AITA for not allowing my BF to use my car to bring his ex and her kid to the ER?
In the stillness of a late-night living room, lit only by the soft glow of a lamp, a couple’s quiet evening unravels with a single phone call. A 27-year-old woman listens, her jaw tightening, as her boyfriend’s ex, a figure from a turbulent past, pleads for a ride to the ER for her sick child.
With a history of boundary violations and closer alternatives available, the woman swiftly refuses to lend her car, suspecting a manipulative ploy. The ex’s hostile texts and mutual friends’ accusations of insensitivity follow, turning a personal boundary into a public feud. As tensions simmer, the woman questions: was her refusal heartless, or a justified stand against a calculated intrusion?
‘AITA for not allowing my BF to use my car to bring his ex and her kid to the ER?’
This late-night drama unfolds like a thriller—past promises clashing with present suspicions. The OP’s refusal to lend her car to her boyfriend’s ex, who has a history of manipulative behavior, is rooted in distrust, especially with the ex’s sudden reappearance after two years. The ex’s aggressive texts only heighten the tension.
The ex’s choice to call the OP’s boyfriend first, despite closer options, raises red flags. As psychologist Dr. Susan Forward notes, “Manipulative individuals often exploit emotional triggers to control others.” The OP’s boundary—protecting her car and peace—is valid, particularly given the ex’s boundary violations, like repeatedly obtaining the boyfriend’s number.
This reflects broader issues: ex-partners sometimes use emergencies to reinsert themselves. The OP should document the harassment for potential legal steps, like a restraining order, and discuss mutual friends’ role in leaking contact info.
Check out how the community responded:
Reddit’s takes are as heated as a late-night ER waiting room! Here’s what the community had to say:
![[Reddit User] − NTA. This really does sound like a ploy to get your BF to come see her. If she really is concerned for her and her child’s health then she would have just gone to the ER herself instead since as you said it’s only 10 minutes from where she is and other people could much easily have taken her.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/265176c-06.png)
These opinions sizzle, but do they clarify the drama or just stir the pot?
This ER clash leaves us wondering: was the OP wrong for guarding her car and boundaries, or was the ex’s plea a manipulative tactic? Trust and past betrayals can tangle like phone cords. What would you do if an ex tried to pull you back into their drama under the guise of an emergency? Share your thoughts and experiences below!
