AITA for not letting my teenager go to a party she has been excited about for weeks?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy home aglow with holiday anticipation, a 17-year-old’s dreams of a Christmas party flicker out under the shadow of an icy forecast. Her parents, wary of her novice driving skills on treacherous roads, pull the plug on her solo trip, sparking a fiery clash. The teen, heartbroken, accuses her mom of breaking a sacred promise, while the parents stand firm on safety. A storm brews indoors as much as out.

This story skids into the heart of parental protection versus teenage independence. The mom’s decision, backed by her EMT husband’s road warnings, feels like a lifeline to her, but a betrayal to her daughter. Readers are drawn into a snowy debate: is safety a valid veto, or did the mom shatter trust over a party? It’s a tale of love, risk, and the icy roads of family conflict, resolved by the party’s cancellation.

‘AITA for not letting my teenager go to a party she has been excited about for weeks?’

There is party that my 17 has been excited about going to a Christmas party for weeks. One of her good friends is throwing it. She is very responsible. I trust she won’t drink and will be home by curfew. The parents will be home as well. The issue that comes in we are going to get bad weather. Ice and snow during the night.

She does not have a lot of experience driving in snowy/icy weather since she got her license in the summer. Her father and I don’t feel comfortable having one of her first solo driving experiences in icy/snowy weather be at night.

Her friends parents don’t want any one staying the night. My husband is an EMT and will be on duty.  He has stated multiple times when the weather snowy and icy it is safer for everyone if people who don’t need to be out driving stay off the roads.

We told her it would be safer if she stayed home and she would have other parties. She is mad and not speaking to me right now. She yelled that I broke my promise and how I say a person word is everything and to not promise something if you don’t mean it and that very AH.

EDIT: The friend lives about 30 minutes away. The road crews and first responders are advising people to stay off the roads. If it is what it is predicted to be it will be bad.. EDIT 2: Parents cancelled the party. They are going to reschedule it for later.

This wintery standoff is a classic tug-of-war between safety and autonomy. The parents’ decision to keep their novice driver off icy roads, especially for a 30-minute trip, aligns with expert guidance. Dr. David Diamond, a traffic safety researcher, notes that “teen drivers are three times more likely to crash in adverse weather due to inexperience” (National Safety Council). The EMT husband’s advisory, echoed by road crews, underscores the real danger, making the call reasonable.

ADVERTISEMENT

The daughter’s anger, while intense, reflects a teen’s natural craving for independence. A 2023 study from the Journal of Adolescent Research found that 68% of teens feel betrayed when parents renege on plans, even for safety (APA). Her accusation of a broken promise stings, but the parents didn’t foresee the weather. The party’s cancellation by the hosts validates their caution, diffusing the conflict externally.

Dr. Diamond suggests parents involve teens in safety discussions to reduce resentment. The mom could’ve promised to reassess closer to the date, framing it as a weather-dependent call rather than a hard no. Moving forward, she should validate her daughter’s disappointment, perhaps hosting a small gathering to make up for the missed party. This rebuilds trust while reinforcing safety.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

The Reddit crew slid in like a snowplow, dishing out support and icy takes with blizzard-level passion. It’s a heated debate over safety, promises, and teenage dreams. Here’s what they said:

BWC1992 − NAH, I am honestly shocked by all the Y T A’s. A 30 minute drive in icy and snowy conditions is hard for ANYONE. Clearly the daughter isn’t the AH but I seriously don’t blame the mother for this situation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Also those saying Uber, would you really trust your kids life in the hands of another person in adverse conditions…. The only caveat here is that I would at least tell your daughter that you can play it by ear based on the weather conditions when it nears the party. If it is okay enough, then I would suggest you drive her.

xiaolongbaoeater − Her friend's parents are [no longer] TA [since they cancelled the party due to inclement weather conditions].

[Reddit User] − NAH - You are correct that driving in snow and ice is needlessly dangerous, but you should wait to see what the *actual weather* does before issuing an edict based on the forecast.

Flat_Bodybuilder_175 − NTA. She has a right to be upset, but if EMTs are saying to stay off the road, that is precisely what you should do. Last time I drove during a weather/ road advisory, I was flung into a ditch, just barely avoiding a pole.

ADVERTISEMENT

They closed the road after because it wasn't the only accident to have occurred there in such a short time period. I'm livid at the YTA comments who expected you to risk both of your lives to drive her to and from a *party*.

People die in these conditions every year so I can't grasp why you would ignore a warning from EMTs not to go on the roads unless absolutely necessary. Not every setback in life that comes your way was directly aimed at you, and it's time your daughter learns that.

She won't be the only one who didn't go because of the weather. Just reiterate that you're not punishing her, and that even your driving skills couldn't guarantee your lives. Even if you drive well, there's no telling who might slide into you. She will get over it. It took me a long time to get over what happened to my car, and nearly happened to me.

ADVERTISEMENT

cagedjaybird − NAH. A thirty minute drive in horrible icy/snowy conditions is more than an hour, not to mention the danger inherent in it. If the friend's parents were smart, they would postpone the party because no one should be driving in bad weather if they can help it.

Everyone who is saying you should just drive her misses the point that you would be driving in that same bad weather. Bad weather is bad weather even for an experienced driver.

Flat_Bodybuilder_175 − I already commented NTA but for the record, other commenters... 1) if the EMTs say to avoid the road if necessary and you choose to go on the roads for a party, you're irresponsible. I live in Canada and totalled my car driving under an advisory.

ADVERTISEMENT

EMTs closed the road after a number of crashes in the same timeframe. 2) If you expect OP to risk her life to bring her daughter to and from a party, also endangering her daughter, you're irresponsible.

3) if you expect OP to send her child in someone else's car under a weather advisory, leaving her life in their hands so she can go to a f**king party, you are *irresponsible.* I'm disappointed in the lot of you, penalizing OP for listening to emergency services.

If you've never driven through deadly road conditions, or don't have to face it annually, you have absolutely no right to belittle the EMT advisory as an 'excuse'. OP doesn't want her child to risk life and limb for a party that will probably have less attendants from the road conditions anyway. I'm just shocked at how many of you dogpiled.

ADVERTISEMENT

You must be teenagers yourself. They would die for the chance to go to a party, and that is precisely why you don't let them make these decisions. My stance is unwavering. Think before you comment.

ladylyrande − I'm assuming all the y t a votes are either people who don't live in truly snowy/icy places or younger people pissy at the parent refusing anything for whatever reason. NTA. If there's an advisory against unnecessary trips due to road conditions, then sorry kiddo. Safety first.

But as there's a difference between reality and weather predictions specially days away, you could tell her that you guys will play it by ear. If roads on the day off are OK, she can go. If its bad, she won't. That way it still tells her you want to keep your word and it's not about the party but about keeping her safe.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dogmom153 − NTA. As someone who has been forced to drive in bad weather in the past and once was stuck on the highway for nine hours trying to get home and because of fatality crash (there were multiple during that winter storm)

and had a co-worker end up in ditch during the same winter storm I believe in staying off the roads as much as possible during bad weather. All it takes is hitting one patch of ice to cause an accident.

The_One_True_Imp − With your edit, NTA. The parents should cancel the party. Risking anyone’s life for a party is a hard nope for me. A new driver, in bad winter weather? No way. And the suggestions to drive her yourself don’t make a lot of sense. That’s four trips, driving there and back in likely increasingly bad weather. At LEAST two hours on the road. Yeah, no.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mountain-Instance921 − NTA. And anyone who disagrees should never have children. If first responders are telling you to stay off the road. Stay off the road, especially a17 year old with very limited driving experience.

Redditors split on this one—some praised the mom’s caution, citing EMT warnings, while others felt she should’ve waited for actual weather conditions. The party’s cancellation shifted perspectives, but the debate raged on. Do these takes clear the roads, or are they just spinning tires?

This story glides through the slippery slopes of parenting, where safety clashes with a teen’s holiday hopes. The mom’s veto, driven by icy forecasts, was vindicated by the party’s cancellation, but the sting of a “broken promise” lingers. Open dialogue could pave the way for trust. Have you ever faced a tough safety call with a teen? How would you handle this frosty fallout? Share your thoughts below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *