AITA for cutting of my BFs parents after they took our baby to get a paternity test?
The nursery glowed with soft light, but a shadow of betrayal loomed large. A young mother, still adjusting to life with her newborn, discovered her boyfriend’s parents had secretly taken their infant daughter for a paternity test, fueled by their belief she’s a gold-digger. Their wealth and judgment had long cast a pall, but this violation of trust lit a fire. Her decision to cut them off sparked a family storm, leaving her torn between fury and fairness.
Navigating class divides and new parenthood, the mother’s stand against her in-laws’ overreach resonates with anyone who’s faced meddling relatives. Readers can feel her rage—how dare they question her daughter’s paternity behind her back? This tale of broken trust and family tension dives into the messy clash of loyalty, boundaries, and the fierce instinct to protect one’s child.
‘AITA for cutting of my BFs parents after they took our baby to get a paternity test?’
Reeling from her in-laws’ intrusive actions, the Reddit user faced a painful revelation about her daughter’s secret paternity test. Here’s her story:
Trust is fragile, and this couple’s in-laws shattered it with a secret DNA test. The mother’s decision to cut contact is a fierce boundary, rooted in their class-driven disdain and violation of her parental rights. The grandparents’ initial generosity—buying baby clothes and offering childcare—seems tainted by their ulterior motive to question the child’s paternity. The boyfriend’s torn loyalty highlights a classic family power struggle, with the mother caught in the crossfire.
This reflects a broader issue: in-law boundary violations. A 2023 study from the Journal of Family Psychology found 70% of new parents report in-law conflicts, often over control or trust (source). The grandparents’ actions, possibly illegal without consent, underscore their disrespect for the mother’s role.
Family therapist Dr. Susan Forward notes, “Boundaries are essential to protect family integrity” (source). The mother’s cutoff is a valid response to betrayal, though the boyfriend’s plea suggests a need for dialogue. Their “apology” lacks accountability, doubling down on their bias.
The mother could propose supervised visits with clear rules, ensuring respect. The boyfriend should mediate, reinforcing boundaries with his parents.
Here’s the comments of Reddit users:
Reddit’s serving up some fiery takes, and they’re hotter than a summer barbecue. Here’s what the crowd had to say:
![[Reddit User] − NTA. “Good parents” would support their son in his decision not to question his daughter’s paternity, not get a DNA test behind his back. Plus, their apology was clearly fake if they were trying to convince you that what they did was right. They have proven themselves to be dishonest and untrustworthy, and who needs grandparents like that?](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/243712cmt-01.png)
![[Reddit User] − NTA. Your boyfriend needs to grow the F up. Bottom line is they've shown they can't ever be trusted alone with her - so if they ever want to see her again they'd better work HARD on repairing their relationship with you. Starting with a full and unreserved apology that makes the point, 'We had no right to do this. What we did was appalling and unforgivable.'. Not one more excuse.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/243712cmt-10.png)
![[Reddit User] − NTA I’m actually pissed that someone would even test an infant without either of their parents present and consent. If your boyfriend had been concerned he would have brought it up. His parents were completely out of line and imo you have every right to not trust them to be around your child at the moment.](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/243712cmt-11.png)
These Reddit opinions don’t mince words, but do they nail the core issue? Are the grandparents manipulative schemers, or is the mother’s cutoff too harsh?
This family saga proves trust, once broken, is tough to mend—especially when it involves a baby and class-fueled suspicions. The mother’s stand to protect her daughter is fierce, but the boyfriend’s plea for his parents tugs at reconciliation. Should she hold firm or give them a chance to rebuild trust? How would you handle in-laws who cross such a line? Toss your thoughts into the mix below—let’s unravel this family knot!
