AITA for flipping out on a dog owner for ruining lunch?

In a sun-dappled grassy spot by a canal, a young family’s lunch break turned into a barking showdown. A couple, savoring Chick-fil-A with their 3-month-old baby, hoped for a peaceful moment on a quiet bench. But when an unleashed dog bounded over, licking the wife’s ankle and startling her, the calm shattered. The dad’s polite requests to the dog’s owner went ignored, sparking a fiery exchange that left both sides fuming. Picture the scene: a crying baby, a startled mom, and a dog owner clueless about the chaos his pets caused.

The dad’s sharp words, laced with frustration, called out the owner’s negligence, but the owner fired back, shocked that not everyone loves his dogs. This Reddit tale dives into the clash of personal space, pet responsibility, and public etiquette. Was the dad’s outburst justified, or did he go too far over a furry intrusion?

‘AITA for flipping out on a dog owner for ruining lunch?’

This happened about an hour ago at the time of typing. I have a 3 month old and wife is still on Maternity leave. They came to visit me at work and brought Chick Fil A for lunch. There is a canal area that has half a dozen decent sized grassy areas with benches.

There is a walking path along it that gets a decent amount of traffic. We find a completely empty grassy area with a bench. There is no one around and its really nice out. My kid is sitting in the stroller just being chill. I'm talking to both my kid and wife while we are eating.

My kid starts crying and I pick him up to soothe him. I see an over 50 guy walking by and he is eyeing us. Figured he was looking at my kid since he was crying. When all of a sudden a maybe 5 pound unleashed dog comes up and licks my wifes a**le. This scared the s**t out of her.

We are not exactly dog friendly. Neither of us grew up with dogs and have zero interest in owning, let alone interacting with them. Then a second small dog walks up to us. I turn to the guy and say get your dogs away from us. He just looks at me with this dopey look on his face.

So I say it again. He half heartedly tells the dogs to come to him. They don't listen to him. I'm like come on man, get your effing dogs away from us. We are eating lunch and don't want them around. My kid is still crying. My wife asks him to get them away too.

He says to me 'You don't like dogs?'. I'm just like no, I don't like dogs, I also hate bad (I used a worse word) owners like you that don't leash their dogs and let them rudely walk up to people. I don't want your dogs around. He tells me I don't have to be so rude.

ADVERTISEMENT

I responded back with you are the effing p**ck that decided to let your dogs occupy the same ten square feet as us despite their being other areas to go. If you wouldn't have bothered us, I wouldn't be flipping out on you. He looked shocked that someone didn't adore his dogs and walks away muttering at me under his breath. So Am I the A**hole?

Edit: This is not a dog park, or even a regular park. Just an area with multiple grassy areas. There is a lot of signage to pick up poop and leash your dogs.

ADVERTISEMENT

A family lunch disrupted by an unleashed dog can ignite tempers faster than a spark in dry grass. The father’s frustration was understandable—his wife was startled, their baby was crying, and the dog owner’s slow response felt like disregard. Not everyone loves dogs, and unleashed pets in public spaces can feel invasive, especially near a newborn. The owner’s failure to leash his dogs, despite clear signage, violated basic public etiquette, escalating the conflict.

Pet ownership comes with responsibility. A 2023 ASPCA report notes that 85% of U.S. communities have leash laws to ensure safety and respect in public spaces (aspca.org). Dr. Stanley Coren, a canine behavior expert, says, “Leashed dogs prevent unpredictable interactions, protecting both people and pets”. The father’s strong language may have been harsh, but his call for control was valid. A calm follow-up with the owner or a park official could prevent future clashes.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit’s pack didn’t hold back, howling support for the dad while throwing shade at the dog owner’s negligence. From leash law rants to empathy for dog-averse families, here’s what they barked:

ADVERTISEMENT

Justalieutell - NTA. Leash laws exist for a reason. Not everyone wants dogs in their space, people have phobias, and allergies are a thing so for multiple reasons it’s irresponsible to have them off leash in the same area as others without knowing if they’re dog friendly.

The fact that you had to ask multiple times and he seemed bewildered that he was in the wrong is aggravating and you’re not obligated to be nice to people who don’t have any respect for others in public.

WholeAd2742 - NTA. He needed to have his dogs leashed. You have no idea if they have food aggression or are friendly or not.. Absolutely hate irresponsible pet owners who do this.

ADVERTISEMENT

SilentDrapeRunner11 - NTA. So sick of entitled dog owners ruining public spaces

No-Personality5421 - Nta. Most places have leash laws. You did ask nicely, like 3 times. A good dog owner would have pulled their dogs back after the first time... actually, good dog owner wouldn't have needed the first time because they would have them on a leash.

C_Majuscula - NTA. Anyone who lets their dog(s) off leash in public outside a clearly dog-friendly event or dogpark needs to be harshly corrected.

ADVERTISEMENT

VehicleSea227 - What is up with people comparing dogs to children?! Like, no, absolutely not. No one has severe allergies to people, which is what kids are, they are actual human beings. A toddler can't run up and do serious physical harm to your body.

Your 'dislike' of small children is nothing compared to the fear of someone who has trauma from a past dog attack. Stop it. NTA. The number of times my dh has been bitten by unleashed dogs as he's walking through the park ( not a dog park) on his lunch break, with their stupid owners gushing over what a 'sweet dog' he usually is,

and 'he never does that!', is enraging. Put your dog on a f**king leash! I don't care how nice you think your pet is, it's still an animal. Animals are unpredictable. And yes, I own a dog. He is part of our family and more important to my kids than I am. But I still keep him on a leash on public trails and parks!

ADVERTISEMENT

NotHisRealName - NTA. I love dogs and I still don't want unleashed dogs that I don't know running up to me. If I were there with a kid, I don't know how I would react.

Euphoric-Pressure-58 - Nta. Sometimes strong language is the only way people take you seriously

Slow-Grass3218 - NTA- dog owner is responsible for making sure their dogs aren’t bothering people in public. You had to ask multiple times, when you should only have to ask once. Imo after the first time you ask, you have no obligation to be “nice”

ADVERTISEMENT

Term-Haunting - NTA. I absolutely hate when dog owners don't leash their dogs.

These Reddit takes bite hard at irresponsible pet owners, but do they miss the owner’s perspective? Or is the dad’s outburst the leash that needed pulling?

This lunch-break showdown shows how fast a furry intruder can turn a peaceful moment into a public spat. The dad’s heated words aimed to protect his family’s space, but the dog owner’s shock suggests a clash of expectations. Was the dad right to snap, or should he have kept his cool? Share your thoughts—have you ever clashed with a pet owner over public etiquette? How would you handle a dog disrupting your family time?

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *