AITA for dumping friend bc I thought she was going after my husband?

A 15-year friendship crumbled when a woman’s vivacious friend crossed a line, sitting on her husband’s lap in a bold display that capped years of flirty texts and cozy selfies. Feeling disrespected and betrayed, she ended the friendship, but lingering doubts about her decision stir questions about trust, loyalty, and the boundaries of friendship.

This isn’t just about a lap; it’s a story of a friend’s disregard igniting a wife’s protective instincts. The narrative pulls us into a tense moment of confrontation, raising questions about when to draw the line with a friend’s behavior.

‘AITA for dumping friend bc I thought she was going after my husband?’

I'll try to simplify. 15 yr friendship. She and I were friends first, then we met husbands. Played racketball with husbands every weekend for at least 10 yrs. Her husband well-to-do and funny but a little bit creepy and 20 yrs older. Husbands not friends but will interact.

She is a few years older but is attractive, vivacious and fitter than I am. She admitted to me that she married for a GC. She complains about her husband all the time. With my husband she is more excited, agreeable, complimentary, coquettish. She takes selfies with him but not me.

She responds to his texts but not mine (on group chat. She had been privately sending my husband texts for years with flirty emojis that I wasn't aware of. My husband didn't think they were flirty). There were several instances where I either I thought something was going on or someone else thought something was going on.

Finally she sat on his lap in front of me and I thought

A woman’s decision to end a 15-year friendship after her friend’s flirtatious behavior—culminating in sitting on her husband’s lap—was a justified defense of her marriage and self-respect. The friend’s actions, from flirty texts with emojis to selfies excluding the wife and overt compliments, suggest a pattern of boundary-crossing, even if her husband didn’t see it as flirting.

Her lap-sitting in the wife’s presence was a blatant disrespect, especially given her admitted green card marriage and complaints about her own husband. The wife’s trust in her gut reflects an awareness of subtle relational threats.

Friendships require mutual respect: a 2022 Journal of Social and Personal Relationships study found 30% of friendships end due to boundary violations, often involving inappropriate behavior with partners. Relationship therapist Dr. John Gottman advises, “Protecting a marriage means setting clear boundaries with others, even friends” (source).

She should discuss her husband’s response to the lap-sitting to ensure alignment, maintain no contact with the friend, and seek therapy if trust issues linger. Her choice wasn’t unreasonable—it prioritized her marriage over a disloyal friend.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit strongly supported the wife, declaring her NTA for ending the friendship, viewing the friend’s behavior—flirty texts, selfies, and lap-sitting—as clear disrespect and potential pursuit of her husband. Many praised her for trusting her instincts, with some suggesting the friend’s actions were predatory, especially given her unhappy green card marriage.

Commenters urged her to monitor her husband’s reactions, noting his lack of outrage at the lap-sitting could be a concern, though most focused on the friend’s betrayal. The consensus encouraged cutting contact and informing the friend’s husband about her green card motives, affirming the wife’s decision as necessary.

Dark_Mode_Nose_Wind − Trust your gut here. Between the texts and that territorial lap-sitting display right in front of you, you have every reason never to speak to her again.

CathoftheNorth − Women know when another woman is after her man. I 100% support ending this friendship, she had no respect for you and would have already slept with your husband if he would have been interested. She's not your friend, you know that, and did what you had to do.. YNW!

Unusual_Entertainer8 − As a man I'm going to say what no has else has. You need to be watching EXACTLY what your husband is doing. If I were a husband who loved his wife I would have been furious if a woman sat on my lap like that, because now you just caused me all kind of problems that I need to deal with. I'm not saying he is cheating on you but ...? Look at his phone or take notice of things that feel off.

QuitProfessional5437 − Lol you're better than me. I would've pulled her off my husband's lap by her hair.. Not wrong. You should've shut it down day 1. She just kept getting more and more comfortable.

ndhatesnts − From the outside it definitely looks like she was angling to try and get him to cheat on you with her. Dropping her was the kindest option.

TraditionScary8716 − What did your husband do when she plopped down on his lap?

Aggressive_Hearing40 − Even if she isn’t after him, she’s certainly not acting like she’s YOUR friend, rather like his bestie and you’re just the annoying third wheel. For that reason I don’t see why you or your husband should have to entertain her further.

lawyerupheaux − Who sits on someone else’s husbands lap?! Absolutely not, she had to go.

HeartAccording5241 − Ya she was after your husband I would have let her husband know she only married him for the gc so he knows

Drgnmstr97 − My wife and her best friend have been friends for 40 years and we have been together for 35. We have had some very candid conversations about her s** life but not really any about our s** life. She is not satisfied with her s** life. She has said some things over time that lead me to believe my wife has shared some details with her though.

One night a few years back she had a few adult beverages and was feeling pretty good. She came over to me and sat right down on my lap. Both of our spouses were in the same room as us but I was sitting around a corner from the main party on a sofa that was not in immediate view.

She actually started grinding ever so slightly and leaned over to whispering directly into my ear something to the effect of, I just wanted to see how big it was for myself. Apparently my wife had been sharing at least that much info with her.

I’m a pretty big guy and I just stood right up lifting her off my lap and turned around and set her down on the couch and she pouted at me. To say I was devastated was an understatement. Unless my wife had somehow given her this green light without letting me in on it, and I didn’t believe that for a second

I was going to disclose something that was going to end their friendship, 40 YEARS of friendship. I waited until we were at home that night before I told her. And I asked why she would say that to me of course. She told me they shared a lot and apparently her friend liked to hear about my wife’s exploits because she pretty much had a dead bedroom.

I cannot comprehend how you could choose to do something like that, even sauced up, to your best friend. She had made some off hand comments over the years about my wife sharing, things like can’t you share the wealth and such but I chalked it up to her dissatisfaction with her s** life and not my wife talking me up to her, I never took that seriously.

They had it out about it and she apologized to her and to me but their friendship has been almost nonexistent since that happened a few years ago. It is absolutely appropriate to end a friendship when they cross a line and where that line resides is totally up to you.

I don’t want to believe that she was actually hitting on me and wanted to start an affair but I certainly don’t know what her underlying thoughts were. I wanted and I guess still want to believe that she just allowed her curiosity and pent up frustration get the best of her that night. However that was a line that should not have been crossed.

This wasn’t just about a lap—it was about a friend’s betrayal eroding a 15-year bond. The wife’s choice to cut ties, driven by her friend’s flirty oversteps, reflects a stand for her marriage and dignity.

As she moves forward, it’s a reminder that true friends respect boundaries, not test them. How do you handle friends who cross lines? Share your story—what’s your key to protecting your relationships?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *