AITA for expecting my wife to help me pay back my student loans from her inheritance?

Charlotte Morse Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a cozy family home, where the hum of daily life—kids playing, dishes clinking—masks a brewing storm over money. A husband, grinding away as the family’s sole breadwinner, sees a lifeline in his wife’s hefty inheritance, hoping it’ll wipe out his student loan debt. But when she slams the door on that idea, claiming the money as hers alone, tensions flare. He retaliates by cutting her personal spending, sparking a fiery debate about fairness and partnership. Readers feel the sting of this financial tug-of-war, wondering: is it selfish to guard an inheritance, or controlling to withhold shared funds?

This Reddit saga dives into the messy heart of marital finances, where love meets ledgers. It’s a tale of clashing expectations, with both sides digging in. Can a couple truly be a team when money divides them? Let’s unpack this drama and see where the fault lines lie.

‘AITA for expecting my wife to help me pay back my student loans from her inheritance?’

My wife is a SAHM for our 2 kids and I work full-time as the sole income provider for the family. I am slowly working on paying back my student loans. My wife recently received a relatively large inheritance, about 5x the amount of my student loans.

A month after everything regarding the inheritance was settled, I talked with my wife about using the inheritance to pay off my loans. She refused to give me any of the money and said the inheritance belongs only to her.

I told her that, yes, legally that's true but we are a family and we should share our resources to make our burdens easier. She disagreed and said my student loans pre-date our marriage and are my sole responsibility.

I felt like she was being unfair to our relationship and to us as a family, so the next day I told her that if she was not going to help me pay off her student loans, now that she has money I will not be paying for any expense that is solely hers (like clothes, eating out, flights, makeup, spas, new phone, etc.).

Instead I will be putting that money towards my loans to pay them back faster. She accused me of being controlling with money and abusing my position as the income earner but I don't see why I should be responsible for all that when she has her own money now?. AITA?

Money disputes in marriage can feel like a cold splash of reality, and this couple’s clash over an inheritance is no exception. The husband sees his wife’s windfall as a chance to lighten the family’s load, while she views it as her personal safety net. Both have valid points, but their approach—petty ultimatums and all—misses the mark of partnership.

ADVERTISEMENT

The core issue here is financial teamwork. A 2023 survey by Fidelity Investments found that 45% of couples argue about money, often due to differing views on shared responsibilities. The wife’s stance reflects a need for security as a stay-at-home mom, while the husband’s frustration stems from bearing the family’s financial weight alone.

Financial therapist Megan McCoy, quoted in a Forbes article, says, “Money decisions in marriage should align with shared goals, not individual wins”. Her insight highlights the couple’s misstep: neither communicated a joint plan. The husband’s threat to cut spending feels controlling, while the wife’s refusal to share seems insular. A compromise—perhaps allocating part of the inheritance to loans while reserving some for her security—could bridge the gap.

ADVERTISEMENT

For solutions, they should sit down with a financial planner or use tools like those on NerdWallet. Openly discussing goals, like debt reduction or savings, can rebuild trust.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit’s got some fiery takes on this money mess, served with a side of shade. Here’s what the community chimed in with:

constant_craving - ESH. Yeah, it would be sensible of her to use that money to help you with your loans to generally put your family in a better financial position. Yes, it's abusing your position as income-earner to deny her money for herself. Unless you're paying her a salary for watching the children, then she is enabling you to make your salary and is entitled to money too.

ADVERTISEMENT

VonShtupp - NTA - and I say that as a SAHM. You can’t have it both ways.

unjessicabiel_evable - ESH... y'all are headed for divorce at this rate.

icebluefrost - INFO: You say your wife is a stay at home mom. Are you paying her for what would be your half of the cost of childcare if she were working? If not, then you paying for her personal items is that compensation.

ADVERTISEMENT

kristent225 - I think you're both being childish about it, but the bigger issue here is WHY is she refusing to share her inheritance when it's 5x your loan amount? I could understand if it was close to the amount

but she would still have a large inheritance, so something else is going on here. I understand why you came to your decision but you're married, now is not the time to be petty. ESH and talk to your wife

ladylyrande - ESH. A marriage should be a partnership. In yours, you bring in the money, she cares for the children and the house. Noth valuable contributions. You shouldn't have had to ask. She should have offered to pay the loans as that would have allowed more money to the household and a more comfortable finantial position for both.

ADVERTISEMENT

The whole 'my money is my money and your money is my money' is very selfish of her and why she is the a**hole. You on the other hand come off as both entitled and abusive. She didn't do as you wanted so you held the purse strings as a first reaction which makes me wonder that it wasn't the first time you used that.

She doesn't work because she is caring for the children and the household. Her personal expenses and items should then be considered part of the household. Now, an inheritance doesn't mean she suddenly is independently wealthy and you still have a responsibility for the financial support since she is still providing her side of the bargain.

Maybe a good compromise there would've been putting most of the money in an investment plan for retirement or so she can have some income with the earninga if feasible (don't know the ammount).. Regardless based on the attitude there... y'all heading for divorce territory.

ADVERTISEMENT

bitchy_badger - Info: what are her plans with the money? Is she putting away for children education, home purchase? Or is she just hoarding it as hers and not the families

parishilton2 - NTA. She should be looking at the inheritance as a way to lift up your whole family. Your family will be better able to prosper when your student loans are paid off. I’m assuming that the degree for which you took out loans is the degree that allows you to be the sole income provider for your family. Your wife reaps the benefit of that. It’s not good that she’s taking such an adversarial stance here. You’re supposed to be a team.

Majestic-Chair-3401 - NTA. You don’t have a problem giving her money for things outside of necessities, making it harder for you to pay off your loans, but she has a problem doing the same for you. It makes sense that you would stop giving her money for things that are not necessities while you pay off your loans.

ADVERTISEMENT

Much-Meringue-7467 - Here's a problem from her standpoint. She is a SAHM. So she is totally dependent on his earnings and, and this is important, her work history and personal earning potential are taking a hit over it. If she spends a chunk of this inheritance on his debts and he bails, she will be SOL. Whereas if she doesn't and he bails, she has more of a cushion.

These hot takes from Reddit cut deep, but do they get to the root of the issue? Is it fair to expect an inheritance to solve family debt, or is the husband’s retaliation a step too far?

This tale of loans and inheritances lays bare the tricky dance of money in marriage. The husband’s push for shared resources clashes with his wife’s need for financial autonomy, leaving readers split on who’s right. Should love mean pooling every dollar, or does personal money deserve a boundary? Share your thoughts—have you faced a similar money spat in your relationship? What would you do to find common ground in this financial face-off?

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *