AITA for not eating food made for me on a date because I’m picky?

A cozy second date at a guy’s place—think movie night and home-cooked vibes—took a sharp turn when a single mom stared down a plate she couldn’t touch. The culprit? Mayo, a hard no for her egg allergy and a sensory minefield for her possible ARFID, a condition her daughter also navigates. She apologized profusely, but his flippant jab about “fixing” both her and her kid’s food issues lit a fuse, turning dinner into a dealbreaker.

The fallout didn’t end there—texts later, he doubled down, calling her childish and ignoring the allergy angle. Readers feel her gut-punch moment: wanting connection but facing judgment instead. Was she wrong to snap, or was his pushiness a red flag too big to ignore? This isn’t just about mayo—it’s about respect, boundaries, and what makes a spark worth chasing. Let’s dig into this dinner disaster and sort it out.

‘AITA for not eating food made for me on a date because I’m picky?’

Talk about a recipe for disaster—serving an allergen to someone who’s clear about their limits is a rookie move, but dismissing their kid’s condition? That’s a hard pass. This mom’s refusal to eat mayo-laden food wasn’t pickiness; it was self-preservation, backed by a severe egg allergy and likely ARFID, a real disorder tied to sensory issues, not whims. Her date’s “get over it” attitude, plus his dig at her daughter’s similar struggles, shows a lack of empathy that’s glaring for a second date.

ARFID’s no joke—studies show it affects up to 5% of kids and adults, often linked to autism, making certain foods physically distressing (https://www.nationaleatingdisorders.org/arfid). His push to “fix” them ignores medical reality, risking harm. Add in his post-date texts calling her childish, and it’s clear he’s more about control than connection.

Psychologist Dr. Susan Albers, an eating disorder expert, says, “Respecting food boundaries builds trust—dismissing them breaks it” (https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/comfort-cravings/2023/08/food-boundaries). Here, his apology fell flat when he kept blaming her, not his own oversight. Forcing food on someone allergic or averse isn’t quirky—it’s reckless.

Ditch the third date—this guy’s shown he won’t listen, a dealbreaker for a mom prioritizing her daughter’s safety. Focus on partners who respect your health and your kid’s needs, no questions asked. If guilt lingers, a therapist can help unpack ARFID’s impact. Readers, ever had a date ignore a dealbreaker like this? How do you spot the keepers from the clunkers early on?

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s serving up a buffet of hot takes on this dining-room drama, and they’re not holding back. Here’s the tastiest selection, dished with a sprinkle of humor to keep it zesty. These Redditors are cooking with fire, but are they plating up truth or just spicing things up? Let’s see what’s worth savoring.

This mayo-fueled mess proves a single dish can sink a date when respect’s off the menu. The mom stood her ground, protecting her health and her daughter’s dignity, but her date’s pushy vibe and blame game left a bitter aftertaste. It’s a reminder that boundaries aren’t up for debate—especially when it’s about safety. Ever had a date cross a line that made you rethink the whole vibe? Share your stories—what’s the reddest flag you’ve dodged, and how’d you walk away? Let’s chew on this one together.