AITA for kicking my wife out after I found out she cheated, even though she says it was “just emotional”?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A quiet evening shattered like glass when a 34-year-old man stumbled upon his wife’s secret: flirty, heartfelt texts to a coworker that crossed every line of trust. For six years, he believed their marriage was a fortress of love and honesty, but those messages—“I wish I could fall asleep next to you”—tore it apart. Kicking her out felt like the only move, but her tears and her family’s accusations have him second-guessing. Was he too harsh, or was her betrayal too deep?

This Reddit story is a raw plunge into love, betrayal, and the murky waters of “emotional” infidelity. As he grapples with a broken heart and a chorus of critics, we’re left wondering: can a marriage survive such a breach? Let’s dive into his pain, unpack the Reddit reactions, and hear an expert’s take on this gut-wrenching mess.

‘AITA for kicking my wife out after I found out she cheated, even though she says it was “just emotional”?’

I (34M) have been married to my wife (32F) for six years, together for nine. We’ve had what I thought was a stable, loving relationship. No major fights, good communication, shared values — or so I thought. A couple of weeks ago, I noticed she started acting... different. Guarded. Always on her phone. Jumping to shower when she got home. I trusted her, but my gut was screaming.

Last Thursday, while she was asleep, I looked at her messages (I know, not proud). That’s when I found them — dozens of messages between her and a coworker. Flirty, intimate, and clearly *more* than just friendship. Stuff like “I wish I could fall asleep next to you” and “You make me feel alive again.” Nothing explicitly s**ual, but emotionally, it felt worse somehow.

They talked about me — how I wouldn’t “understand her the way he does.” I confronted her the next day. She cried, admitted it, and insisted it was just “emotional,” that it never got physical, and that she was going through a “phase” of feeling unappreciated. I asked her why she didn’t just talk to *me* about that. She said she was scared I’d shut her down.

I told her to pack a bag and leave. I needed space. She begged me not to

Now I’m sitting alone in our apartment, questioning everything. I loved her. Still do. But I feel betrayed on a level I can’t describe. I don’t know if I overreacted. Part of me wonders if I’m letting pride ruin what could be fixed.. So... AITA for kicking her out after finding out about her emotional affair?

That gut-punch of betrayal? It’s real, and this man’s reeling from it. His wife’s emotional affair—intimate texts spilling her heart to a coworker—cracked the foundation of their marriage. Her claim it was “just emotional” doesn’t erase the secrecy or the sting, especially when she vented about him to her fling. His decision to kick her out? A raw reaction to a deep wound.

Emotional affairs can hurt as much as physical ones, often more. A 2021 study in Family Process found that 78% of couples view emotional infidelity as a serious breach, with trust harder to rebuild than after physical cheating. Her failure to address her feelings with him first screams poor communication, a red flag in any relationship.

Dr. Shirley Glass, a renowned infidelity expert, wrote, “An emotional affair becomes dangerous when it involves secrecy and emotional intimacy that displaces the partner” (source: Not Just Friends). This case fits the bill—her guarded phone and dismissive excuses amplify the betrayal. Asking her to leave was a boundary, not cruelty, giving him space to process.

For couples in this spot, experts urge open talks about needs and therapy to rebuild trust, if both commit. He’s justified in seeking answers, but her family’s attacks complicate things.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s warriors didn’t mince words, dishing out support, suspicion, and some fiery shade. Here’s the scoop from the community, with takes that hit hard and fast:

DreamExecutioner27 − NTA but if it wasn’t physical why was she rushing to the shower as soon as she got home?! Emotionally cheating hurts just as much as physically but I’m not so sure she didn’t cross both lines…

AdhesiveTeflon1 − NTA. You only caught her early enough before it did go physical.

No-Concentrate-8607 − NTAH- That would break my heart into a million pieces. I understand some couples don’t see cheating a deal breaker but not only do me and my husband do but emotional cheating is just as bad as physical.

Unfortunately I would maybe try to fix it but I know it would eat at me for the rest of my life unless I buried it deep or something. Deff wouldn’t want them to work at that same place anymore and I would insist if I decided to attempt to work things out.

RDDTLurker7 − NTA. She threw away the marriage when she emotionally cheated. Physical cheating was probably in the works. If you do end up divorcing, you can tell her “now you can be with the person that understands you.

LostInNothingBox − NTA. They definitely f**king. If not already then soon.. Oh and tell her sister to go f**k herself.

akillerofjoy − No, ChatGPT, you are NTA.

DittoDattoDoo − This is more than just flirting - if it was just mild flirting it would be forgivable. But this is a relationship. It may or may not have involved s**, but it was still a relationship. They were communicating regularly and she basically told this guy she liked him more than you. You’re correct that she needs to go. This is not acceptable.

sideof-extralemons − NTA. personally, an emotional affair would be way more hurtful than a purely physical one. you're not overacting at all. she's the one that fucked up. so if you need space from her, then you get to claim the apartment. some people would be able to move on with the relationship, some wouldn't. whatever group you're in is something to figure out.

but at this point she's already f**king up even more by downplaying the affair and being unsupportive. the problem isn't just the cheating; it's now also her reaction when it came out.. sorry this happened to you man

Worried-Cheek-3330 − thanks to all of you responding, it means a lot to know i have so many people that understand where im coming from. i have set up a date to final on a divorce. even though it has been a couple of hours i have had multiple calls and texts from her family members telling me i am in the wrong and i should hear her out.

they have called the police on me about 2 times already saying i abused her and raped her. im at my buddies house for the time being because she is trying to ruin my life all because i caught her cheating. again, thank you all for the support

Any-Expression2246 − Her sister knew and was probably egging it on. Probably because she has experience doing the same thing.

These Reddit zingers pack a punch, but do they nail the truth or just fan the flames? One thing’s clear: the crowd smells more than just texts, and her family’s drama isn’t helping her case.

From a loving marriage to a lonely apartment, this man’s story is a heart-wrenching dive into betrayal and tough calls. His wife’s “emotional” affair cut deep, and booting her out felt like his only shield. But with her family crying foul and his heart still tangled, was he right to draw the line, or is there room to mend? Reddit’s got his back, but love’s a messy battlefield. What would you do if you found those texts on your partner’s phone? Spill your thoughts below—let’s keep this convo burning!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *