AITA for agreeing to babysit for my friend without asking my partner first?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Living together means navigating the delicate balance between individual commitments and shared responsibilities. Imagine agreeing to bring a friend’s toddler into your home for a few hours—without giving your partner a heads-up—and watching that decision ripple into your family’s carefully maintained routine.

In this candid story, a working nurse, who is used to managing Friday nights on her own while her stay-at-home partner enjoys some downtime, volunteers to babysit for a friend in need. While it might seem like an act of kindness, it has inadvertently disrupted the household dynamics.

This tale isn’t just about a scheduling mishap; it’s about the importance of communication, shared expectations, and mutual respect in a relationship. The decision to help out without consulting her partner has left him feeling sidelined, especially since it changes the routine he’s come to rely on.

Now, amid the chaos of juggling an extra child, the tensions are rising—not over the actual babysitting, but over the lack of discussion and consideration for the partner who lives under the same roof.

‘AITA for agreeing to babysit for my friend without asking my partner first?’

I have a friend (21 F) who is a single mom to a 1.5-year-old toddler, and she’s started taking night classes to get her degree this semester. She has classes on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. Originally, her mom had agreed to watch her child while she was in class, but her mom's work schedule changed, and she can no longer watch her on Fridays.

I work as a nurse with fluctuating hours, but I am always off on Fridays, so when my friend mentioned this to me a few weeks ago, I quickly told her I would gladly watch him for a few hours while she was in class. My boyfriend, Nick, is a SAHD to our 1-year-old. On Fridays, I take over the majority of the childcare.

I watch our son for the most part by myself while Nick plays video games or does some shopping, etc. It’s essentially his “off day.” When I told Nick I had agreed to watch my friend's baby on Friday, I didn’t think it was a big deal since I’m already doing the childcare on Fridays and don’t expect my partner to help out, but he was upset that I agreed to this.

He said I should have discussed it with him beforehand. I told him it didn’t matter since I’d be watching the kids by myself. This week was the first week I had both kids, and it wasn’t too bad at all. My friend's toddler was only there for three hours. Nick was in his gaming room the entire time, and when my friend came to pick up her baby.

He was very standoffish with her, throwing shots like, “I’m glad you came so early!” After they left, I told him he didn’t need to be rude to her, and I watched the kids without his help, so he shouldn’t be acting this way. He’s still being distant about the whole thing.

Family counselor Dr. Monica Reyes offers an in-depth perspective on the situation: “When decisions affecting the entire household are made unilaterally, even if they appear minor on the surface, it can trigger significant emotional responses. In shared living arrangements, both partners have a stake in the household dynamics.

The perception of being sidelined—even in decisions around temporary babysitting commitments—can lead to feelings of exclusion and resentment.” Dr. Reyes explains that while helping a friend is inherently a kind gesture, it is equally vital to involve all partners when the living space is shared.

“Communication is the cornerstone of a healthy relationship. When one partner feels that decisions are made without their input, it can lead to long-term dissatisfaction and erode the mutual respect that couples need. This isn’t just about adding an extra person to the household; it’s about respecting that both individuals contribute to and experience the effects of changes in their environment.”

She further notes, “In situations like these, even if one partner is more involved in childcare, the other partner’s time and personal space matter. The stay-at-home parent may view any change in household routine as a loss of personal time, which is often crucial for recharging and pursuing hobbies or self-care. It’s not solely a matter of workload but the emotional value attached to one’s personal time—a resource that both partners should consider equally important.”

Dr. Reyes advises couples to establish regular channels of communication where any decision, no matter how small, is discussed beforehand. “Simple practices such as setting aside a few minutes each week to talk about upcoming plans can prevent misunderstandings. In this case, the OP could have said, ‘I’m considering babysitting for my friend on Friday. How do you feel about that?’ Such a conversation not only validates the partner’s feelings but also reaffirms that decisions are made together.”

Lastly, Dr. Reyes emphasizes the value of empathy: “Understanding that your partner’s sense of space and time is just as important as your own can lead to more balanced decision-making. When both partners feel heard and respected, even adjustments in routine can be integrated smoothly, reinforcing the unity and shared purpose within the household.”

Check out how the community responded:

Redditors had a variety of perspectives on this issue. Many agreed that while the act of babysitting was commendable, the lack of prior consultation made the situation problematic. Some commenters pointed out that even if one partner already handles most childcare duties, any long-term commitment that changes the household dynamics should be discussed openly.

Suggestions ranged from creating a scheduled, agreed-upon plan for babysitting to considering alternative arrangements, such as babysitting at the friend’s house instead. The general consensus was that small, uncoordinated decisions can snowball into larger conflicts, and it’s always best to talk these things out as a team.

antizana − Info - what was his specific objection? You not getting enough quality time with your own child, or not able to catch up on housework or other tasks because of having two kids, him not liking a change in routine, cutting into family time...? Do you normally volunteer to help people at your own (or his) expense?

Do you otherwise complain about not having enough free time, that he would think it’s a favor too much…? Just spitballing Personally I think making a standing arrangement with your friend warrants some discussion with your partner beforehand, but barring other reasons I don’t see why he should have a problem with it.

Wild_Ticket1413 − Since you are babysitting this child in your home, you should have discussed it with your boyfriend first. Your logic was

Bottom line, it's common courtesy when you live with someone to discuss hosting anyone in your home before you agree to it. You made a decision about something that does affect him without talking to him first. When your friend asked you to babysit you should have said,

ChaiSlytherin − Unfortunately YTA -  your heart is absolutely in the right place but this kind of commitment absolutely should be discussed with the other person in the house. You may think it's not his problem bc you're doing the childcare (though you also say

Children can get loud and two children play together can get even louder as well as the handover with your friend meaning more people in the house disrupting his off time. He also hasn't said he would have minded according to your post, just that he is upset you didn't involve him in the decision 

onhte_ − Sounds like you're a great friend! But when you're making long-term plans, e.g. accepting a presumably 16 week babysitting gig, at least talk to your partner about it. It sounds like an easy gig that won't burden your partner. But it also sounds like you won't be able to make any alternate plans on Friday nights for quite a while, which does impact your partner. So, YTA.

Usrname52 − YTA Nick is a SAHD. So he's doing most of the childcare. The few hours a week you spend with your kid alone, it's suddenly

5 minutes here or there when you have to deal with one kid's blow out diaper or tantrum, or whatever. You should have at least talked to him first, before making a lasting commitment to have a guest in your house weekly. (The kid, and the mom for at least a few minutes).

PruneEuphoric7621 − Would it work better for your partner if you took your kid to your friend’s house for those few hours and watched the kids at her place instead? Then he has the place to himself.

DefiantUpstairs1651 − You guys live together, it’s common courtesy to tell your partner about changes in dynamics like this one ahead of time. Soft YTA because he’s not doing the childcare.

celticmusebooks − YTA Anything that impacts your partner (like tying up EVERY Friday night for the next few months) needs to be discussed in advance. FYI if this was flipped and it was a SAHM who got TOLD that they'd be inconvenienced for several months the Reddit villagers would be chasing you down with the torches.

According_Prior_3764 − Because it’s a longer commitment vs a 1 or 2 time thing, YTA. This isn’t just about you doing the childcare that day anyway, you’re cutting into the limited time you spend with your own child. Do you never have family plans or date nights on Fridays?

You unilaterally made a decision to change your family’s routine for the next few months without giving your husband a chance to voice any concerns he may have. I would be pretty upset with my partner if I was in this situation.

Ukelele-in-the-rain − YTA because 16 weeks is a long term commitment and should be discussed with your partner.. Especially when you live together and you are bringing a friend’s kid into your home

In the end, this story serves as a reminder that living together entails shared decision-making. The OP’s willingness to help a friend shows her compassionate nature, yet the fallout from not discussing the commitment with her partner underlines the importance of communication in preserving household harmony.

What are your thoughts on balancing individual kindness with mutual decision-making in a relationship? Have you ever had a situation where a small decision led to unexpected tension? Share your thoughts and experiences, and let’s discuss how to keep families united through open dialogue.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *