

I figure okay then, but I get a message a few minutes later that he got another one of his buddies to take his place. I told him I was not comfortable letting 2 strangers stay and didn't get a reply. At any rate roughly an hour and a half later my doorbell rings and 2 dudes stand there with their luggage. I say hi and ask them what they want and they say they are staying here,

I say they ain't and tell them to bugger off, they ask me if they can at least stay the night, I say no. Brian calls me later going out of his mind with anger claiming I am a giant AH and that his friends had to drive for hours only to drive back home when he told me they would be coming. I told him to go F himself.. His friends probably at least I assume knew nothing about this so I feel terrible for them.

This lakeside debacle is a classic case of overstepping boundaries. When Brian swapped himself out for two strangers without checking, he didn’t just disrupt plans—he broke trust. The OP’s refusal to host unvetted guests wasn’t just about comfort; it was about safeguarding their home. This scenario highlights the importance of clear communication in friendships, especially when personal space is involved.

Psychologist Dr. Irene Levine notes in a Psychology Today article, “Friendships thrive on mutual respect, and overstepping boundaries can erode trust quickly” (source). Brian’s assumption that the OP would roll with his last-minute switch shows a lack of respect, likely fueled by the allure of a free vacation spot. The OP’s firm stance was a necessary boundary.

This ties into broader issues of personal space in social dynamics. A 2021 study by the American Psychological Association found that 68% of adults value control over their home environment as a key factor in mental well-being (source). Brian’s move ignored this, putting the OP in an awkward spot.

For the OP, moving forward could mean a frank talk with Brian about respect and expectations. Setting clear guest policies—like only hosting close friends—can prevent repeat issues.

ADVERTISEMENT

Check out how the community responded:

The Reddit crew came in hot with their takes, and it’s clear they’re Team OP on this one! Here’s what they had to say about Brian’s bold move:

dh_k02 − NTA.. what the f**k is wrong with Brian..

bbanda − NTA This isn’t an Airbnb reservation. You thought your friend was coming to stay and he sent a couple of randos in his place. He clearly gave them the go ahead before talking with you. Sorry bud this isn’t a rental, jog on.

ADVERTISEMENT

RoyallyOakie − NTA...Letting a friend stay there is not a blank invitation for anyone. Let me know if you change your mind about strangers as I could use some nature.

ur-humble-overlord − NTA. brian knew well before they got there plans had changed and he didn't run it by you. they don't get free lodging with an hours notice. id be peeved.

InsertMyNameHere9154 − No you’re NTA....who in heck let’s strangers stay at their house?! That would be BEYOND stupid. And your friend is an AH for even thinking that was ok, then getting mad that it wasn’t. Sucks to be the friends, but they should have prepared for the worse and got a hotel before traveling back....

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA!!!! I don’t want strangers in my house either.

LizzyrdCE − NTA - your friend is being a presumptuous AH and should be to blame for inconveniencing his friends. You're not running a frickin' hotel or AirBnb...

TogarSucks − NTA. 10 hour drive and “Brian” told you an hour and a half before they got there not only that he wouldn’t be coming but another stranger was taking his place? That was intentional to trap you. The two guys may or may not have been in on it(like you pointed out) but Brian is a giant a**hole.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − Wait, it's a 10 hour drive and he called you to say he couldn't come but a friend was coming in his place, 1.5 hours before they arrived? Meaning he let them not only set off but also do 8.5 hours of the drive before he even bothered to check with you whether it was ok?. NTA.

Celastr1na − NTA. You aren’t running a B&B and there’s no way Brian would honestly think you’d be happy to have two complete strangers stay in your home. He’s probably a total chancer trying to make you feel uncomfortable calling him out and guilting you into letting them stay because he’s promised them a cheap trip and he knew you wouldn’t agree if he told you in advance.

These Reddit opinions are fiery, but do they nail the heart of the issue? Is Brian’s audacity a one-off, or a sign to rethink the friendship?

ADVERTISEMENT

This story is a wild ride through the perils of friendship and the sanctity of home. The OP’s lakeside haven turned into a battleground for boundaries when a friend’s last-minute switcheroo backfired. It’s a reminder that even close pals can misstep, leaving trust in tatters. Would you have opened your door to those strangers, or sent them packing like the OP? Share your thoughts—have you ever had to slam the door on an overstepping friend?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *