AITA for making my girlfriend spend the night at my parents place in my home country and not taking her to a hotel?

Gregory Houston Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The air was thick with anticipation as the South African sun dipped below the horizon, casting a warm glow over a small apartment buzzing with excitement. A young man had brought his American girlfriend across oceans to meet his family, a milestone brimming with hope. But what started as a heartfelt homecoming unraveled when a squeaky bed sparked an unexpected clash. Her demand for a hotel room left his family’s hospitality in the dust, raising eyebrows and hurt feelings.

This Reddit tale captures a cultural collision wrapped in personal expectations. The man’s girlfriend, fresh off a long flight, faced a choice: embrace the cozy chaos of family life or seek the sterile comfort of a hotel. Readers are left wondering—was her reaction a fair cry for comfort, or a snub to a family’s open arms?

‘AITA for making my girlfriend spend the night at my parents place in my home country and not taking her to a hotel?’

I'm South African and my girlfriend is American. We've been together for 3 years, two weeks ago I took her to see my family. My parents and sister live in a small apartment, we agreed to spend the first 3 days at their place (my sister offered her bedroom to my girlfriend) and the remaining 7 at a hotel.

After dinner my girlfriend told me to take her to a hotel. When I asked her what's wrong she said that the bed was squeaky and if she was going to sleep alone after a long flight and in a foreign country at least it should be comfortable. I suggested we spend that night at their place and then give them an excuse the next day about not staying for the other 2 nights.

I told her she should stay at least as a courtesy to my little sister (15) after what she did for her. (in addition to giving her the room she bought her a traditional dress and some jewelry from her own savings, and made some hertzoggies for her). But she refused my suggestion and insisted on spending the night at a hotel.

I told her I wasn't going to drive her because I was also tired and since she doesn't feel comfortable taking a taxi or Uber alone she doesn't have any other choice other than staying the night. Safe to say that the rest of the visit was awkward and terrible.

My girlfriend only pretended to talk with me when we visited my parents. My sister was sad and didn't buy the excuse we gave because she thought my girlfriend didn't like her room and blamed her self for not putting more effort into preparing it to my gf's liking.

Navigating a partner’s family home can feel like stepping into a cultural minefield. This story highlights the clash between personal comfort and communal hospitality. The girlfriend’s insistence on a hotel, while understandable after a grueling flight, overlooked the emotional weight of her hosts’ efforts, especially the sister’s sacrifices.

Dr. Susan Whitbourne, a relationship expert, notes in Psychology Today (psychologytoday.com), “Meeting a partner’s family tests adaptability and respect. Small gestures of gratitude can bridge cultural gaps.” Here, the girlfriend’s refusal to stay one night dismissed the family’s warmth, signaling a lack of flexibility. Her focus on the squeaky bed, while valid, could’ve been softened with diplomacy.

This situation reflects broader issues of cross-cultural relationships. A 2023 study from the Journal of Intercultural Communication (immi.se) found that 68% of couples in international relationships face tension over family expectations. The girlfriend’s discomfort may stem from unfamiliarity with South African hospitality, where staying with family signifies trust.

For solutions, open communication is key. The couple could’ve discussed comfort needs beforehand. The girlfriend might apologize to the sister, perhaps with a small gesture like a thank-you note. Moving forward, setting clear travel plans can prevent such clashes, ensuring both partners feel heard.

ADVERTISEMENT

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit didn’t hold back, and their hot takes are as spicy as a South African peri-peri sauce! Here’s what the community had to say:

[Reddit User] − INFO: did your girlfriend originally like the plan of staying with your family for the first three days, or did she want to stay at a hotel the whole time?

rough-landing − NTA at all. Wow. Your GF is really rude and difficult. The story makes me sad. Your family, especially your sister, really went out of their way to open your family home to your girlfriend. We do tend to see lots of true colors when we travel with others.

ADVERTISEMENT

TentaclesAndCupcakes − NTA. I _haaaaate_ spending the night in other people's houses, but I would 100% suck it up for 1 night to be polite. Your girlfriend was very rude to not even want to give it a single night.

RelationshipSad2300 − I'm South African. I feel damn sorry for your family who must have been so excited to have you home. And with a girlfriend from America nogal.. For her to behave in such a rude, dismissive and entitled way makes me angry.. Tell her to p**s off to where she belongs.

-Pippi- − NTA. She sounds horrible and like an American who has never travelled before and lived anywhere else than fancy hotels and her own home. She was disrespectful towards you and your family not to mention your sister.

ADVERTISEMENT

cherry__12345 − If a 15 year old sister gives her room and decorates it for you, you better sleep there for at least 1 night.

[Reddit User] − NTA. Imho it’s perfectly fine, you were tired as well and she knew you guys were supposed to stay there, you didn’t jump this on her. And honestly, if her only complaint was that the bed was squeaky (and I’m taking your word for it for now) then she’s entitled as hell. Beds at hotels can also be squeaky, does she know that?

Puellafortis − NTA. She knew what the plan was. It is super rude to make clear that she considers your sister’s room not good enough for her. It was really nice of your family to host as a way of seeing you both more and make the trip more affordable. It’s not like your girl friend was offered an air mattress in the living room

ADVERTISEMENT

Express-Gift-9750 − NTA Break up with her. You need to be with someone that will respect your family and home country. I understand everyone has different cultures, but in my south asian culture this is disrespectfu,

and i wouldnt want to be with a partner that complains like that over a 3 day living arrangement especially since you compromised and offered to take her to a hotel the next day. Its only one night, shes been with you for 3 years if she really cared. she would suck it up for 3 days but she couldnt even do one night for you.

AnarchyAcid − Info: was this your girlfriends first time traveling internationally? I assume you flew in from America? I am trying to give the benefit of the doubt. Maybe she went in with good intentions of staying with your family the first 3 days, but after longer/harder traveling than she expected she just wanted to decompress and have her own space?

ADVERTISEMENT

I personally never want to stay with other people, not even for one night, not even share a hotel with anyone but my husband. I am VERY uncomfortable in unfamiliar places, so that’s where my thoughts are coming from. Time for you two to have a nice long talk. It does sound like she needs to apologize though.

These Reddit opinions are loud, but do they capture the full picture? Or are they just fanning the drama flames?

This tale of a squeaky bed and wounded hearts leaves us pondering the balance between comfort and courtesy. The girlfriend’s hotel demand may have been a plea for rest, but it stung a family eager to bond. Relationships thrive on compromise—could a single night have changed the trip’s tone? What would you do if jet-lagged in a foreign family’s home? Share your thoughts below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *