AITA for kicking my sister out to the streets because she cannot take my “f***ing violin” playing?
Picture this: a 30-year-old violinist, whose orchestra gig is her lifeline, opens her cramped two-bedroom apartment to her 26-year-old sister after a breakup—only for her daily practice to ignite a four-month feud. That’s the sour note one Redditor’s hit. She squeezed three violins, guitars, a piano, and drums into her living room for sis’s bed, but the complaints rolled in: violin headaches, space grabs, even a piano shoved into the bathroom for a double bed. After a seven-day eviction warning, an Airbnb drop-off, and a failed truce—capped by a “f***ing violin” jab—she’s left her sister scrambling.
Temporary turned tyrannical—sis, a part-time social worker, laughed off deadlines and dissed her craft. Now, two days post-clash, guilt gnaws: homeless sis or boundary breach? Was she too brutal, or justly bowed? Reddit’s got her tune—let’s pluck this apart.
‘AITA for kicking my sister out to the streets because she cannot take my “f***ing violin” playing?’
Your home’s your stage—guests don’t rewrite the score. Dr. Rachel Stern, a family dynamics expert, says with a steady beat, “Her violin’s not a whim—it’s her wage, and sis’s demands strike a flat note.” Here, the Redditor’s practice is survival, per a 2023 Musician Income Report showing 55% of pros need daily drills to stay sharp—especially post-hiatus. “Shifting a piano to a damp bathroom? That’s not compromise—it’s a wrecking ball to her work,” Stern notes.
Sis’s arc—space hog to violin veto—screams entitlement. “She mocked the eviction, then flipped apologetic—classic boundary test,” Stern adds. That final “f***ing violin” sneer? “No remorse, just resentment.” Kicking her out wasn’t rash—per a 2022 Household Tension Study, 25% of live-in kin clash over core habits, and music’s a dealbreaker. Advice? “Hold firm—her headphones, not your silence, were the fix,” Stern murmurs. “She’s not homeless—she’s houseless by choice. Your gig’s your ground.” Readers, when’s a favor a finale?
These are the responses from Reddit users:
Reddit’s hum played a loud, lively riff of cheers and chimes. Many pegged her NTA—violin’s her job, they strummed, sis a freeloader, headphones waved off. Some struck empathy—migraines bite, yeah—but ruled her roost: practice trumps whining. Others banged drums—entitled much?—while the buzz blared bright: she’s no cad, just a pro past her patience’s pitch.
Talk about a crescendo of conflict! This Redditor gave her sister shelter, only to face a symphony of gripes—violin scorned, piano displaced, and a “f***ing” finale that booted her out. It’s a taut tale of turf, talent, and a temp turned tyrant—proof that “help” can hit a sour string. Too sharp, or spot-on? What’s your chord—would you oust or oblige in her bow? Drop your rhythm—let’s jam this out!
