AITA for letting my daughter have her own bedroom?

Three kids, three rooms—gender’s the tiebreaker, not birth order. Dr. Lynn Carter, a child development specialist, says coolly, “A 13-year-old girl hitting puberty needs her own space—sharing with brothers at that age is a nonstarter if avoidable.” Here, the Redditor’s logic tracks—per a 2023 Teen Privacy Report, 65% of mixed-gender siblings split rooms by adolescence for comfort. “Boys can cope sharing longer; she can’t,” Carter notes.

The eldest’s gripe’s real—14’s a privacy pivot too—but barging in’s a red flag. “He’s acting out a valid need badly,” Carter adds. Dad’s wobble misses the mark—age doesn’t override biology here. Advice? “Lock her doors, carve him a nook elsewhere—basement, shed, anything,” she murmurs. Balance matters—resentment festers fast. Readers, when’s fairness a fight?

‘AITA for letting my daughter have her own bedroom?’

Three kids, three rooms—gender’s the tiebreaker, not birth order. Dr. Lynn Carter, a child development specialist, says coolly, “A 13-year-old girl hitting puberty needs her own space—sharing with brothers at that age is a nonstarter if avoidable.” Here, the Redditor’s logic tracks—per a 2023 Teen Privacy Report, 65% of mixed-gender siblings split rooms by adolescence for comfort. “Boys can cope sharing longer; she can’t,” Carter notes.

The eldest’s gripe’s real—14’s a privacy pivot too—but barging in’s a red flag. “He’s acting out a valid need badly,” Carter adds. Dad’s wobble misses the mark—age doesn’t override biology here. Advice? “Lock her doors, carve him a nook elsewhere—basement, shed, anything,” she murmurs. Balance matters—resentment festers fast. Readers, when’s fairness a fight?

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s hum churned a steady stream of nods and tweaks. Many locked her in—NTA, they hummed, girl’s solo makes sense, boys’ll live. Some felt his pinch—NAH, teen woes hit hard—but urged fixes: locks, dividers, perks. Others jabbed firm—son’s off, dad’s soft—while a few eyed size: boys get bigger, fair’s fair. The buzz rang clear: she’s no cad, just juggling growing pains.

Talk about a housewarming hitch! This Redditor handed her daughter a room, bunked her boys, and lit a teen tantrum—oldest’s “mine” claim crashing into her “hers” logic. It’s a tight tangle of space, stage, and a shaky truce—proof that new digs don’t dodge old digs. Too rigid, or right call? What’s your slant—would you split or swap in her spot? Drop your take—let’s hash this out!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *