AITA for getting someone fired because they pretended to know the language?

Picture walking into your dream job interview, your native Russian flowing like a river, only to be met with an interviewer whose “Russian” sounds like a Google Translate trainwreck. For 27-year-old Katya, this wasn’t just a bad interview—it was a betrayal of fairness. Fluent in Russian, she aced every mangled question, yet was rejected for “poor” language skills by an interviewer barely able to form a sentence.

Stunned by the injustice, Katya posted a truthful review on a job site, detailing the interviewer’s incompetence. The post went viral, prompting a company investigation and the interviewer’s firing. Now, Katya’s inbox is flooded with angry messages from the woman’s friends, blaming her for ruining a livelihood. Was Katya’s review a stand for justice, or did it cross a line? This Reddit tale unpacks the fallout of workplace lies and the courage to call them out.

‘AITA for getting someone fired because they pretended to know the language?’

I (27f) decided to apply for my dream job. I have met all the criteria and one of them was to be proficient in my native language (Russian) , which I am, since I've grown up in the country speaking and writing in it and have finished school and university where obviously all the subjects are taught in Russian, except English and French/German language classes.

I ended up securing the interview with this place and needed to demonstrate the knowledge of Russian, so the person who did the interview started asking me questions in it. However I could barely understand her, not only the accent made it incredibly difficult but the fact that she couldn't build a sentence, but also used incorrect forms of the words and the pronunciation was totally wrong too.

In short it sounded as if she was randomly putting the words in Google translate and was trying to repeat them over. I have answered all her questions, however I've also noticed she barely made any notes. I decided to let it pass and wait for a verdict. After about 3 months of chasing and silence,

I got an email saying I wasn't successful and the reason was that they believed my knowledge of Russian language was poor and insufficient for the job and not up to their 'standards' according to the interviewer. Of course I was confused, since the lady who interviewed me could barely speak the language herself.

So I have decided to leave feedback about my experience on one of the job sites, which was made to share info about working at the job and interview process. My review received a fair amount of traction and last week Monday I ended up getting a call from the higher ups, who listened to my feedback and opened the investigation.

On Friday I have found out the lady who interviewed me was dismissed. She and her friends were messaging me on social media calling an a**hole, because this job was her only source of income and was struggling. I am now feeling guilty about this and feel like I was an a**hole for writing about my experience.. AITA?

A job rejection stings, but one based on a lie cuts deeper. Katya’s review exposed an interviewer who faked Russian fluency, costing her a dream opportunity. HR expert Liz Ryan warns, “Deception in hiring undermines talent and trust, harming businesses and candidates alike” (Human Workplace). The interviewer’s false assessment protected her own inadequacy, potentially blocking countless qualified applicants.

This highlights a wider issue: skill misrepresentation in the workplace. A 2024 LinkedIn report found 29% of employers have faced employees exaggerating language skills, disrupting team performance (LinkedIn). Katya’s feedback was a public service, alerting the company to a flaw in their process. The interviewer’s firing was her own doing—Katya merely shone a light on the truth.

Feeling guilty is human, but Katya’s review was factual, not malicious. She could reach out to the company, saying, “I’d love a chance to re-interview with a qualified assessor,” as Redditors advised.

ADVERTISEMENT

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit’s serving up takes sharper than a job market edge—here’s what they said about Katya’s interview fiasco:

EagleSevenFoxThree - NTA - She is scamming her company by pretending to speak a language that she has minimal fluency in. Imagine how many other people she’s turned down for jobs.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - Nta. You were denied a job based on a lie that wasn’t yours. That’s not on you. It could have been your only source of income too.

[Reddit User] - NTA, she shouldn’t have pretended to know a language she wasn’t fluent in, and it’s her own fault for being sacked. She could’ve easily had avoided this by not pretending and having someone else do the interview that did know Russian

ADVERTISEMENT

Angelblade92 - NTA- you missed out on a wonderful sounding job, due to a person who clearly wasn’t up to scratch and had no business interviewing someone fluent in the language.

ELSquared71 - NTA. She isn’t qualified to do her job, and lied about the results of the interview. The business that employs her requires a knowledge of the language and she’s pulling the wool over their eyes. Not your concern, and I hope you’re able to interview again.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ehgender - NTA She took a job she shouldn’t have, and the consequence of that is that the team suffers. She would have been found out eventually. Not only that but she specifically is the reason you didn’t get the job *because she was afraid she would have been found out had you been hired.*

She was trying to keep a job she didn’t deserve leaving other *more qualified* people to suffer the consequences.. I hope they reconsider your application.. And don’t feel bad about her. I’m sure she’ll find another scam soon enough.

RedditUser123234 - NTA She and her friends were messaging me on social media calling an a**hole, because this job was her only source of income and was struggling.. And there were probably struggling people who could've used that job who she denied.

ADVERTISEMENT

If he job was really so important to her, and she absolutely had to lie to keep her source of income, then in her spare time after getting this new job responsibility, she should've been getting language lessons (rosetta stone or something else online), instead of relying on whatever translate thing she was using.

DarkAthena - NTA. She was being dishonest and threw you under the bus to save herself. She got what she deserved. I’m sorry you lost out on the job.

Dark_Phoenix25 - NTA. Her poor language skills made you miss out on your dream job. That’s not on you, you were simply being honest. OP you might wanna email that same higher up to see if you can re-interview seeing as this wasn’t your fault. Good luck

ADVERTISEMENT

hellahellagoodshit - NTA. It sounds to me like she denied you a job opportunity because she was afraid that you would know that she cannot speak Russian. And for that, she is a bad person and deserves to be fired.

From roasting the interviewer’s scam to rooting for Katya’s reapplication, Reddit’s got her back. But do these takes land the job, or just stir the pot?

Katya’s review toppled a workplace fraud, but it came with a side of guilt. Was she right to expose the interviewer’s lie, or should she have spared her job? Have you ever called out unfair treatment at work? Drop your stories—what would you do when a lie blocks your big break?

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *