AITA for kicking my brothers GF out?

Coming home to find an uninvited guest camped out in your apartment sounds like a sitcom plot—until it’s your reality. For one guy, his brother’s girlfriend turned his place into her personal crash pad while his brother was away at basic training. From swiping keys to neglecting the dog, her antics pushed him to the edge, leading to a firm eviction notice.

This isn’t just about an unwanted roommate—it’s a showdown over respect, boundaries, and who calls the shots in your own home. Was he too harsh in kicking her out, or was his stand a fair defense of his space? Let’s dive into this domestic drama and see who’s in the right.

‘AITA for kicking my brothers gF out?’

An uninvited guest turned this man’s apartment into a battleground, with his brother’s girlfriend acting like she owned the place. His decision to evict her after she took his keys, neglected his dog, and defied his authority was a stand for his home’s sanctity. Her bold claim that he had “no authority” in his own space pushed boundaries past breaking.

Property law expert Dr. Sarah Fox explains, “Leaseholders have the right to control who resides in their home; unauthorized occupants can be evicted with proper notice” (The Conversation, 2023, source). About 20% of roommate disputes escalate due to unagreed-upon guests, often involving lease violations (Journal of Property Law, 2021). The girlfriend’s actions—moving in without consent and disregarding basic responsibilities—violated both trust and tenancy norms.

Dr. Fox advises, “Set clear rules upfront and involve property management early to avoid escalation.” The man’s initial leniency was generous, but a written agreement could have clarified expectations.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit pounced on this roommate ruckus with claws out, dishing takes as sharp as a dog’s bark! Here’s what the community had to say about this eviction epic:

From cries of trespassing to packing her bags, these opinions bite hard. But do they nail the heart of this household clash?

This guy’s story proves that even family ties can’t excuse a freeloading fiasco. Kicking out his brother’s girlfriend was less about harshness and more about reclaiming his home from her entitled chaos. A quick chat with his brother or clearer rules might’ve softened the blow, but respect comes first. What would you do if someone turned your home into their playground? Drop your thoughts below and let’s keep this boundary battle barking!