AITA for not inviting my girlfriend’s daughter to my daughter’s birthday party?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy home buzzing with birthday plans, a 15-year-old girl crafted invites for a dream party, her eyes sparkling with excitement. But beneath the festive vibe, a family tension simmered. Her dad’s girlfriend, Kelly, hoped her 16-year-old daughter, Anna, would join the fun—only to learn Anna wasn’t welcome, thanks to her bullying ways.

The dad’s choice to back his daughter’s guest list sparked tears and a heated clash. This Reddit tale dives into the messy world of blended families, where loyalty and teenage drama collide. Let’s unpack this birthday brouhaha and see what it reveals about parenting and protection.

‘AITA for not inviting my girlfriend’s daughter to my daughter’s birthday party?’

I(45M) have a daughter(15F). She and I are very close, her mother is not in the picture. I have been seeing 'Kelly' for almost 2 years. She has a daughter 'Anna' (16F) with her ex, they have joint custody of their daughter. Kelly does not live with me at the moment, but the idea has come up a few times.

One of the big reasons why I am not into the idea is that Anna is horrible to my daughter. Kelly does see how Anna treats my daughter, but thinks it's just a phase. My daughter loves to play video games, sports, watch Science-Fiction movies. Anna is the opposite, she is into make-up, wearing dresses and skirts, drama. They are two very opposite people.

My daughter's birthday is coming up quick and she wants to have a huge party. I was onboard with the idea and we spent a day making invites. She passed around invites to school to all her friends and right now the party is looking to be around 15-20 of her friends. My daughter made it clear that she did not want to have Anna at the party.

Kelly texted me asking if her daughter was going to receive an invite and I told her that daughter did not want to invite her. Kelly called me sobbing asking why she wasn't invited and I told her that the invites were up to my daughter. She then proceeded to accuse my daughter as the reason why kids in school did not like Anna

and that I was a huge AH for supporting her decision. I told her that the reason why kids in school did not like Anna was because of the way she treats them. She hung up on me and we haven't spoken in a few days.. AITA for not inviting my girlfriend's daughter to my daughter's birthday party?

This birthday party snub lays bare the challenges of blended families. The dad’s support for his daughter’s choice protects her from a known bully, but Kelly’s emotional reaction—sobbing and blaming—suggests denial about Anna’s behavior. Excusing it as a “phase” ignores a pattern that needs addressing.

ADVERTISEMENT

Family therapist Dr. Susan Forward notes in Toxic Parents, “Enabling harmful behavior by dismissing it damages relationships.” Research shows 30% of teens experience bullying, often impacting self-esteem. Anna’s actions, targeting the daughter’s interests, aren’t mere differences but deliberate cruelty. Kelly’s failure to intervene risks further harm.

The dad’s stance is right—his daughter’s safety comes first. Kelly should address Anna’s behavior through counseling or honest talks, not force inclusion. He might consider pausing cohabitation plans until Anna improves.

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Reddit erupted like a party popper with this one—imagine a teen hangout buzzing with hot takes! Most cheered the dad for shielding his daughter, slamming Kelly’s parenting.

[Reddit User] − ESH. Her for insisting her brat be invited, yes... But why are you still with a woman who lets her daughter be n**ty to yours? She sees it, she doesn't care. And you're okay with that? That's an AH move

ADVERTISEMENT

Unit-Healthy − NTA. Protect your daughter. And if your gf, age 40+, 'sobs' over a teenage party, and her daughter is a bully, are you really sure you want to blend these families?

jg700 − NTA.. I don't think moving in together is a good idea

[Reddit User] − “Anna is horrible to my daughter. Kelly…thinks that it’s just a phase.” Kelly, who needs some serious work on her parenting skills, is making excuses for a 16-year-old damn near adult. It sounds like Anna is spinning a tale that paints your daughter as the bad guy are you seriously going to allow her to do that?

If you force your daughter to invite someone who’s abusive to her, you’re going to damage your relationship. Instead of enabling bad behavior, step up for your child.. eta: NTA. Do the right thing, OP.

ADVERTISEMENT

OneMikeNation − NTA: when I first read the story I was thinking this were actual children not teenagers. It's one thing to try and force let's say 5 year olds to be friends. But teenagers are a different story. Your daughter is old enough to choose who she wants at her party

that-bro-joshy − NTA. Anna will only make your daughters party miserable and ruin her special day, Kelly sees how her daughter is, I would hope punishments and lectures are given to her when she bully’s your daughter (I doubt it by how Kelly dismisses her behaviour) if not then Kelly is just as big of an issue as her daughter,

if so you truly need to rethink this relationship, being a bully is not a “phase” and even if it is she needs to be dragged out of it. I have to ask why the hell would you consider moving in with someone when it’ll make your daughters life an absolute misery, I’m all for single parents moving on and dating and finding love but not at the expense of your own child.

ADVERTISEMENT

keegeen − NTA. At 15, it’s well understood that parties are for friends, not everyone. If Kelly wants Anna to be invited next time, she can take responsibility for getting her daughter’s behavior in line. Being different doesn’t have to mean not liking each other; Anna chose to make it that way.

Nilimamam_968 − INFO: if you don‘t mind sharing, in what way did Anna mistreat your daughter? I only saw you mention how different their interests are but otherwise no real explanation

nannylive − NTA. A 15 year old gets to choose her own birthday guests. Dad might get veto power to delete a guest in dire circumstsnces. but never to add one.. You will be better off if Kelly stays mad.. At least don't move in with her until both those girls are out of the house and self sufficient.

ADVERTISEMENT

PrehistoricBetty − NTA. Your daughter is your primary responsibility, and it is your job to protect her from bullying and mistreatment. Why should your daughter be forced to invite someone to her party who has a history of being horrible to her? You are doing what you need to do with the party and by not rushing into moving Kelly into your house.

You'd be bringing your daughter's tormentor into her safe place. If you and Kelly want to live together, wait until your daughter moves out or Anna learns how to treat people. Anna is an AH for bullying your daughter, and Kelly is an even bigger AH for not addressing the issues. Two years of terrible behavior is not a 'phase,' it is a pattern that is not going away without intervention.

Does Anna even want to go to the party, or is this Kelly trying to project her wish for one big happy blended family? Kelly needs to know that it isn't happening. Sixteen is plenty old enough for Anna to hear the truth (from her mom) about why kids don't like her, and why she didn't get an invite.

ADVERTISEMENT

But do these Reddit roars capture the full story, or are they just fueling the family drama?

This birthday bash battle highlights the tightrope of blended families, where a teen’s safe space clashes with a partner’s hopes. The dad’s loyalty to his daughter is solid, but was Kelly’s plea unfairly dismissed? Protecting a child comes first, yet relationships need work. What would you do in this family feud? Share your thoughts—have you navigated a clash between your kid and a partner’s?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *