AITA for moving in with my dad’s “affair baby”, ie my sister, and not asking her to leave or hide in her room so my mom can visit without seeing her?
In a cozy apartment filled with laughter and sisterly banter, two young women built a home together, their bond defying a painful family secret. For one Reddit user, moving in with her half-sister—the child of her father’s affair—was a joyful step, but it stirred old wounds for her mother.
Expecting the sister to vanish during visits, the mother’s hurt clashed with the daughter’s loyalty to her newfound sibling. What seemed like a simple roommate decision spiraled into a test of boundaries and forgiveness. This heartfelt story pulls readers into a tangle of love, betrayal, and family ties, asking: can a daughter honor her sister without dishonoring her mom?
‘AITA for moving in with my dad’s “affair baby”, ie my sister, and not asking her to leave or hide in her room so my mom can visit without seeing her?’
Family secrets can cast long shadows, and this Reddit user’s story illuminates the fallout. By choosing to live with her half-sister, she embraced a bond her mother sought to erase, creating friction. The mother’s demand to hide the sister reflects unresolved pain from her husband’s betrayal, unfairly aimed at an innocent child.
Dr. Susan Heitler, a family therapist, notes, “Blaming a child for a parent’s infidelity displaces anger and delays healing”. Studies show 50% of spouses struggle with trust post-affair, often projecting onto others. The mother’s insistence on erasing the sister’s presence burdens her daughter with her own unresolved grief.
This taps into broader issues of blended family dynamics and forgiveness. The user’s refusal to hide her sister honors their bond but risks alienating her mother. Therapy could help the mother process her pain separately. Meeting outside the apartment might ease visits.
Take a look at the comments from fellow users:
Reddit rallied with fiery support for the user, tossing shade at her mother’s misplaced anger with a side of humor. Here’s the crowd’s take on this family drama:
Reddit’s got her back, but are they seeing the full picture of this tangled family web?
This Reddit user’s choice to live with her half-sister has cracked open old wounds, pitting her loyalty to a sibling against her mother’s pain. Refusing to hide her sister, she’s drawn a line, but at what cost? Is she right to stand firm, or should she bend for her mom’s sake? Share your thoughts—how would you navigate a family divided by a parent’s past mistakes?
