AITA for not apologizing to my girlfriend’s sister and getting us kicked out the wedding?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In the whirlwind of wedding planning, where tulle and tantrums often collide, one man found himself at odds with his girlfriend’s sister, the bride-to-be. Her endless demands—midnight cupcake runs, last-minute dress shop visits—had his girlfriend running on fumes. Exasperated, he whisked her away for a phone-free week of peace, only to return to a bridezilla’s wrath.

Uninvited from the wedding and facing a demand for a public apology, he stands his ground, leaving his girlfriend heartbroken. This Reddit tale dives into the chaos of family loyalty and wedding stress, prompting readers to wonder: is he wrong for refusing to grovel, or is the sister’s reign of terror out of bounds?

‘AITA for not apologizing to my girlfriend’s sister and getting us kicked out the wedding?’

My girlfriend's older sister is getting married and I get that she's anxious about her wedding day but I don't feel like that gives her the right to boss around people the way that she does.. It's nonstop - 'Get this, get that. Go do this, go do that.'

I don't think she likes me very much because while everyone on her side of the family is running around trying to make sure that she has the 'perfect day' I'll help when I can. I'm not going out of my way to do that. And because of that I think she started punishing my girlfriend.

She would call at all hours of the night, have my girlfriend rushing over to her place or running errands. And of course I'm not just going to be letting my girlfriend drive around half-asleep so most of the time *I'm* the one driving her.

And it's stupid stuff that could be done in the morning - 'Oh, I heard about this spot that designs wedding dresses and I just want to check it out and compare prices.' So a few weeks ago, my girlfriend came home toward, almost collapsing, and her sister called her to ask her if she could go to the store and bring her some cupcakes 🤦‍♂️.

I told my girlfriend to rest and I'd do it. So I went to the store, bought the cupcakes, brought them to her and I told her, 'Look, your sister and I are a little tired of all this running errand, so I'm taking her out of town for awhile.' And I did. We didn't go too, too far.

I just took her to a hotel a few hours from where we live (no phones) and we just spent a week of walking around and relaxation. When we got back, the older sister was *ballistic*. She had told the family that we had been ignoring her calls on purpose, and then she said because we weren't contributing any help we were no longer invited to the wedding.

I didn't care, but my girlfriend broke down, so I told her family that it was my fault - that I had taken her out of town for awhile. But the sister recently told my girlfriend she doesn't care and that she isn't reinviting her until I publicly apologize to her.. Nuh-uh. Not doing it.. AITA?

Wedding bells can sometimes sound like battle cries, and this story proves it. The Reddit user prioritized his girlfriend’s well-being, but his blunt delivery—calling out the sister’s demands—lit a fuse. The sister’s reaction, uninviting them and demanding a public apology, reeks of control, while the girlfriend’s distress shows the emotional toll of family conflict.

ADVERTISEMENT

Psychologist Dr. Terri Orbuch explains, “Wedding stress can amplify controlling behaviors, especially when family dynamics are strained”. Research shows 40% of couples report family tension during wedding planning. The sister’s “bridezilla” behavior, while not uncommon, crosses boundaries by punishing her sister for needing a break.

This highlights a broader issue: weddings often test family boundaries. The user could soften the rift by acknowledging the sister’s stress while standing firm on his girlfriend’s needs. Mediation or a calm talk might help.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit jumped in with a mix of cheers for the user’s stand and sympathy for his girlfriend’s plight, all sprinkled with bridezilla jabs. Here’s the crowd’s take, served with a side of sass:

iaincaradoc - NTA. Classic Bridezilla.

ADVERTISEMENT

Idgiethreadgoode86 - NTA Sounds like the sister has a major case of Bridezilla syndrome. And asking for cupcakes...what does that have to do with the wedding? Sounds like she is just plain bossy to begin with and is now using her wedding as an excuse.

[Reddit User] - Nta but you’re girlfriend might really want to go to the wedding and maybe it might be worth apologizing just to make her happy

ADVERTISEMENT

ksun427 - NTA, just because she is getting married doesn't mean she gets to boundary stomp or expect your girlfriend to drop everything she is doing to run errands for her.  Your girlfriend needed a break and you took her somewhere so that she could get it. You shouldn't have to apologize for taking care of your girlfriend's well being.. As far as her sister goes in the Immortal words of Taylor Swift, 'You need to calm down.'

GothPenguin - NTA. You prioritized your girlfriend’s well being over a bridezilla.

[Reddit User] - NTA. This is a tough one. On the one hand, it's wonderful that you're being an advocate to your bullied girlfriend. On the other hand, what does your girlfriend want? Does she want you to apologize so she can go to this wedding that she's essentially slaved over? Is this kind of odd behaviour for her sister or is it normal?

ADVERTISEMENT

throwaway0413589874 - NTA. DO NOT apologize and please tell your GF not to. Yes it is her sister, but at some point enough is enough. Your GF needs to tell her sister that going out of town for a couple days to get some rest is OK,

and since she has helped out so much, she deserves it. She should also remind her sister that being invited to a wedding and/or being in the wedding party doesn't require middle of the night phone calls, going to get her cupcakes.

It means helping with the guestlist, going shopping to look at dresses during normal business hours. If she wants to be a spoiled brat, let her. If you bow down now, she will never realize the severity of her behavior, although she seems like the type who is like this any way.

ADVERTISEMENT

OilSeeYouL8er - ESH you spoke for your girlfriend saying you were both tired of it and telling the sister you were going away because of her. Why on earth would you not just do the trip instead of drag your girlfriend into the mud

nonotReallyyyy - INFO If she was asking your girlfriend (her sister), why can't your girlfriend say something if it bothered her? Why did you have to intervine?

electricgirl826 - I’m not gonna make a verdict but you sound a bit controlling. “And of course I’m not going to be letting her drive” if it is nighttime you are both tired so you just sound controlling. I feel like there may be more to this story....

ADVERTISEMENT

Reddit’s dishing out shade, but are they on point, or missing the deeper family drama?

This Reddit user’s clash with a bridezilla sister exposes the messy intersection of wedding mania and family loyalty. His refusal to apologize keeps the couple uninvited, leaving his girlfriend torn. Is he right to hold his ground, or should he swallow his pride for her sake? What would you do when faced with a family member’s over-the-top demands? Share your stories or advice—how do you navigate wedding chaos

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *