AITA for not giving my daughter 50k.. again?

When twin sisters Sarah and Ellie were promised $50,000 each for their futures, their parents set clear rules: use it for education with earning potential or a house down payment. Sarah’s nursing degree ate up her fund, while Ellie’s savvy carpentry scholarship left her enough for a house, sparking Sarah’s demand for another $50,000—or half of Ellie’s fund—for her own home.

The parents refused, insisting both got equal shares. This Reddit story, simmering with sibling rivalry, mirrors your own battles with family fairness, like your sister’s complaints of unequal treatment or your cousins’ expectations. Is the parent wrong to hold the line, or is Sarah’s demand out of bounds?

‘AITA for not giving my daughter 50k.. again?’

$And then since her course work would be lighter the first year, she could take an interior design course. We agreed. She chose to use her savings for the intro course. With the intro carpentry under her belt she got a scholarship to the full carpentry course. She used the 'fund' for design (3k). \*both girls lived at home for free during school\*$

$Sarah doesn't think it's fair that Ellie got the education and house while she doesn't. I told her we can't afford to give her 50k and I'm not taking from what was promised to Ellie to give to Sarah when she already got what was promised.. AITA for refusing to give my my daughter \*another\* 50k?$

Sibling comparisons can ignite family tension, and this Reddit user’s refusal to give Sarah an extra $50,000 upholds a clear, equal financial promise. Sarah’s nursing education, fully funded, contrasts with Ellie’s frugal carpentry path, which preserved her fund for a house—a choice within the agreed rules. Sarah’s demand, much like your sister’s fairness disputes, reflects entitlement born of envy, ignoring the equal opportunity both received.

Dr. Laurie Kramer, a sibling dynamics expert, notes, “Perceived inequity often stems from differing outcomes, not unequal treatment” . Sarah’s high-earning career, free of student debt, mirrors the “head start” Reddit praised, while Ellie’s thrift maximized her options.

The parents should reaffirm the rules calmly, as you’ve navigated family disputes, and encourage Sarah to save for her goals, perhaps offering non-financial support like budgeting advice. A family meeting to clarify intentions could ease tensions.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit overwhelmingly backed the parents, calling Sarah’s demand “bratty” and praising the equal $50,000 gift, with analogies and personal stories to drive the point home. Here’s their take:

Reddit’s siding with fairness, but are they missing Sarah’s emotional sting or just nailing the logic?

This parent’s refusal to give their daughter another $50,000 has fueled a twin rivalry, with Sarah crying foul over Ellie’s house fund. The story, like your own family fairness fights, asks where equal opportunity meets personal choice. Are the parents right to stick to their rules, or should they soften for Sarah? How would you handle a sibling demanding more than their share? Share your thoughts or stories of keeping peace in family money disputes!