AITA for chastising my son for selling the car we bought him for his birthday?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a sunlit suburban driveway, a shiny new sedan gleamed with promise for an 18-year-old’s birthday—a parental gesture brimming with pride. But the joy screeched to a halt when the son swapped it for a clunky, no-frills car, pocketing the profit. The parents’ hearts sank, feeling their thoughtful gift dismissed, while their son stood firm, prioritizing college savings over sentiment. This clash of values—generosity versus pragmatism—ignites a family drama that’s as relatable as a heated Thanksgiving debate, pulling readers into the emotional tug-of-war.

What happens when a heartfelt gift becomes a financial strategy? The parents grapple with feeling disrespected, while their son defends his choice with a steely focus on future stability. This story unfolds a universal tension: balancing emotional bonds with practical decisions, leaving readers curious about where to draw the line.

‘AITA for chastising my son for selling the car we bought him for his birthday?’

So for my son's 18th birthday my wife and I decided to buy him a car. We bought him a new sedan, it was a little over 30k. He was very appreciative, though he said he didn't need a brand new one. Everything was in his name.

Almost immediately he sells it to carmax and gets some old cheap no frills sedan with roll-up windows. We were floored, he said it was to help him pay for college, which was weird because we agreed we would help him split the costs.

He probably made at least 22k in profit from doing this. We feel this was a total slap in the face, and we told him how disrespected ~~he~~ *we* felt, but he said, and I quote, 'If I'm going to survive long-term in the 21st century, I need to save as much as possible.' Does this really mean you have to sell gifts other people give you?

EDIT: This thread has given us a lot to think about, and it isn't all that easy to draw a single conclusion from a thread this divided. We are going to have a candid conversation with our son, and if updates are permitted we will provide one. Thank you all for advice and perspectives.

Gifting a car is no small gesture—it’s a milestone wrapped in love and expectation. Yet, this son’s choice to sell it flips the script, revealing a generational divide. Dr. John Gottman, a renowned family psychologist, notes, “Conflict in families often stems from mismatched expectations” . Here, the parents’ hurt reflects their vision of a reliable car ensuring their son’s safety, while he prioritizes long-term financial security.

The son’s decision, though jarring, shows foresight. With U.S. student loan debt averaging $30,000 per borrower , his move to bank $22,000 is strategic, reducing future burdens. Still, the parents’ sense of betrayal is valid—gifts carry emotional weight, and selling one can feel like rejection.

ADVERTISEMENT

This situation mirrors broader societal shifts, where younger generations prioritize financial pragmatism over traditional gestures. The son’s logic aligns with economic realities, but his delivery—selling without discussion—stings. Gottman’s advice to “turn toward each other” suggests a family talk could bridge this gap, fostering understanding.

To move forward, the family should discuss expectations openly. The parents could acknowledge their son’s savvy while expressing their hurt. The son, in turn, could validate their intentions. Structured communication, as Gottman advocates, builds trust. Both sides can learn: gifts are about connection, but so is respecting each other’s choices.

ADVERTISEMENT

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit’s peanut gallery didn’t hold back, serving a spicy mix of cheers and jeers for this family saga. Some fist-bumped the son’s financial hustle, while others side-eyed his tactless move. Here’s the raw scoop from the crowd:

LtDan281 − NAH. I can see how this would rub you wrong, as I’m sure some time and planning went into selecting the vehicle, but you also need to take a step back and admire how smart this actually is (if he’s good on his word, of course).

ADVERTISEMENT

He’s investing in his future, and that’s a lot bigger than what kinda car he’s rolling around in. For an 18 year old, it sounds like he has his head screwed on pretty damned well, even if it may seem unconventional to others.

Mobile_Prune_3207 − If he's genuinely going to save the money then that's a smart move on his part. I agree as his first car he didn't need anything fancy. Money is more valuable than a car which loses its value every time you get behind the wheel.

CakeEatingRabbit − NAH. Splitting the cost would still put him in dept. 20.000 less dept is a lot.. My feelings would be hurt too but you should be a little proud of his decision too.

Fragrant_Fix − INFO: Was the son involved in choosing the present, or did you surprise him with a car?

ADVERTISEMENT

DevilishRogue − What kind of person spends $30,000 on another person without checking that this is what they actually want first? If you'd spoken and ensured you got a gift they wanted you wouldn't be facing this issue,

which is entirely of your own making, and could have instead, for example, given them a $5,000 car and $25,000 in investments if that is the sum you wanted to give them for this birthday. Not checking first is *entirely* on you. YTA.

doktornik − NTA. But I nunderstand him. Be grateful that you have a kid, who’s so smart about long term plans etc. now you know how concerned about his future he is and you can adopt your gifts accordingly. So many young people have no pension plans, no savings etc. it’s scary!

ADVERTISEMENT

DutchTinCan − NAH/ESH, but you both could've benefited from better communication. He could've been upfront about wanting to sell the car, rather than presenting it as a 'fait accompli'. After all, it hurts your feelings having put thought into selecting presumably a nice car for him. If you had communicated to him 'son, we'd like to buy you a new car',

he could've expressed he'd rather drive a beater and save money. Instead, you've now both hurt eachothers feelings, amd wasted a couple of grand in the process. I'm going on an assumption that you'll be hard-pressed to find a dealer who'll buy back for sticker value.. Whether the judgement is NAH or ESH is dependent on how harsh you are to yourself.

Help24-7 − YTA. It was a gift. You gave him a gift. You don't get to control what he does with his gift. Your son is also smart enough to realize at 18 ..he didn't need a brand new car ( don't forget he has to pay for the reg and maintenance...which is expensive on new vehicles). He knows he has to afford college, books, rent, etc....

ADVERTISEMENT

He knew the better investment was to drive a beater car and save the money to help further himself. Be proud of him. He really is thinking about his future and long term goals...most 18 year olds aren't at that point yet.

surfaholic15 − NAH. I get that you are upset. But who would be paying the insurance? Maintenance? Is his school in a higher crime area? Sure, brand new wheels are nice. They are also extremely expensive for young drivers.

Your son made a wise choice financially provided his used car is a reliable one. And having a solid plan for the profits is good thinking on his part.. Again, I can see why you would be miffed, but in this economy he made a good choice.

ADVERTISEMENT

JeepersCreepers74 − NTA. Yes, it was a gift and legally his to do with as he wanted, but he's still an AH for looking such a generous gift horse in the mouth. And as someone who drove a beater in college but a much nicer/reliable car in grad school, I disagree with those saying this was a smart financial move. He's going to have maintenance expenses that he never would have had with the new car.

It would have been better for him to drive the new car all through college and *then* sell it to pay off student loans. In addition, $20k is not that much in the grand scheme of college expenses, but having a reliable means of transportation can make a big difference in your life.

I feel like those calling OP an AH would still call OP an AH if OP now rescinded their offer to pay for half of college. Yet OP has just as much right to not give a gift as the son did to sell the one he received. Sometimes you can act within your rights and still be TA.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors weighed in with passion, some praising the son’s hustle, others roasting his lack of communication. But do their hot takes capture the full picture, or just fuel the family fire?

This tale of a sold birthday car peels back layers of family dynamics, where love and logic collide. The parents’ hurt and the son’s pragmatism both hold weight, making this a story that sparks debate. Clear communication could have softened the blow, but the son’s foresight is hard to dismiss. What would you do if you were caught in this family crossfire? Share your thoughts—would you side with the parents’ emotional investment or the son’s financial focus?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *