AITA for meeting up with a girl I met on my bachelor/stag party?

Fresh from a broken engagement, a man finds himself in a European city, laughing with a woman he met at his bachelor party abroad. His ex-fiancée’s controlling ways had eroded his confidence, but this new connection sparks joy. They met innocently during his stag night, sharing photos, and reconnected only after he was single.

Now, their chemistry hints at something more, but he wonders if their meeting’s context makes him wrong. Is pursuing this new path a fair shot at happiness, or a misstep tied to his past? This tale of freedom and fresh starts questions how past relationships shape new beginnings.

‘AITA for meeting up with a girl I met on my bachelor/stag party?’

I’ll try and keep this brief. Was engaged to a girl for a while. Not a happy relationship, all your typical red flag behaviours (very controlling, huge tantrums for minor things, personal insults and the general degradation of my self confidence). On my bachelor/stag party (abroad) I met a girl.

ADVERTISEMENT

We got on well and she WhatsApped herself some photos I’d taken on the night out. After the engagement was broken off I was feeling low. I texted the girl for some conversation and we got on well. I told her I wanted to visit more places. She wanted to come with.

We eventually met up in a European city and had a great time, agreeing to do it again. My ex and I are totally over. Neither of us wanted to fix or resume the relationship. However, AITA for meeting up and potentially starting a relationship with a girl I met on my own bachelor/stag party?

This post-breakup tale is a vibrant mix of liberation and lingering doubts. The man, free from a toxic engagement, pursued a connection that began innocently at his bachelor party. His hesitation stems from social optics, not actions, as he was single when meeting again. The ex’s controlling history justifies his need for a fresh start.

Psychologist Dr. Susan Newman notes, “Post-breakup, people often fear judgment for how they move on.” A 2022 study by the Journal of Social Psychology found 25% of new relationships face scrutiny over their origins, like this bachelor party meeting. His transparency about the timeline clears ethical concerns, though mutual friends might misjudge.

ADVERTISEMENT

This story highlights reclaiming personal happiness. He could avoid sharing details with his ex’s circle to minimize drama.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s takes on this romantic rebound are as lively as a stag night. Here’s what they had to say:

happylittlehena - I dont think so, people meet people all sorts of ways

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - I dont see any problems. You're free to do as you please, bud. You dont need permission to spend time with this girl or any girl for that matter. Enjoy yourself.

ocelotwildlyxx - I mean, I can see how your ex would be upset about this and may assume more happened on your stag party so be ready for that, but that's kind of her problem at this point. She has no claim over you and you're broken up. Go for it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sometimes one of the best things in order to get over someone is to have fun with someone else and remind yourself that you can. You're not the a**hole, unless of course you were actually emotionally cheating on your stag party, but that's in the past anyway and it sounds like she was kind of emotionally abusive and those things get gray in that situation anyway, imo.

Gaoler86 - Not the a**hole on one major condition, that nothing happened before the break-up. If thats the case then youbare a free man and have done nothing wrong. Even if this new girl was part of the reason for the break-up,

ADVERTISEMENT

you clearly were not completely happy in your previous relationship and meeting someone you feel better suited to is a good reason to break up. However, if you hooked up with this new girl whilst still in the previous relationship you are a major a**hole.

[Reddit User] - NTA. Youre single and you can see whoever you want, regardless of how you met them. Although I wouldn't rub it in your ex's face that you met her on your stag do: while it doesn't make you an a**hole,

ADVERTISEMENT

I can understand why she would be upset about you meeting someone that way which could make her second-guess why you broke up (she may think you cheated and may refuse to take responsibility for any part she had in the breakdown of your relationship)/might make you look like a d**k to any mutual friends.

jefuchs - Every post on this sub:. Headline: 'I'm the biggest a**hole!'. Text: 'Nope. Didn't do anything wrong, but made you click!'

ADVERTISEMENT

metasploiter - NTA as long as you’re being honest about your timeline.

[Reddit User] - Not enough info.. The engagement was broken off, how it was broken off is the important bit.. Because of the girl you met = A**hole. Any other reason = Not the A**hole Truthfully though, either way... Does it really matter that much? I don't believe that it does, and it's not something you should beat yourself up over. Good luck to you. I hope it works out and I hope that you're able to find the happiness your ex couldn't provide.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - NTA. Your ex may think you are, but if she does, it’s her problem. Take care of your own happiness, neighbour.

[Reddit User] - No. You’re fine. Enjoy your life and be happy.

ADVERTISEMENT

These reactions carry spark, but do they fully capture the balance of personal freedom and social perceptions?

This story of a post-breakup rendezvous probes the heart of moving on. The man’s meeting with a woman from his bachelor party, after escaping a toxic engagement, was a bid for joy, not betrayal. Yet, the context invites scrutiny from those tied to his ex. He owes no one his happiness, but discretion might ease tensions. Have you ever faced judgment for how you started a new chapter? Share your thoughts—what’s the line between owning your freedom and dodging drama?

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *