AITA for being upset at my wife for running away and leaving our son, when they were in danger?

Tiana Garrett Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Rain pelts the sidewalk as a family hurries home, laughter fading into a heart-stopping moment. A speeding car barrels toward a father’s wife and son, and in a flash, she sprints away, leaving their child frozen in the street. The father’s relief at his son’s safety turns to fury as he grapples with his wife’s panic-driven flight, a choice rooted in her own trauma but shattering to witness.

This story crackles with raw emotion—fear, betrayal, and love clashing in a single, terrifying second. The father’s anger is palpable, yet his wife’s tears reveal a deeper wound. Readers are drawn into a drama where instincts collide, leaving a family to pick up the pieces and question trust in the face of danger.

‘AITA for being upset at my wife for running away and leaving our son, when they were in danger?’

Last weekend, my wife Emily, our son Jacob, and I were walking home in heavy rain from the park. Emily was crossing the street holding Jacob's hand and I was walking a little back behind them. They were both rushing to get out of the rain and had gotten ahead of me.

When they were crossing the street, a car came speeding to the intersection much too fast and slammed on their brakes before the red light but hydroplaned in a deep puddle. And I watched in horror as my wife literally sprinted away, pulling her hand free of Jacob's.

He was frozen in place like a deer in headlights. The car got traction and swerved to a stop at the last moment and I ran over to Jacob. Emily was a ways away across the street. I was furious at Emily for running, and I confronted her when we got home and we could talk privately.

She started crying and saying she was terrified because her friend in college had been in a bad hit and run and she just panicked and ran. I said that I was terrified for Jacob too, how could she run and literally yank her hand away from him? She just kept saying she was so scared she wasn't thinking,

and I was saying that I don't care how scary something is, my first instinct was to protect my son. She stormed out of the house and went to stay with her friend, and ever since she's come back she's been refusing to talk about it anymore.

I want to talk stuff through, like honestly this has made me worried about leaving our son in her care alone, knowing she will put herself first to the point of leaving him in danger. AITA for being angry at my wife for running away and leaving our son in the street when a car blew through the intersection?

This street scare is like a lightning bolt exposing raw nerves in a marriage. Dr. Bessel van der Kolk, trauma expert and author of The Body Keeps the Score, explains, “Trauma can trigger automatic fight-or-flight responses, bypassing conscious control” (Bessel van der Kolk). Emily’s sprint, tied to her college friend’s hit-and-run, was likely an involuntary reaction, not a deliberate abandonment.

The father’s anger stems from seeing Jacob left vulnerable, a primal fear for any parent. A 2023 study from the Journal of Traumatic Stress notes that 1 in 5 adults may experience trauma-driven reactions, impacting relationships (APA). Emily’s refusal to discuss it suggests shame, while the father’s distrust reflects new doubts about her reliability. Both reactions are valid but divisive.

This highlights broader issues of trauma’s ripple effects in families. Dr. van der Kolk advocates therapy to process such triggers. The father’s instinct to protect Jacob is natural, but shaming Emily risks deepening her guilt without resolution.

ADVERTISEMENT

For solutions, the couple should seek couples therapy to rebuild trust, with Emily exploring trauma-focused therapy, like EMDR, to manage her triggers. Open dialogue, guided by a professional, can help them address Jacob’s feelings too. Supporting each other’s healing honors their love and protects their son.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

The Reddit crowd dished out a mix of empathy and tough love, like neighbors hashing it out over coffee. They wrestled with instincts versus intent in this near-tragedy:

[Reddit User] − NAH everyone reacted on instinct not intent. Don't be the a**hole who breaks their SO and makes their life hell for one bad choice in an emergency. She knows, she nearly caused her son to die, she feels guilty, she will probably always feel guilty. Even though she reacted on instinct. Can you move past this? Can you forgive her?

ADVERTISEMENT

Mars1040 − No judgement but you guys do need to talk about it. If it was frightening for her, **what about your son who almost died**? This situation triggers trauma for your wife, but it also created trauma for your son.

He'll remember this situation as his mother abandoned him to save her own skin. At some point, she's going to need to talk about this to him, if not to you. Everyone needs therapy in this situation.. EDIT: I wake up to my first ever **gold**?! Thank you!

ThePunchlineIsFunny − NAH. You can't blame her for giving into her instinct especially if it's coupled with a trauma, but no one can fault you for being worried about your son too. Worst case scenario something terrible could have happened,

ADVERTISEMENT

so you're justified for feeling at least concerned about it and I get emotion got in the way in that moment. Be thankful nothing bad happened and try to move past this while making it clear to her that you don't want to blame her.

invisiblebats − I'm going to say a very gentle NAH. Your wife had a horrifically traumatic experience, and she was reacting to that. She didn't mean her child harm. There was no malice involved at all. Shaming her for a response that was involuntary isn't going to make her change - it's just going to make her resent you.

Obviously you are upset. What you saw was terrifying. You love your kid. But you need to understand that your wife loves him, too. And she probably feels guilty as hell right now. I suspect that her reaction terrified her just as much as it terrified you.

ADVERTISEMENT

j027 − Please make sure Jacob is OK after this

Smart31069 − YTA. She just kept saying she was so scared she wasn't thinking, and I was saying that I don't care how scary something is, my first instinct was to protect my son. I was gonna say N A H up until here. Before this point, both your reactions were reasonable.

Your wife acted without thinking, fight or flight and all that, I'm sure she wouldn't leave y'alls kid behind on purpose. And if my significant other left our kid for dead of course I'd be mad, but that 'I don't care how scary something is' comment made you the a**hole.

ADVERTISEMENT

After she talked about what happened with her college friend and said she just panicked you could've ended it right there and said something along the lines of, 'I understand that it just kind of happened. Sorry about getting mad, I was just so scared for Jacob.' But no, you went on to say that you don't care about how it was beyond her control.. Apologize to your wife, man.

Niteynitenurse − NTA. She left your son to fend for himself in a dangerous situation, when as his parent she should protect him and care for him. Your wife needs someone to talk to, like a counselor, to resolve these issues, and figure out what she needs.

lamamaloca − NAH, in the day it happened. People are saying her reaction was instinctive, so was yours. But I also don't see how talking this through is going to help. She wishes she had a different reaction, but she didn't. What will talking help? What response do you want?

ADVERTISEMENT

LeMot-Juste − Force Majeure. NAH. No one can predict their automatic reaction to eminent danger. You can't hold this against your wife. Also, your son has to have a reaction to this. Focus on him, why not?

introverta100 − NAH, I get that you’re mad and terrified of what could have happened. I hate how people refer to “maternal instinct”, it really does not work how most people think it does. For one it is not an instinct but a learned behavior!. ...

As Darcy Lockman, psychologist and author of All the Rage: Mothers, Fathers, and the Myth of Equal Partnership told us, “Human beings don’t really have instincts. Primates don’t. We have a neocortex. There are animals that rely primarily on instinct to survive. Human beings are not among them.

ADVERTISEMENT

We have a more developed brain and we require learning to survive, which has made us more able to adapt to our environment. So, parenting skills are learned, not innate for males as well as females.”

To qualify as an instinct, the behavior should be automatic, irresistible, triggered by something in the environment, occur at some particular time during development, require no training, be unmodifiable and occur in all individuals of a species.. So few (if any) human behaviors qualified as ‘instincts’ that psychologists replaced the term with ‘drives’.

Yes, the idea of maternal instinct is largely a myth, says Dr Catherine Monk, psychologist and professor of medical psychology. The exception, she says, is that a person, no matter their gender or s**ual orientation, can gain early on and maintain throughout development, a keen sense of their child.

ADVERTISEMENT

But this ability is still different from maternal instinct. For example, a parent may quickly suss out the specific meaning behind the cries of their newborn. Psychotherapist, Dana Dorfman, PhD, agrees that many aspects of maternal instinct are a myth.

“A mother’s intuition or innate sense about the baby’s needs may be attributable to their experiences, temperament, and attachment style,” As parents connect and bond with their babies, Dorfman says they learn parenting skills through practice and experience.

While some of this process may be “unconscious,” she says it does not necessarily mean that it is instinctual. “When you become a parent, biologically, or otherwise, your brain chemistry changes,” says Dorfman. This doesn’t only happen to the person giving birth.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors saw both sides, urging compassion for Emily’s trauma but validating the father’s fear. Some pushed for therapy, others for Jacob’s well-being. But do their nuanced takes fully bridge this couple’s divide, or just stir the emotional pot?

This tale is a gut-punch of fear, love, and human frailty. The father’s anger and Emily’s panic reveal how trauma can fracture trust in a heartbeat. It’s a reminder that instincts don’t always align with duty. Have you ever faced a moment where fear overrode reason? What would you do to rebuild trust after such a scare? Share your thoughts below!

 

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *