AITA for forcefully removing my drunk female friend from a party?
The scene’s buzzing: music thumps, drinks flow, and laughter fills a crowded house party—until the vibe shifts to something murky. A college guy, out with his girlfriend, roommate, and friend Sandra, watches her down drinks, slurring past her usual limit. A sober stranger hovers, flirting relentlessly, while another shady character lingers, eyeing Sandra as the night winds down. The clock ticks late, work looms for her in hours, and red flags wave like neon signs in our guy’s gut.
His girlfriend pleads, but Sandra clings to the party, brushing off warnings. The host shrugs, “She’s fine,” yet unease gnaws. Frustrated, he scoops her up, hauling her out despite her squirms. She thanks him later, but doubts swirl. Readers, feel the tension: was he a hero or overstepping? Buckle up for this wild, boozy ride!
‘AITA for forcefully removing my drunk female friend from a party?’
This party saga mixes booze, instinct, and a bold move. Sandra, hammered beyond her norm, drew a sober guy’s focus—his persistence clashing with her clouded judgment. The host’s “she’s fine” and a sleazy bystander’s nudge raised alarms, prompting our guy to physically whisk her away. Her later thanks hints at relief, but the host and Sandra’s initial resistance spark debate: protection or control?
Consent’s the crux. The National Sexual Violence Resource Center notes 1 in 5 women face sexual assault risks, often tied to alcohol, where consent can’t be given (source). A sober pursuer targeting a drunk person screams trouble. Dr. Laura McGuire, a consent expert, says, “Impaired individuals can’t consent—full stop. Bystanders intervening can prevent harm” (source).
Our guy’s call—offering a number swap, then carrying her out—leaned on gut and Sandra’s past regrets. Advice? Stick to boundaries: check in sober, lean on friends.
Here’s what Redditors had to say:
Reddit poured out raw, rowdy takes—some cheering, some sharp. Did our guy save the night or nanny too hard? Here’s the party line from the crowd:
![[Reddit User] - NTA. While you can't force a grown woman to do something against her will because you want to protect her, I think most reasonable would consider this extenuating circumstances. It's like shoving someone out of the way of a speeding car. Yeah, you don't shove people, but it was necessary to save a life.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/286963cm-08.png)
![[Reddit User] - NTA. You 100% did the right thing. She was not in a state where she could look after herself and there were people who knew that and were COUNTING on that. They were 100% planning to do something awful when they got a chance. You need to look out for your friends, even if they’re in a state where they don’t realise at first that you’re helping them. Sandra even thanked you because she knew you were helping too.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/286963cm-09.png)
These are Reddit’s hot takes, but do they hold water? Maybe he dodged a disaster, or perhaps he overplayed his hand.
This late-night drama pours out worry, loyalty, and a gutsy exit. A friend, drunk beyond reason, teetered on a risky edge, and our guy hauled her out, shrugging off protests. Sandra’s hug and thanks hint he nailed it, but the host’s pushback and her initial fight muddle the mix. Safety won, yet consent’s shadow lingers. Could a gentler nudge have worked, or was muscle the move? What would you do—swoop in or step back? Spill your thoughts, experiences, and takes below—let’s shake this up!
