AITA for not letting my boyfriend’s little sister play Animal Crossing?

Venus Leo Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a snug apartment lit by the glow of a Nintendo Switch, a 20-year-old woman’s virtual paradise in Animal Crossing became a battleground. Her boyfriend’s 7-year-old sister, entrusted with the game, turned her carefully curated town into a digital wasteland, ignoring clear rules. Now, with tantrums erupting at every visit and her boyfriend tossing around words like “selfish,” the woman’s stand to protect her game is testing their love.

This tale of pixels and promises dives into the clash of boundaries and family ties. Was her ban on the child’s gameplay a fair call, or is she letting a game overshadow real relationships? Let’s explore this Animal Crossing chaos and the drama it unleashed.

‘AITA for not letting my boyfriend’s little sister play Animal Crossing?’

I (20F) live with my boyfriend (23M). Our relationship is pretty great, I’m very happy. Last year he got me a Switch as a gift. I’m a huge Nintendo fan so it was really awesome! His little sister (7F) frequently visits us, we babysit her for his parents a lot. I love her like my own sister. She’s usually pretty well-behaved but she has her moments.

His little sister recently saw me playing Animal Crossing and wanted to play. I initially said sure and let her play on the Switch for a while, but told her to not cut down any trees or destroy anything in my town because I put a lot of effort into it (like, 400 hours of effort, I’ve been playing since release).

Well, she gives me the Switch back once she’s bored, and my town is destroyed. All the trees are gone, my flowers are dug up, all of the items I placed are either moved or missing. I didn’t get angry or blow up at her, I calmly told her that what she did really hurt my feelings and she won’t be allowed to play Animal Crossing anymore.

She didn’t care at the time so I thought that was it. I spent at least 3 days rebuilding everything. She visited again a week or so later and wanted to play, but I told her no. She got increasingly upset and threw a huge tantrum. My boyfriend got involved and told me to let her play but I refused.

If she could have her own profile then that’d be different, but with this game you are limited to one save file per console. She’s visited several times since then and it’s always a fight. She demands to play and I tell her no. My relationship is on thin ice because of it!

My boyfriend said she’s just a kid and I should let her play, and he’s called me selfish more times than I can count. I put a lot of love and effort into this game, it’s my favorite. I have offered to let her play any of the other games on the Switch (Smash, Mario Kart, Minecraft) but she only wants Animal Crossing.. Am I being an a**hole for not letting her play?

Protecting personal passions, like a 400-hour Animal Crossing town, can spark real-world tensions. The woman’s decision to ban her boyfriend’s sister from the game after the child ignored rules reflects a valid need to safeguard her effort.

Dr. Tovah Klein, a child development expert, notes that by age 7, children can understand consequences for actions, making the ban a fair lesson in respect. The sister’s tantrums suggest she’s testing boundaries, a common phase, but one that needs firm guidance.

The boyfriend’s dismissal of the woman’s feelings, however, risks deeper strain. About 30% of couples report conflicts over differing parenting styles, even in non-parental roles. Klein advises the woman to calmly explain to her boyfriend how the game’s destruction felt like a violation, using analogies to his hobbies.

ADVERTISEMENT

Offering other games was a good compromise, but the boyfriend should teach his sister accountability, not enable her demands.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit’s comment section jumped into this drama with fiery support and clever analogies. Here’s what the community crafted:

TooTall2Function − NTA OP. At 7 she's old enough to understand when someone asks or tells her not to do something and she's old enough to begin learning there are consequences to her actions.

ADVERTISEMENT

If you haven't already, you need to explain to your boyfriend why she's not allowed to play Animal Crossing anymore and if he can't understand then try use an analogy with something he enjoys.

EDIT: while it's understandable that your boyfriend loves his sister and dotes on her, he's being incredibly disrespectful and showing a distinct lack of empathy towards your position if he's calling you selfish and refuses to listen to you and your position.

r36l10 − NTA you gave her expectations and she went against them, this is the consequence and now she is just throwing tantrums. Maybe do activities like planting flowers when you are together as a way to do the game irl and let her know that if she can be responsible with this she might get the chance to play again. Make sure to explain these expectations to ur bf too

ADVERTISEMENT

quetzal86 − NTA, it’s your property and your game. If he wants to appease her every time she comes over it’s on him, not you. He can get her a DS with animal crossing on it and be done with it. Also, what a spoiled little kid. You let her play once and she didn’t follow your instructions.

She should experience the consequence of her actions. If it bothers your bf so much, he should fork over the money for a switch so she can play, or better yet what about her parents?? You’re her baby sitters, your job is to keep her safe, fed, and clean not give into her every desire.

loser_rat − NTA your bf should be using this as an importunity to teach her about respecting other people and their property.

ADVERTISEMENT

loudent2 − INFO:. 1. Does you BF know she destroyed your town and cost you 3 days? 2. Does your BF know there is only one save in this game and if you let her play it she can, again, destroy what you've worked to build?. 3. Does your BF know that you offered to let her play other games and she refused?. If your BF knows all that and is still calling you selfish then he is an AH.. NTA

MinkMartenReception − NTA Don’t ever have kids with this guy. He’s obviously the type to toss candy, to get them to shut up.

xBayMang − NTA. Your console, your game, your call. You laid it out plainly to her, and she chose to ignore you.

ADVERTISEMENT

GrenadineBombardier − NTA. My relationship is on thin ice because of it! My boyfriend said she’s just a kid and I should let her play, and he’s called me selfish more times than I can count.. If this is the hill he wants to die on....

iShipwreck − I'm new and so far I have given everyone a 'YTA'. But in this case, 100% NTA. If anything your BF needs to teach his little sister about respecting other people's property. You explicitly told her not to do something and she did it anyways. The punishment: can't play anymore. Sorry

Of course there's the argument of 'It's just a game' but as a (former) gamer, it's not 'just a game'. It takes real life hours and effort to play a game and you have every right to be upset for someone destroying what you put into it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Like, if your BF played guitar everyday and put many hours into it and his little sister came in and broke it, I think he would be pretty upset and wouldn't let his sister near his guitar again. And a 'it's just a guitar' would help nothing.

CoconutxKitten − NTA. If she can’t respect your rules, she can’t play

These Redditors didn’t hold back, but do their takes nail the issue? This Animal Crossing saga’s got everyone buzzing.

ADVERTISEMENT

This Animal Crossing clash shows how a game can mirror real-life boundaries. The woman’s stand to protect her virtual town sparked tantrums and tension, testing her relationship’s foundation. Respecting property—digital or not—matters, but so does family harmony. Would you ban the kid or let her play again? Share your gaming stories and thoughts below—let’s keep this island chat going!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *