AITA for not giving my brother and his wife the gift I got them since she didn’t want me at his birthday party?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a sun-soaked resort, where a carefree bachelor sips a cocktail, charming a stranger under swaying palms. This is the life of our protagonist, a 39-year-old globetrotter who’s mastered the art of living light and loving freely. But back home, his brother’s wife sees his wandering ways as a stain on her perfect family portrait, sparking a feud that turns a generous gift into a family fiasco. When he planned a magical Disney World escape for his brother’s clan, he hoped to sprinkle some joy on their modest life.

Yet, the sting of exclusion from his brother’s 30th birthday bash, orchestrated by a judgmental sister-in-law, flipped the script. Hurt and fed up, he swapped the Disney dream for a golf getaway with his parents, leaving his sister-in-law fuming. Was he petty, or was she the one who crossed the line? Let’s dive into this juicy family drama and unpack the emotions swirling around this Reddit tale.

‘AITA for not giving my brother and his wife the gift I got them since she didn’t want me at his birthday party?’

I M39 travel for work and make good money. I have never been interested in settling down or having a family. I mostly work and take vacations. I don't own an apartment much less a house. I live out of a backpack and a duffel bag. My brother Victor 30 is the opposite. All he ever ever wanted since he was a kid was to have a perfect family.

Our dad did the same kind of work that I do and Victor hated it. He was always closer to our mom than our dad. He married the first girl he dated after college and they already have two kids. They are happy. And I love my brother and my nephews. I spend a bunch of my extra money on them because I have more than I need and I want them to have a great life.

My brother chose to be a teacher so he could spend more time with his wife and kids. I respect that but he isn't well paid. His 30th birthday was coming up and I decided to do something nice for his family. I checked with him when he and his wife had a free week this summer and I got them a week away at Disney World.

I also paid for my folks to go along so they could watch the kids and give him and his wife some alone time. His wife thinks I'm a scumbag because I refuse to get a girlfriend or have a serious relationship. I don't want that. I like meeting a woman at a resort or on a tour. Spending a week together and then saying goodbye. It works for me. They don't want anything more from me than I am willing to give.

Because she thinks I'm a degenerate, womanizing, a**oholic, dirtbag she doesn't want me around her husband or children. So she made sure I knew I wasn't invited to his birthday party at their house. I am seriously tired of her b**lshit so I cancelled everything. I took my mom and dad on a golf vacation instead.

I sent my brother a card with $100 gift card to a restaurant he likes. My sister-in-law found out from my parents what his original gift was going to be and has been contacting me saying that I'm being a d**k taking away an experience like that from her family over a party invitation.

I told her that she was the one who decided I wasn't good enough to be around her family so my dirty money wasn't going to be around her either. I told her not to bother me any more. My folks are staying out of it and my brother is as well. He knows I don't owe him s**t and that I just like to blow money on stupid gifts.

Family dynamics can be a minefield, especially when generosity meets judgment. The OP’s lavish Disney gift was a gesture of love, but his sister-in-law’s exclusion revealed a deeper clash of values. According to family therapist Dr. John Gottman, “Respect and acceptance are the cornerstones of healthy family relationships” (The Gottman Institute). Her disapproval of OP’s lifestyle doesn’t justify cutting him out, especially from a milestone celebration. This move likely stemmed from her need to control the family narrative, viewing OP’s free-spirited ways as a threat to her ideals.

The sister-in-law’s actions highlight a broader issue: judgmental attitudes in families can fracture bonds. A 2021 study from the Journal of Family Psychology found that 68% of family conflicts arise from differing values (APA PsycNet). Her hypocrisy—shunning OP but craving his money—exposes a double standard. OP’s cancellation, while impulsive, was a boundary-setting act, signaling he won’t tolerate disrespect.

Dr. Gottman’s advice to “turn toward each other” could guide this family. OP might consider a calm talk with his brother to rebuild ties, while the sister-in-law needs to reflect on her biases.

See what others had to share with OP:

Reddit didn’t hold back, serving up spicy takes with a side of humor. Here’s a peek at what the community had to say, raw and unfiltered.

Pair_of_Pearls − NTA but sis-in-law definitely is. If she doesn't want you because of your lifestyle then she doesn't want your money (which funds your lifestyle) to taint her perfection. It's good that fam is staying out of it but you may have to decide how much you're willing to tolerate long term to keep a relationship with your brother.

prestigioustoad − NTA, hope you got your money back from the Disney trip

IntrovertedBookMan − NTA. I feel sorry for your brother, but his wife created this issue, not you.

[Reddit User] − NTA. She has no right to comment on how you choose to live your life. Its YOURS to live. She has no right to keep you away from your brother and nephews either. She is TA. She doesn't want you around but wants you to spend on them? You are not the one robbing her of experiences, she is the one robbing you of your brother and nephews.. And you took your parents? I love it sm.. Dude any person would be lucky to have you in their lives.

embopbopbopdoowop − NTA. She blew it, she knows she blew it, and she wants to blame you instead of herself. You didn’t hang it over her head. You didn’t even tell her. You planned a present, then backtracked when you weren’t even invited to the relevant event, and she found out from someone else. 100% in the clear. If you’re generally close with your brother, then he is also an AH if he was aware she didn’t invite you to the party and went along with it.

Time-Tie-231 − That was not a stupid gift. It was a magnanimous, kind and thoughtful gift.. NTA. It is understandable that you are hurt to be excluded from your brother's birthday celebration. Your SIL sounds like a n**ty piece of work. So judgemental!. Your brother is an AH for tolerating her horrible behaviour.. EDIT - hang on - why DOES your brother tolerate her decision on your attendance at his birthday?

FliptrickBento − Feels like a solid NTA. SIL clearly doesn't want you around, but wants your money after she learnt what it would have been going towards.

bentscissors − Don’t bite the hand that feeds you free child-care-included Disney vacations. SIL FAFO *hard*. NTA, even your brother knows it.

ku_78 − She sees you as a threat. Marriage and parenting is hard. On the table of your brother’s life, she’s the vegetable and you’re the brownie with ice cream.

Gladtobealive2020 − NTA. SIL f.cked around and found out that there are consequences to her actions.

These Reddit opinions are fiery, but do they capture the full picture? Maybe the sister-in-law’s judgment hides her own insecurities, or perhaps OP’s bold move was the wake-up call she needed.

This tale of gifts and grudges leaves us pondering: where’s the line between standing your ground and escalating drama? OP’s decision to yank the Disney trip was a power move, but it also protected his self-respect. Families are messy, and sometimes love comes with tough choices. What would you do if you were snubbed by a relative but still expected to play Santa? Drop your thoughts below and let’s unpack this family saga together!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *