AITA for not inviting one girl to my daughter’s birthday party?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Planning a cozy sleepover for her 8-year-old daughter’s 9th birthday should’ve been a joyful task for this 35-year-old mom, but a schoolyard bully turned it into a parenting dilemma. With one girl in her daughter’s class making her life miserable—flushing toys, yelling, and worse—this mom decided the bully’s name doesn’t belong on the guest list. But her ex-husband’s call for “kindness” and inclusion has her second-guessing.

Torn between shielding her daughter from toxicity and avoiding the label of “mean mom,” she’s facing a family divide over a party meant to celebrate. This story of standing up to bullying while navigating co-parenting clashes is a heartfelt reminder that protecting a child’s peace can spark grown-up drama. Get ready for a tale that’s as empowering as it is contentious.

‘AITA for not inviting one girl to my daughter’s birthday party?’

I (35F) have an 8-year-old daughter who’s turning 9 next month. She goes to a small school and there are only 6 other girls in her year. For her birthday, she’s asked for a small sleepover party with just the girls from her class, which I’m happy to host at mine. Here’s the issue: one of the girls in her year has been relentlessly bullying her for the past 6 months.

She’s flushed one of my daughter’s toys down the toilet, regularly yells at her during break time, kicked her in the head (yes, really), and most recently threatened to kill her pets. My daughter has come home in tears multiple times, and I’ve spoken to the school, but not much has changed. Given all this, I told my daughter she absolutely doesn’t have to invite this girl to her birthday.

I don’t want to teach her that politeness and keeping the peace should come at the cost of her own mental health and safety. I was bullied at school and couldn't escape it for the same reasons. If this were an adult friendship, I’d be telling her to cut the toxicity out of her life - and I don’t think a birthday party should be an exception.

Here’s where I might be the a**hole: my ex-husband (her dad) thinks we should invite the girl because “it’s the kind thing to do” and that “we should be teaching her to include everyone.” He says it’s mean to invite all the other girls but exclude just one, and that we’re teaching our daughter to be cold and unkind.

I get that on the surface, excluding one kid might seem harsh - but does that still apply when the kid has made your child’s life miserable? I don’t want to be petty, but I also don’t think my daughter should have to play host to someone who actively bullies her, just to avoid social awkwardness.. So Reddit, AITA for not wanting to invite one girl to my daughter’s party?

Choosing not to invite a bully to your child’s birthday party is a bold stand, and this mom’s instinct to protect her daughter’s emotional safety is rooted in care. The bully’s actions—physical aggression and threats—cross serious lines, while the ex-husband’s plea for inclusion risks prioritizing appearances over well-being. The school’s inaction only heightens the stakes, leaving the mom as her daughter’s main defender.

This scenario underscores a critical issue: teaching children to set boundaries against bullying. A 2023 study by the National Center for Education Statistics found 22% of students face bullying, with emotional harm often outlasting physical incidents. Forcing inclusion of a bully at a personal event like a birthday can signal to a child that their comfort doesn’t matter.

ADVERTISEMENT

Child psychologist Dr. Becky Kennedy advises, “Kids need adults to model that it’s okay to say no to harmful behavior, especially in their safe spaces”. The mom’s decision empowers her daughter to prioritize self-respect, though her ex’s perspective reflects a common pressure to “keep the peace.” Dr. Kennedy’s insight highlights the need to balance empathy with protection.

To navigate this, the mom could calmly explain to her ex how the bully’s actions justify exclusion, emphasizing their daughter’s right to a joyful day. She might also push the school harder or explore counseling for her daughter to build resilience. Readers, take note: shielding kids from harm isn’t petty—it’s parenting. Teach boundaries early to help them thrive.

ADVERTISEMENT

See what others had to share with OP:

The Reddit crew came out swinging with takes hotter than a birthday candle, rallying behind the mom’s protective stance and torching the idea of inviting a bully. From calling out the ex’s misguided kindness to urging school action, these comments are fiery and fierce. Here’s the lineup.

Upset_Fail3456 − No f**k that the kids a bully and your daughter should have to put up with it on her birthday and I wouldn't want that girl in my house

ADVERTISEMENT

ElinaSweetx − Your guest list is your choice. It’s okay to set boundaries, especially if the person doesn’t fit well with your plans.

Long-Oil-5681 − NTA,you dont invite bullies to parties.. Life is not a disney movie and it's not up to CHILDREN to heal each other.. Any issues that kid has are not yours to solve.

CandylandCanada − General rule: Everyone gets a Valentine, and everyone gets an invitation for such a small number of girls. Specific rule: The greater good here needs to prioritize safety and security (which includes emotional security) over keeping the peace. It is particularly important to avoid instilling in girls the idea that their job in life is to keep everyone happy all the time and to not make waves.

You need only to trawl this sub for an hour or two to see the damage that is wrought when women sacrifice their own needs for other people's wants in the name of being a

ADVERTISEMENT

It seems as though dad may not have seen the full impact of the bullying (or he may be part of the problem if he thinks that little girls need to go along to get along). There should be no

If that happens then you'll have full confirmation that you made the right choice. Bottom line: Imagine your daughter's POV if the adults in her life are not only not defending her from this kid but insisting that she include her as part of her special day.

Civil_Environment858 − NTA but invites and such should not be done at school. Also, please remind the girls the kind thing to do would not be to talk about the party at school. What are the girl’s parents and the school doing about the bullying? Nothing? She’s kicked her and threatened to kill your daughter’s pets?

ADVERTISEMENT

Why are the police not involved?  I would honestly put my child in a different school. My parents did that when I was getting bullied like your daughter and it made all the difference for my physical and mental health. The school did nothing of course. . It might be time to go to the media…

sfree42 − Absolutely NTA it’s your daughter’s birthday not your ex-husband’s. Does he not care that this girl is terrorizing your daughter?

No-Chance-2145 − I don't think excluding one child from a party is the worst thing to do as long nobody brings invitations to school and hand them out during class or anything. It's best to get the address and mail the invites or go door to door. We need to start teaching children that it's fine not to be invited to things.

ADVERTISEMENT

That's just life people are excluded from things all the time. Also remind your daughter to not talk about her upcoming party in class even though it's exciting. That will hurt the bullies feelings and then the school or the bullies may parents get involved and that's a headache.

Due-Reflection-1835 − As long as she doesn't hand out the invitations in school. Rules used to be that if invitations were passed out in class, the whole class had to be invited. Of course, kids can be mean and they will make it known who's not wanted.. I wouldn't have a kid in my home that threatened to harm my pets. No way.

No_its_not_me_its_u − So. When she grows up and has a boyfriend that smacks her should she be kind and invite him to dinner?. Avoid mean people/abusers.

ADVERTISEMENT

Puzzleheaded-Ad7606 −

These Reddit sparks are blazing, but do they light the way or just fuel the fire? One thing’s certain: they’re all in on protecting this kid’s big day.

This birthday party showdown proves that standing up for your child can blow out the candles on family harmony. By barring her daughter’s bully from the sleepover, this mom chose safety over social niceties, but her ex’s push for inclusion keeps the debate burning. As the party plans take shape, we’re left wondering if this family can find common ground. Have you ever had to exclude someone to protect a loved one? Share your stories below—let’s cake up this conversation!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *