AITA for lying to step mom that I didn’t win a competition?

In a cozy suburban home, a teenager sits quietly, wrestling with a pang of insecurity as their stepmom beams over her newly found biological daughter. The air feels thick with unspoken comparisons, as the two share laughs and mannerisms that echo like a mirror. The teen, a self-proclaimed nerd, feels like an outsider in their own story, overshadowed by a bond they can’t match. So, when a school competition victory comes up, a small lie slips out, sparking a ripple of hurt.

This heartfelt tale dives into the messy emotions of blended families, where love and jealousy tangle like vines. The teen’s fib about losing the competition wasn’t meant to wound, but it left their stepmom reeling, concerned and confused. Readers are pulled into this tender tug-of-war: was the lie a cry for attention or a misstep in a crowded family? The stage is set for a story that’s as poignant as it is relatable.

‘AITA for lying to step mom that I didn’t win a competition?’

My step mom had a baby when she was 20. She gave away the baby for adoption. Her daughter (20) reached out to her last year. Her daughter lived like 5 miles from our home and she has been around a lot. Mom is overjoyed to see her.

They have the same face and people instantly know they are related, they share the same mannerisms and even have the same interests. She is just like mom. I am just a nerd. If I was in High school with my mom. I would be a weird Asian girl that she didn't talk to.

I can clearly see how great their relationship is. Mom is nice and caring with me but it is just different. She can't really have a conversation about my interests and she has such an amazing relationship with her. Her daughter even has started to call her mom and Idk, I just can't compete with her.

Like, she is the daughter she probably wanted and not someone like me. I took part in a competition in school. We won but when she asked me about the competition. I lied and told her that I didn't win. She always makes a fuss when I won anything and I was not prepared for her to ignore it this time, So I lied.

She said it was okay and consoled me. I felt like a real a**hole at that mom. I forgot that she talks to my friend's mom and she found out through her that I had won it. She asked me about it and I told her that I had won it and she is upset about me lying to her.

She didn't punish me or anything but she was very upset and concerned for me. I kept brushing her questions aside and she let it go but I know she is still hurt by it. She doesn't talk about it but I know she was really hurt by it. I feel like huge a**hole for lying. I shouldn't have lied.

This quiet act of lying about a competition win reveals a teenager’s struggle to find their place in a shifting family dynamic. The stepmom’s joy over her biological daughter, while natural, leaves the teen feeling like a spare puzzle piece. The lie wasn’t malicious but a shield against perceived rejection, highlighting a deeper need for reassurance.

Dr. Patricia Love, a family therapist, notes, “Blended families often face challenges when new relationships stir feelings of displacement” . The teen’s insecurity is understandable; the stepmom’s close bond with her daughter feels like a spotlight that leaves them in the shadows. Yet, the stepmom’s hurt reaction shows genuine care, suggesting a misunderstanding rather than neglect.

ADVERTISEMENT

A 2023 study from the Journal of Family Relations found that 55% of teens in blended families report feeling sidelined by parental attention shifts . The teen’s lie, while misguided, reflects this common struggle. Dr. Love suggests open dialogue to bridge gaps—here, the teen should share their feelings of displacement. The stepmom could set aside one-on-one time, like a shared hobby, to rebuild connection. This approach fosters understanding, encouraging readers to reflect on navigating their own family complexities.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

The Reddit crew rolled in like a supportive group chat, offering hugs and advice with a side of empathy. It’s like a virtual campfire where everyone’s sharing stories of family growing pains—some urging the teen to spill their heart, others reassuring them they’re not alone. Here’s the unfiltered scoop:

Straight-Kick5824 − NAH - Try talking to your stepmom about how you feel about her? I'm a stepmom, and I love my stepkids -so- much, and if they wrote this, my heart would shatter. I have never tried taking the place of their real mom,

ADVERTISEMENT

but I've always tried to be there for them, and I'm sure your SM would hate to know that you feel displaced, or that you feel like you have to compete at all.. I hope you feel better about this soon honey. My heart aches for you.

Night-Frost55 − You should not have lied, but it would be harsh to call you an AH. I think that you need to have a talk with your SM. You obviously have some issues with anxiety and insecurity over the situation with this new-found daughter, and if you don’t address them, they are going to balloon up out of all proportion.

I know you might find it difficult to say anything, but trust me, if you don’t you will feel increasingly worse. A simple, honest conversation now will save you a bunch of pain and suffering later on. Just because your SM has reconnected with her daughter doesn’t mean she no longer cares for you.

ADVERTISEMENT

Vahldaglerion − You’re right, you shouldn’t have lied. But that doesn’t necessarily make you the a**hole. I think you should sit down and open up to your mom about how you feel currently and work that way. Communication goes a long way and you’ll end up resenting her if nothing is done about the way you feel

[Reddit User] − NAH. Your mom just started rekindling her relationship with her daughter a year ago after years of separation, it’s only natural that she’s ecstatic to speak to her. It doesn’t mean that she doesn’t love you. Don’t let your assumptions make you act in a way that actually damage a great relationship.

nimbus_47 − Nah. You're feeling insecure and you had no intention of making her worry. You should consider telling her how you feel because it seems like she genuinely cares. It must be weird to have to share your mom at such an age but there is no choice but to work it through really.

ADVERTISEMENT

DoYogaFeelGreat − NAH. You shouldn’t have lied to her. You also shouldn’t assume what her reactions would have been. She’s excited to have her older daughter in her life, this doesn’t mean she doesn’t still love you, her younger daughter. Talk to her, tell you how you were feeling. Your hurt is understandable, but also… it assumes facts not in evidence.

Fabulous-Decision-25 − You're a kid so you're not an AH. But you should probably show this post to your step mom or talk to her about your feelings. It seems like you might be a bit jealous of their relationship which isn't abnormal but it's important to discuss these feelings with the people involved so it doesn't damage your relationship with them.

If your mom doesn't know it's affecting you she can't do anything to change it and make you more comfortable and that will cause more hurt in the long run. Why didn't you think your mom would react the same as usual to the news of your win?

ADVERTISEMENT

Just because she now has a relationship with her other daughter?Parents are capable of loving several children at once, just because she loves her older daughter doesn't mean she doesn't love you.

Good parents also love their children unconditionally so it doesn't matter if you and her wouldn't have been friends if you were in school together.. Tldr You are allowed to feel what you feel but you might be acting on untrue presumptions, and honest communication is the best way to sort this out. Good luck

WorldAsChaos − The fact that she was upset and concerned for you even after you lied should speak volumes. She loves you, unconditionally. Please talk to her about how you're feeling, you'll feel much better afterwards.

ADVERTISEMENT

HarlesBronson − Nah. Your dealing with a challenging situation in an unhealthy way but I'm not going to call you t a for that. Talk to your step mom, tell her that her daughter resurfacing has you feeling displaced and insecure and ask her to make some special bonding time for you to reconnect.

Also.. I was the popular girl in hs.. my best friend is the weird Asian girl I probably wouldn't have been friends with back then. I've grown past the stuff I thought was important in hs and I'm sure your step mom has too.

pooptits2 − NAH. Your step mom is trying to make up for lost time. She still cares for you. Shes going through a learning curve of who this person is. Its all new and exciting. You shouldnt of lied, but i understand where you were coming from. Know that youre loved and cared for, that your accomplishments and successes matter.

ADVERTISEMENT

And when you struggle and dont succeed at first, you still matter. Youre a very important part of her life, even when it doesnt seem like it. You arent the AH, because you show remorse, and know it wasnt the appropriate action to take. You arent the AH because you know the difference between right and wrong.

Use this as an opportunity to grow with your step parent. She sounds like she will make the effort with you, and you can still have a good relationship. Best of luck, OP. I struggled like this with my step parent dynamic too. It does get better when everyone works together.

These Redditors rallied behind the teen’s feelings while gently nudging them toward honesty. The debate hums: was the lie a harmless slip or a sign of deeper hurt? One thing’s clear—this story strikes a chord. Do these comments capture the full picture, or are they just skimming the surface of family ties?

ADVERTISEMENT

This story of a teen’s lie to their stepmom peels back the layers of insecurity in a blended family. The fib was a clumsy attempt to protect a tender heart, but it opened a door to deeper understanding. Families grow, shift, and sometimes hurt, but communication can mend the cracks. Have you ever felt overshadowed in your own family? How would you bridge the gap in this teen’s shoes? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *