AITA for forbidding my wife to go to her affair partner’s funeral?

In the quiet of a long-healed marriage, a phone call from a mother-in-law stirred up old wounds like dust in a forgotten attic. A couple, married 15 years, faced a ghost from their past when the wife’s former affair partner passed away in a workplace accident. The husband, once shattered by her betrayal during his deployment, felt his heart lurch at her wish to attend the funeral.

This Reddit saga peels back the layers of trust rebuilt through years of effort, only to be tested by a single request. Bound by lingering pain and protective instincts, the husband drew a hard line, sparking a silent standoff. Let’s dive into this raw tale of loyalty, boundaries, and resurfaced scars to uncover what it means to heal.

‘AITA for forbidding my wife to go to her affair partner’s funeral?’

Married 15 years and almost didn't make it this far. In our second year of marriage my wife went home when I was deployed and slept with Some D**khead (who I'll refer to as SD from here out) who she was loose acquaintances with growing up.

She hadn't seen him in years but he just happened to show up during my daughter's birthday party because he was the son of one of my mother-in-law's old friends. SD and my wife hooked up later that week after reconnecting.. ​The reason I didn't kick my wife's ass to the curb and eventually forgave her is because she told me herself soon after I got home.

And she didn't try to justify it with the 'oh well you were gone, i felt lonely blah blah blah'. No she actually said straight up that she was a f**king dumbass (her words not mine, though I agree) and she felt so sick and disgusting for doing it.. ​She immediately cut off all contact with SD and it took a lot of counseling and healing but here we are today;

feels like non-stop since that time that my wife has gone above and beyond proving that I was right to keep her.. ​Well my mother-in-law called yesterday and she heard from SD's mother that SD died in some workplace accident and they're having a funeral service this weekend.. ​

My wife told me this and that she wanted to go and it was like I got kicked right in the d**k. I instantly felt nauseous and had f**king horrible flashbacks of when she told me about her affair. All those horrible feelings resurfaced along with the s**tty memories of me crying my f**king eyes out and my image of her shattering.

The pain felt as fresh as when she dropped that bomb on me.. I asked her why seeing as she hadn't talked to the guy in over a decade not to mention...you know....she f**ked him while we were married. She keeps saying s**t like 'it's the right thing to do' and 'she just wants to pay respects'.. ​

ADVERTISEMENT

I can't stop repeating that I'm so hurt with that decision as he's had no part of her life in so long and I'm re-living all those s**tty nights I was sure our family would be shattered and I would only see my daughter 50% of the time.. ​ After some back and forth I put my f**king foot down and told her NO, she cannot go. I said it's so disrespectful to me and our marriage and we've been on the silent treatment since then. AITA?. ​

EDIT: Seems like people are starting to trip up on me saying 'feels like non-stop since that time that my wife has gone above and beyond proving that I was right to keep her.' as if I'm saying I own her and she's a piece of property to me. That is not the case, I am simply illustrating that she didn't just say she'll do better, she proved it with her actions and has made me a very happy man in our time together.

ADVERTISEMENT

EDIT 2: I apologize for nothing and honestly it brings a happy tear to my eye to to see so many people referring to him as SD, because that's what he was. F**k 'im. A lot of people are saying it's her decision to make and it is but that doesn't mean I have to like it or support it, and yes right at this point I can see myself walking away if she insists on going. We're going to counseling starting tomorrow

This funeral feud lays bare the fragile threads of trust in a marriage scarred by infidelity. The husband’s visceral reaction—nausea, flashbacks—reflects unhealed trauma, while the wife’s wish to “pay respects” suggests a need for closure. Both perspectives clash, rooted in valid emotions, but the husband’s boundary feels like a shield against past pain.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Shirley Glass, a renowned infidelity expert, wrote in Not ‘Just Friends’, “Rebuilding trust requires protecting the relationship from any threat, real or perceived.” The husband sees the funeral as a threat, reopening wounds from a betrayal 13 years ago. The wife’s intent may be innocent, but her disregard for his distress risks their hard-earned progress.

Infidelity’s long shadow is common: a 2020 study found 60% of couples face trust issues years after an affair. The wife’s push to attend could stem from guilt or societal norms around mourning, but it dismisses her husband’s pain. Couples therapy, as they’ve planned, is a smart move to navigate this. For now, she should prioritize his feelings, perhaps sending condolences privately.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit didn’t mince words—picture a virtual bar erupting with hot takes! Most backed the husband, citing his pain, while some saw the wife’s side, urging closure.

Chihuahuamangoes − NTA. You are obviously distressed and she should consider this.. Also, excuse my atheism, this person is dead. His non-conscious decaying body will not care who shows up.. Add: Oh, my first gold! And my first silver (edit: and diamond). I feel special. Thanks guys!

ADVERTISEMENT

TDIsideHustle − NTA thank you for your service. This would be an absolute no go for me. You’re a good man for putting your family first, and not kicking her to the curb when you first found out. No need for her to open up old wounds. If she wants to pay respect, send some flowers...

[Reddit User] − Normally, I’d be against partners not allowing their partner to do something like this. But not this time. You’re NTA for expecting and demanding she make things up to you by starting to show some respect for your marriage and the pain she has caused you.

I would say to her, ‘if you want to go, I won’t stop you, but don’t come back if you do.’ Did SD have a wife? Kids? Did he cheat on them as well? If so, her presence would also be disrespectful towards his family.. Edit: I appreciate the silver.

ADVERTISEMENT

BobsDadBod − NAH. I'd be more worried about your reaction to this being quite visceral and painful that maybe you guys needs some more therapy. If your reacting in such a way that's causing an ultimatum I'd say you've not forgiven and forgotten. Is.it possible to talk the funeral situation through with mediation?

[Reddit User] − NAH. Well, at least after she stopped cheating. You have a right to your feelings but so does your wife. She made a mistake but showed you ever since how she regretted it.. Might it be she just wants closure here? He - once - was a friend and a bit more.. Don’t let him pose a threat now, after all this time. Let her go to the funeral.

StrykerVeritas − NTA.. You seem pretty grounded here and probably know this already, but death does crazy things to people. That said, the continuation of your marriage was predicated in large part to her breaking all contact with this f**k. To me that includes when he dies.

ADVERTISEMENT

No reason for you to feel bad about communicating the feelings of betrayal that come bubbling back to the surface with the news. Might consider talking about it to a professional, since you’ve obviously had success doing that previously. Best of luck, friend.

RiflemanLax − NTA. This is what, 13-14 years ago? Makes no sense. I mean, if it were an ex-husband or ex-boyfriend, you'd be a d**k. No contact with a dude who she cheated with for that long? Makes no sense. Your feelings are quite understood and I don't understand what she'd gain from this. Closure? No...

bexallday − NAH I think your feelings and response are totally reasonable and valid. I also think death is a tricky thing to deal with. Funerals provide some closure for a lot of people. It could be that your wife is just seeking that final closure. And I’m not trying to imply that if he were still alive so would a small part of their former relationship.

ADVERTISEMENT

I just mean attending the funeral could be therapeutic for her, putting the final nail in the coffin (what a horrible metaphor here, I’m sorry, I couldn’t come up with something else) of that terrible decision she made. Bottom line, you’re not TA for feeling how you do about this and communicating that to your wife. She’s not TA either unless she just totally disregards your feelings.

g-rammer − INFO. Does MIL know about the affair? She called to inform your wife about the funeral. It seems like her mother is expecting her to go. If she knew about the affair, maybe she wouldn't? Not going may then be questioned, leading to the affair being revealed? That would at least explain why she would want to go.

Goodfella0328 − I’m gonna go against the tide here and say NAH. You’re not an a**hole because...she f**ked this guy. But she’s not an a**hole here either because...the guy *is* dead. It does seem like the right thing to do, to pay respects to his extended family. On a side note, how did you react when you heard he died? I’m not asking this to judge you, I just honestly wanna know.

ADVERTISEMENT

But do these Reddit rants capture the full picture, or are they just fuel for the drama fire?

This marital clash unearths the ghosts of infidelity, where a funeral becomes a battleground for trust and respect. The husband’s firm “no” protects his heart, but is it too controlling? The wife’s wish for closure feels human, yet it stings. What would you do if old wounds clashed with new choices? Share your thoughts—have you faced a moment where past betrayals tested your present?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *