AITA for directing an overweight guest to sit in a different chair from everyone else?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Imagine a dining room aglow with vintage charm, where mid-century chairs gleam under soft light, each a treasure from a bygone era. Hosting a family celebration, the homeowner’s heart skips when a guest heads for a fragile seat. A quiet request to switch chairs, meant to protect prized furniture, explodes into accusations of fat-shaming, sending guests storming out. This Reddit saga hums with tension, blending practicality with hurt feelings.

Readers are hooked, debating where care for property ends and sensitivity begins. Was the host’s discreet nudge a faux pas, or a fair move to save their cherished chairs? As family ties fray, this tale invites us to weigh: how do you balance hospitality with protecting what’s yours?

‘AITA for directing an overweight guest to sit in a different chair from everyone else?’

I collect mid-century furniture. I have a set of chairs and a table that I love and which are also quite expensive to repair and replace. Since they are old (about 60-70 years old) and from a different era, I don’t expect them to hold a significantly above average amount of weight. I had my family over, along with their guests, to celebrate a special occasion.

One of the guests was my sister’s boyfriend, a man who is maybe 5’10 and easily 300 pounds. I set out a more contemporary chair for him. Not exactly a folding chair, but an IKEA chair which I trusted to hold more weight. He went to go sit in one of the mid century chairs at the table.

I tapped his shoulder and asked him very quietly to sit in the other chair, since I didn’t think that the much older chair would be able to hold his weight well. He immediately blew up at me. He turned to my sister and said very loudly that I was trying to make him feel bad about his weight and that I thought that a chair would break under him.

She starts getting mad at me too, saying that she’s overweight too and did I have a special “fat chair” for her as well? I tried to defuse the situation and said that these chairs were just old and prized, and I wanted to make sure that they wouldn’t break. A lot of people in my family were giving me n**ty looks and saying that singling him out was unfair,

and I should have just had the same chairs for everyone to avoid singling him out. I wanted my chairs out for people to admire and use them and they’re sturdy, for the most part, for an average person’s weight, so I don’t see why I should have just bought all new chairs for this occasion.

The argument reached such a point that my sister and her boyfriend left and so did some of my family. I wasn’t trying to fat shame anyone, it was really just about the chair, and I thought maybe I could prevent him from feeling the embarrassment of breaking a chair as well. Should I just have bought different chairs for the party? AITA?

Hosting guests while safeguarding prized possessions can feel like juggling fine china. This chair swap clash highlights the delicate balance between practicality and perception. Dr. Susan Krauss Whitbourne, a psychology professor, notes, “Weight-related comments, even unintentional, can trigger deep-seated insecurities” (Psychology Today). The host’s discreet request aimed to protect vintage chairs, but the guest’s public outburst turned it into a spectacle.

The host’s concern wasn’t baseless—mid-century chairs, like Eames designs, often have weight limits around 275-350 pounds, per manufacturer specs. A 300-pound guest could indeed risk damage, especially to 60-year-old furniture. Yet, the boyfriend’s reaction, amplified by the sister, suggests personal sensitivities, not just chair concerns. A 2021 study in Body Image found 60% of overweight individuals feel judged in social settings, which may explain the blowup.

Dr. Whitbourne advises, “Empathy in delivery can defuse tension.” The host could’ve used place cards to subtly assign seats, avoiding direct confrontation. The broader issue—society’s weight stigma—fuels such misunderstandings. For resolution, the host might apologize for any hurt, clarifying intent, and offer to discuss privately.

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Reddit’s takes on this chair drama are as lively as a family reunion gone rogue. Here’s the juicy rundown, with a dash of humor:

[Reddit User] - NTA, but this is a delicate topic and I honestly don't know how you could have handled this better except to have put out different chairs for when company comes over.

ADVERTISEMENT

Lonemango - NTA. As an ~ 300 pound guy who has been known to break a chair or two (I also fidget which makes things worse), I would be thrilled if someone had the courtesy of putting a sturdier chair out for me. There are times where I stay standing for fear of breaking a chair. You were discrete, what more could he ask for.

If he chose to make a scene it’s because he wanted the attention, not because you did anything wrong. Also, If he broke your chair he’d seem like a bigger fatty, he would be more embarrassed, and you’d be out a chair. And then You’d be labeled an a**hole for not having a sturdier chair for him. You can’t win with people like that.

ADVERTISEMENT

Furthermore, it’s not about fat shaming, if he was 6’10 300 lbs weight lifter, would you not have said the same thing to him? It’s the weight, not the cause of the weight, that’s the issue. Frankly I’m concerned for your sister, this guy seems to be a manipulator. Even if you did offend him, the normal response would be to tell you afterwards, not go straight to your sister to get her mad at you.

Most normal people don’t try to start s**t between family members, especially for something so trivial. He may be trying to get her to alienate her family, which then makes it easier to manipulate her. And don’t listen to these people who say you shouldn’t put out chairs if they can’t fit everyone, they are talking out their asses.

ADVERTISEMENT

I really doubt they have house fulls of chairs rated at 500 lbs plus just in case an obese person comes for a visit.. Lol, I’m getting heated just thinking about that poor chair. It’s the guilt of serial chair breaker.

SassyPants5 - NTA - you were trying to be subtle and did not call him out in front of everyone. I don’t see a**hole behaviour. It became an issue when he blew up about it.

[Reddit User] - Obesity is tricky business. You dont want to body shame people, but there are times where weight and shape can be damaging or invasive. My personal opinion is NTA, but maybe have the chairs as display items and not functional for anyone if you dont want them broken.

ADVERTISEMENT

schnellermeister - NTA - Since its a sensitive topic, something my family does (we also have chairs like this) is strategically set out place cards. That way it looks fancy and we don't have to worry about chairs.

addyblack - I'm an obese woman that is over 300 lb and you are absolutely NTA. I will go to functions and look around to find the sturdier looking chairs. I've been to places with old style seating, I'm looking at you Key West and Ernest Hemingway house, And we'll sit downstairs.

I know my weight affects me and affects those around me and I try to be very diligent on other people's property. I say he is completely the a**hole because when we get a certain size we should be aware of our surroundings. We should be aware, and have common knowledge, that older furniture even in its Hay day were not made for heavier people.

ADVERTISEMENT

Would I like to lose the weight and be able to sit on those type of chairs? of course! But I have my own things I have to get over before I can start losing weight. Yeah going back to the post, you try very hard to be quiet and polite, had I been the one you were talking to I would have profusely apologized and gone and sat in the better chair for my weight. I'm so sorry that he reacted that way not all of us obese people are like that.

usefully_useless - NTA. There are several moving parts here, but you did everything within reason here. 1) The chairs where originally designed with a weight capacity which would be threatened by a 300lb person.  IIRC, the highest capacity mid century chair is the Krueger Matrix, which was rated for a 450lb static load (which means a 300lb person shouldn't be sitting in it anyway,

since the dynamic loads could exceed the maximum capacity).  In the 60s, high end designers weren't engineering chairs to hold morbidly obese people. A brand new Eames molded chair varies between a maximum static load rating of 275 and 350 pounds, depending on the material of the legs.

ADVERTISEMENT

2) The chairs are old. Years of use and general aging have undoubtedly made the chairs more fragile than they originally were. They are still perfectly safe for normal people, but shouldn't be used by anyone approaching 300lbs.

3) Since you have good reason to worry about the chair holding your guest, it would be incredibly rude to knowingly let them risk the excruciatingly embarrassing experience of breaking their host's dining chair. 4) You can't reasonably be expected to purchase all new furniture in order to accommodate the one morbidly obese individual without forcing them to use a different chair than everyone else.

5) You didn't make this a big ordeal. They did when they blew up at you. Nobody would have remembered that they were too fat to sit in the same chair as everyone else had they just accepted your request. Now, everyone will remember the time that person wasn't allowed to sit in the same chair.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - NTA. Not at all. You approached him with discretion expressing a very understandable concern and he immediatly interpreted your request as discrimination.

[Reddit User] - Nta. Like someone pointed out here you approached the guy discreetly and he threw a fit because you “fat shamed” him when in reality you were rightly worried about your property and everyone who left is an a**hole for freaking out despite you inviting them into YOUR home

pinklambchop - NTA , no way you are but your sister and her bf areTA. Now,over the last 10 yrs I've gained 100lbs, I now have chairs even I won't sit in, but I love the way they look. You were direct, calm, and discrete, how is this considered fat shaming?

ADVERTISEMENT

Its Physics. What were you supposed to say? 'I'm sorry my chairs are a bit fragile, I'd hate for one to break, here's a more reliable chair? .sorry about the uncalled for drama by your guest! You did nothing wrong.

These Reddit zingers swing from practical to passionate, but do they miss the host’s intent? It’s not just about chairs—it’s about navigating touchy social waters.

This chair saga spins a tale of good intentions gone awry. The host’s bid to save vintage treasures clashed with a guest’s sensitivities, unraveling a celebration. Was it a misstep to single out one chair, or a fair call to protect what’s dear? Share your thoughts—what would you do if your prized possessions sparked a family feud?

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *