AITA for choosing to get married where I live and not where my mom lives to be accessible for her and her husband to bring my stepsister?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In the heart of a familiar town, anticipation mingles with lingering resentment as one man gears up for one of life’s most important celebrations—his wedding. Memories of a childhood punctuated by constant relocations paint the backdrop of an event that is as much about reclaiming his personal space as it is about celebrating love. The echoes of past decisions, where family needs repeatedly overshadowed his stability, now form the undercurrent of an approaching life-changing day.

The wedding plans reflect not just a celebration, but a bold declaration of independence. Choosing to tie the knot in his hometown, he deliberately embraces the life he’s built rather than yielding to external pressures. His decision stands as both a personal statement of self-worth and an implicit refusal to let old wounds dictate the terms of his future, even if it risks fracturing family ties further.

‘AITA for choosing to get married where I live and not where my mom lives to be accessible for her and her husband to bring my stepsister?’

Maybe I (29m) will come across as an a**hole and I'm here to face if I am or not. Let me begin with some background. My dad died when I was 6 and it was just me and my mom for a few years before she met Dan. Dan was okay and they got married a little over a year after they met. I was 11.

A few months after my mom and Dan got married, Dan's ex said she wanted to move with their daughter to another state. Instead of saying no and fighting it Dan and my mom decided we would move to follow them and that had us moving 8 times in 5 years just so he could follow his daughter around. He never fought it in court and they uprooted me every time too.

I was resentful as hell. I was away from the rest of my family and chasing after a stepsister I didn't really care if I never saw again. I know my mom cared and Dan cared and they were married. But I felt so unsettled when we never knew how long we'd stay and Dan even admitted his ex didn't want us nearby so she'd keep moving when she could.

But then my stepsister and her mom were in an accident. Her mom was mostly fine but my stepsister was left with life altering injuries and became disabled to the point that she needs around the clock care. Dan and my mom put down roots in the last location and ended up with custody of my stepsister. They have devoted their time to caring for her.

While I moved when I turned 18. This was a source of tension between me and Dan because he had expected me to be there for his daughter and to one day take over her care. But I told him that would never be me. It made my mom sad to be away from me and she and I argued over my choice to leave and to hold a grudge against their decision to move so much.

She argued about wanting to keep the family together while I pointed out she tore me away from mine and removed my stability. I started dating my fiancée a decade ago and we got engaged last year. Our wedding is this year and we sent out some save the dates with some details on it for everyone.

My mom called and acted surprised that I was getting married in town where I live instead of where she and Dan are living. She told me my stepsister could not do that kind of commute and how did I expect them to be there. I told her if they could not make it I would understand but my life was here and this is where I would get married.

Dan called to tell me how selfish I am and how fucked it is to choose to marry somewhere my stepsister can't access. He said it would have been no big deal for me to go there for one day to get married. I hung up the phone on him because I didn't want to listen to BS like that.

My mom has brought the topic up some more and I told her I was not traveling just for them to be able to go. She got upset and asked me if I really felt okay with my only sibling not being there. I told her she didn't want to hear my honest response to that but yes I'm okay with Dan's daughter not being there.

I said I can live without her there if she's just going to come and tell me how I should've gotten married where she lives. She said it feels like my choice is a punishment for their decision to follow Dan's ex and daughter when we were younger and how she doesn't think that's entirely fair and especially not to my stepsister. AITA?

Letting your partner meet your family can feel like a monumental step in a relationship, but sometimes the journey to that meeting point is filled with personal sacrifice. Our storyteller’s struggle is a poignant reminder of how early experiences can cast long shadows over our adult decisions. His decision to forge his own path, even at the cost of family friction, is a clear statement of self-preservation and determination.

Analyzing the situation further, it becomes evident that the longstanding tension roots from repeated sacrifices made during a turbulent childhood. Having been uprooted multiple times to suit his family’s shifting priorities, he now faces a conflicting expectation: to honor a duty that was never truly his to bear. The emotional imbalance between familial demands and personal need for stability is at the core of his internal battle, challenging conventional ideas of loyalty.

Broadening the scope, this story touches on a larger, underlying social issue—that of prioritizing individual well-being over traditional family roles. Statistics from family relationship studies indicate that unresolved childhood disruptions can echo into adult choices, influencing how individuals manage personal boundaries. Such conflicts are not uncommon, and modern psychology increasingly supports the notion of self-care over unyielding familial expectations.

In the realm of relationship guidance, renowned expert Dr. John Gottman advises, “The secret to a lasting relationship is not about finding the right partner, but being the right partner.” His words underscore the importance of self-respect and active communication in resolving conflicts.

Applying his insight here, our protagonist’s decision can be seen as an act of self-empowerment, urging him and others to break free from regressive family roles and shape their own destinies. His stance offers a call for balanced relationships where both personal happiness and familial ties can coexist.

See what others had to share with OP:

The general sentiment among the Reddit community is one of clear support for the OP’s decision. Broadly speaking, commenters agree that after a lifetime of compromises and being overlooked, choosing a local wedding is a justified stand for self-care and autonomy.

They emphasize that family obligations should not force an individual to sacrifice personal happiness, especially when previous actions have repeatedly undermined his stability. In essence, the overall opinion is that prioritizing one’s well-being—even when it means disappointing family expectations—is not only reasonable but commendable.

StrangledInMoonlight − Oh honey.  . I am so sorry.  Your mom has continually chosen  Dan and Dan’s daughter over you.. And here she is, once again prioritizing them.  . That sucks. I hope your mom makes it. But even if she doesn’t, I hope you have a wonderful wedding, and I wish you all the best in life.  

SpiteWestern6739 − NTA, just because your mum chose her step daughter over you doesn't mean you also need to prioritise her over your own well being, your mum and Dan are huge assholes who seemingly only see you as a potential carer for Dan's daughter

TheLastWord63 − NTA. You can tell that your mom knew she was wrong for uprooting you so much as a child. Her response is an admission of her n**lect.

CryptographerHot8398 − NTA. This is your life, your city, your wedding. They put you second many times — now you're putting yourself first. That’s fair.

Prior_Incident344 − You had to move around to suit them now they can move for one day to your wedding. Why should all your other guests where you live have to travel to another town. They didn’t consider your needs in the past - you certainly are NTA.

SugarPlumWhimsy − It’s your wedding, and you shouldn’t have to cater to their past decisions or make huge sacrifices just to accommodate someone who hasn’t been a big part of your life. You’ve already compromised enough by trying to keep the family together, but your day should reflect your choices, not their expectations.

Buttered_Crumpet09 − NTA. Your mum really needs to understand what she's done. You had your entire life uprooted 8 times in 5 years so that she and Dan could follow your stepsister. Rather than fight in court, it was easier for them to constantly disrupt your life because they were both more concerned about your stepsister than you.

Not content with your childhood revolving around your stepsister, Dan then decided that you were going to be his daughter's carer. Never asked, never talked about, just decided that it was going to be your job, and when you moved out and showed that it wasn't going to happen, that your adult life wasn't going to revolve around is child, he got pissy.

Now you're getting married, and they once again are demanding that you make it all about your stepsister. Instead of getting married where you want to in your home, they genuinely think that your wedding plans should have been focused on Dan's daughter and what she needs.

Now, Dan focusing on his daughter, I get, but your mum is an entirely different thing. His daughter is meant to be his priority, but you were meant to be hers. You don't have a second living parent, you only had her, but she pushed you aside to focus on Dan's daughter over and over again.

Not once has she stood up and advocated for you or even considered you. The worst bit is that now she's basically going to miss your wedding because heavens forfend she put you first for one day. It's not like Dan could stay home and look after his daughter whilst she is there for you. Nope, she's still choosing Dan's daughter.

kindaright-ish − NTA. Tell your mum you don't see the point in making everyone you've invited travel to where they are just to make her and Dan's life easier once again. It's her turn to chase you. It's one weekend at most.

Logistically, it would be a nightmare to plan a wedding in a place you don't visit often or to rearrange everything you have already planned. Especially for one person you aren't fussed about being in attendance anyway.

PotatoMonster20 − NTA

LittleUnicorn89 − NTA. Your Mum has acted like she didn't give a crap about you most of your life. She didn't care about uprooting you constantly to follow her husband. A husband who's ex was clearly trying to escape him! His ex didn't want him around for a reason, and he forced himself into her life over and over.

So both your mum and husband are s**tty people. His daughter is not your sibling, not even a half sister. Tbh, for your own peace, consider blocking both of them and going no contact. Neither deserves to have you in their lives.

In conclusion, our storyteller’s journey invites us to question the extent to which we should sacrifice our happiness for family expectations. It challenges conventional norms and encourages embracing one’s individuality.

What would you do if you found yourself torn between familial loyalty and the pursuit of your own peace? Share your thoughts and experiences below—let’s start a conversation about finding balance in a complicated world.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *