AITA for giving my daughter an allowance?
In a cozy living room, vibrant Valentine’s Day roses catch the eye as an 8-year-old girl, let’s call her Rose, proudly shows off her chore-earned money jar, brimming with $40. Her diligent saving for a new Switch game sparks envy in her 11-year-old cousin, setting off a family firestorm. The original poster (OP) thought they were teaching Rose responsibility with a $5 weekly allowance, but now faces a brother demanding they either stop or bankroll his kid’s chores too.
This Reddit drama unfolds like a sitcom spat, with parents, in-laws, and a striking nephew throwing shade at the OP’s parenting. Is a small allowance a clever lesson or a family feud starter? Let’s dive into Rose’s money jar saga, unpack the Reddit reactions, and see what experts say about kids and cash.
‘AITA for giving my daughter an allowance?’
This allowance uproar is less about dollars and more about clashing parenting philosophies. The OP’s $5 weekly reward for Rose’s chores teaches financial literacy, while their brother sees it as bribing kids for basic duties. Both sides have merit, but the brother’s demand that the OP fund his son’s allowance or stop Rose’s is a wild overreach, turning a personal choice into a family feud.
Teaching kids about money early pays off. A 2023 study by the University of Cambridge found that children who manage small amounts of money by age 7 develop stronger financial habits by adulthood. Rose’s saving for a Switch game shows she’s learning value and patience, skills her cousin might miss without similar lessons.
Dr. Ron Lieber, author of The Opposite of Spoiled, notes, “Allowances tied to chores can teach kids the link between work and reward, fostering responsibility”. The OP’s system aligns with this, while the brother’s refusal to adapt dismisses a chance to teach his son. The nephew’s chore strike suggests a need for dialogue, not demands.
For solutions, the OP should hold firm but offer to share their chore chart system with their brother. Open family talks could ease tensions, and tools like Greenlight, a kids’ money app, might help the nephew learn responsibility.
Heres what people had to say to OP:
The Reddit squad rolled in with�라이크, dishing out spicy support for the OP. Here’s the tea:
![[Reddit User] − NTA. They're telling you how to parent, if they expect you to pay his allowance then you get dibs in all parenting decisions with their son.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/262564cm-01.png)
![[Reddit User] − NTA it's a good life skill your daughter is learning. I've told my wife that we should be doing this with our 7 year old but it's never happened so I just stay out of it](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/262564cm-06.png)
These Reddit zingers back the OP with gusto, but do they nail the nuance? The community sees the brother as entitled, but is there room for compromise in this family face-off?
Rose’s money jar has sparked a family showdown, pitting the OP’s savvy parenting against old-school chore expectations. The allowance works for Rose, but her cousin’s rebellion and the brother’s demands reveal how parenting choices can ripple. Would you pay your kid for chores or expect free labor? Share your stories and solutions below—let’s keep this cash-fueled convo flowing!
