AITA for letting my kids call my late wife’s parents their grandparents?

In a cozy suburban home, where toys scatter the living room like confetti, a widower navigates the delicate balance of love, loss, and new beginnings. Seven years after his wife’s tragic passing, he’s built a vibrant family with his adopted twins, weaving in the warmth of his late wife’s parents as their grandparents. But when his girlfriend moves in, her discomfort with this bond sparks a heartfelt dilemma, stirring emotions as tender as a fresh bruise. Readers can’t help but wonder: can love for a new partner coexist with cherished ties to a past life?

This story unfolds with raw honesty, pulling at heartstrings while posing a universal question about family and loyalty. It’s a tale of chosen connections, where the widower’s decision to embrace his late wife’s parents as family for his kids clashes with his girlfriend’s insecurities, setting the stage for a poignant exploration of blended family dynamics.

‘AITA for letting my kids call my late wife’s parents their grandparents?’

My wife, F, passed away suddenly 7 years ago while she was pregnant with our first child. Was obviously completely devastating. We had been together for 6 years + close friends for another 5 before that, so I was pretty close with her family.

After she died, my MIL told me that no matter what happened they’d always consider me family and would always be there for me if I needed anything. 3 years after her death I ended up fostering twin siblings as a single parent, who I have since adopted. They were 3 at the time.

As a first time parent, my mom helped me out, as did F’s parents. It started off pretty small, with them just coming by to drop off food and small gifts but eventually they really ended up bonding with the kids, so much so that I decided they may as well be honorary grandparents to the kids, as I only have my mom and I thought the more people in their life who care about them, the better.

They’ve honestly been amazing grandparents to the kids and my kids really love them. Anyway, about 2 years after I got the kids, I met my current girlfriend, L (currently 33F). Recently, after ~2 years of dating, I asked her to move in with me and she moved in 2 weeks ago. I love her and she’s great with the kids.

However, the kids’ birthday was this week and F’s parents stopped by to drop off presents for the kids and wish them, which was the first time she met them. Afterwards, he told me she thought it was inappropriate for me to “make” the kids call them grandma and grandpa,

and that it showed that I was clearly still not over F and that I saw her as their mom, and what else could be the reason I treated her parents like their grandparents. She said that the attachment I had with F’s family was unhealthy and I was pretending like she was still my wife and the mother of my kids,

and it was bad and confusing for the kids and that it makes it difficult for her to connect with them and see herself as a parent to them because this makes her feel inadequate and like she’s competing with F over kids F never even met. I don’t really see how it’s unhealthy or confusing as I rarely talk about F to them, least of all treating her as their mother.

They have got to the age where they’ve asked question about how I/they are related to their grandparents and I just tell them that we chose them to be part of our family, like how I chose them to be my kids. At this point my ex in laws have been part of my kids life for 4 years and I feel like it would be more damaging to try and cut them out now?

ADVERTISEMENT

But I CAN kind of see where she’s coming from and I don’t want to sabotage her bond with the kids either as they’ve become very close. Idk, was I the a**hole for letting them be grandparents to them, and for refusing to stop it now (and not even at least slowly distancing the kids from them, as L suggests I could try to do)?.

Edit/update:. Just wanted to clarify a few things: My wife and I never had biological kids, she died in an accident while pregnant, before the baby would’ve been viable. I saw a few people confused about this so wanted to clarify. The issue here is not them being non-biological.

ADVERTISEMENT

Thank you to the people who affirmed that family is family regardless of blood, but if that was her issue I would’ve never had any doubt that she’s the a**hole because I’m adopted, my kids are adopted, there are no blood relations here whatsoever. The issue that she has is specifically that by calling F’s parents the grandparents she feels like I’m treating F as their mother and am prioritising F over her.

• Obviously she knew my kids before we moved in together. My kids really get along well with her and look forward to seeing her and spend time with her. I would never have moved in with her if I thought she would be a bad parent to them, and she isn’t, independent of this - she’s just letting her insecurities about my late wife cloud her view.

ADVERTISEMENT

One of the main reasons I tried to see her point of view was that she was so good with them and I didn’t want the kids to lose their relationship with her either, but I see now that if they did, that’s her fault and something that’s out of my control. • People are acting like I was genuinely considering separating them. Like I said in the post, I’d already refused to do so or negotiate with her about this.

My kids will always come first for me and obviously my first instinct was to shut this down. But she made me feel like the a**hole for not being willing to budge at all on an issue that she was clearly very sensitive to, so I wanted to make sure that my first instinct was not the wrong one, which I am now reassured that it’s not.

ADVERTISEMENT

• At the end of the day, the core issue here is her being insecure about my relationship with my late wife. When making this post I was genuinely trying to see her point of view and thought maybe it was normal for her to feel this way, maybe I was the bad guy for not at least recognising how our close relationship with my late wife’s parents made her feel.

Now I see that obviously it’s not normal, and what’s unhealthy is not me still having a strong bond with people who have been in my life and supported me for 18 years but her feeling insecure and jealous of a woman who has been dead for 7. • I will be doubling down and telling her that the kids and my relationship with F’s parents is non negotiable,

and that I’m not choosing between her or them, I’m just maintaining two important relationships and if she has a problem then she’s the one choosing her insecurities over me and the kids. Some of you have recommended articles etc. that I will try to show her to get her to understand.

ADVERTISEMENT

• While it’s possible she may have specifically waited till after she moved in to press this issue, this was also the first time she’d ever met the grandparents and seen them interact with the kids and seen how close they really are, which I think is mainly what triggered this.

• I don’t think she’s a horrible, calculating, manipulative person like many people are suggesting, I think she’s just deeply insecure and not able to handle being in a relationship with a widower as well as she thought she was.

I think she thought that because my kids are not my wife’s biological kids that she could sweep my wife under the rug and pretend that she never existed, and my in laws being in the picture ruins that. But regardless of whether or not we had biological kids, F will always be a huge and important part of my life and she needs to understand that.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m not going to dump her but I’m going to make my position crystal clear and she can either be okay with it or choose to leave. • Thank you to everyone who commented and gave advice, it really helped to clear my head and see what the real issues are.

Navigating blended families can feel like walking a tightrope over a sea of emotions. The widower’s choice to maintain a close bond with his late wife’s parents reflects a deep commitment to his children’s well-being. Yet, his girlfriend’s discomfort highlights a common tension in relationships involving loss. According to Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, “Trust is built in very small moments” . Here, the girlfriend’s insecurity about the grandparents’ role risks eroding trust, as it pits her against an established family dynamic.

The widower’s situation underscores a broader issue: blending families requires embracing all connections, biological or chosen. His girlfriend’s push to distance the grandparents stems from her fear of competing with a ghost, but this overlooks the kids’ need for stability. A 2023 study from the Journal of Family Psychology found that children in blended families thrive with consistent, loving figures . Cutting ties could disrupt the twins’ sense of security, which the widower rightly prioritizes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Gottman’s advice on fostering trust applies here: open communication is key. The widower should validate his girlfriend’s feelings while firmly asserting the grandparents’ role. Couples therapy could help, offering tools to navigate insecurities without sacrificing family ties. By modeling mutual respect, the widower can show that love isn’t a zero-sum game, encouraging his girlfriend to build her own bond with the kids without erasing existing ones.

Ultimately, the widower’s stance is a masterclass in prioritizing children’s needs. His girlfriend must decide if she can embrace this expansive view of family.

See what others had to share with OP:

The Reddit crew dove into this family saga with gusto, serving up a mix of cheers and jeers that could rival a lively family reunion. Here’s what they had to say, unfiltered and brimming with conviction:

ADVERTISEMENT

Bambie-Rizzo − NTA but your girlfriend is. There is absolutely nothing wrong with anything you’ve done. She’s being manipulating and selfish. Your kids love them and they love your kids. Do not let her step in and ruin yours and yours kids’ relationship with your ex in laws. I say lose the girlfriend unless she apologizes.

[Reddit User] − NTA. How is this any different than if they were actually your biological children and your in laws were actually their grand parents?? What you gf is saying makes no sense at all. She’s just using it as a reason to alienate your late wife’s parents. She can connect with the kids in her own way that has nothing to do with either your late wife or her grand parents.

Moggetti − NTA. I am sorry to say it, but your GF sounds like a horrible, insecure, nightmare person. She’s trying to pathologize your loving relationship with your in-laws because she’s jealous. The fact that she waited to move in to express her creepy selfish opinions makes it worse. And she’s so incredibly self-involved that she wants to separate your children from their grandparents. How utterly vile.

ADVERTISEMENT

BaronVonMagnus − NTA. Enough people have explained why GFs out of line here that I don't need to. Instead I will say that you have a responsibility to protect your children, either by making sure GF straightens up her act or by getting rid of her. Fail to do so and you \*will\* be the a**hole.

MaximusIsKing − NTA.. Your girlfriend is projecting her own insecurities onto you.. You *chose* your children. F’s parents *chose* to take an active role in their lives. It’s not just a title they’ve proven to be grandparents.. And, you’ve *chosen* L to be your GF.

Try to explain to her again, how family is more than formal titles and arrangements, take out F would she have an issue? Probably not. She’s projecting and if she can’t talk herself off of this hill, I don’t think there’s much there to salvage because taking away your children’s grandparents is not fair to THEM. And their needs trump her insecurities.

ADVERTISEMENT

josiejo72 − NTA! I think the fact that your late wife's parents still treat you as part of their family is a beautiful thing. Your children deserve to have as many loving people in their life as possible. I think your girlfriend is being completely unreasonable.

It is unfair of her to ask you to distance yourself from people who have been in your life for as long as they have and been as loving and supportive as they have. Your girlfriend should spend more time creating a loving bond with your children instead of being upset over the children's relationship with others.

Pseudo-Data − NTA - by blood or by choice, they are family. Their relationship with your children is no bearing on your GFs relationship with them. GF can embrace the family dynamic or she can move on if it’s too much for her. Don’t punish your children and their grandparents for your GFs insecurities.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pod_Potato − NTA but I do have to wonder how you dated this woman for 2 years and she never had a problem with the kids grandparents until she moved in? I'm sorry to say that I think you need to put your foot down on this because 1) it sounds like a very healthy relationship between your kids,

and their 'grandparents' so why disrupt that for them? and 2) once the gf gets her way on this, I can guarantee that won't be where she stops with demands. It will always be something else to be jealous of or taking attention away from her. Definitely 🚩 🚩🚩🚩

bamf1701 − NTA. Family is not defined by blood, but by love.

ADVERTISEMENT

cautiousoptimzm − NTA in any respect whatsoever. Your GF has zero say in who loves your kids, even if WTE gilders of divorce and your wife (deeply sorry) we’re still alive. She’s not thinking of the best interest of your children at all here. Wow. What kind of “stepmother” demands the removal of loving grandparents to your kids?

These Redditors rallied behind the widower, praising his loyalty to his kids and their grandparents, while some roasted the girlfriend’s insecurities as a red flag. But do their fiery takes capture the full nuance, or are they just adding fuel to the drama?

This story reminds us that family is a tapestry woven from choice, love, and time—not just blood. The widower’s commitment to his kids’ happiness shines, but his girlfriend’s struggle shows how grief can cast long shadows. By standing firm, he’s teaching us that honoring the past doesn’t diminish the present. What would you do if you found yourself balancing a new love with cherished family ties? Share your thoughts and experiences below!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *