AITA For asking my brother to not un-veganify my food?

Tru Nixon Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The kitchen hummed with warmth as a 24-year-old woman and her vegan fiancé, a professional chef, crafted a holiday feast for her family. Fresh pasta twirled, vibrant veggies simmered in a rich sauce, and golden rolls promised a meal to unite everyone at the table. Their goal was simple: showcase the joy of vegan cooking, tailored to please even her picky brother. As the aroma filled the house, anticipation bubbled—until a block of cheese hit the table, threatening to unravel their vision.

When her brother began grating cheese over his plate, the woman’s heart sank. Her gentle request for him to stop, citing their effort to create a shared vegan experience, sparked a huff of defiance, casting a chill over the dinner. This tale unfolds the delicate dance of personal beliefs, family harmony, and the quest for mutual respect around a shared meal.

‘AITA For asking my brother to not un-veganify my food?’

I (24F) have been vegan for almost 5 years, and was vegetarian before that. My family is generally supportive but when I was in high school and still living at home I often cooked my own meals, or just ate the sides because my parents weren't super in to cooking vegetarian.

In the past year or so my mom has really opened up to it and has been experimenting with vegan cooking as well which has been nice to talk about. I went home for the holidays earlier this year with my fiance, who is also vegan. My older brothers (26 and 28) still live at home with my parents.

My fiance is also a professional chef (I'm an okay cook but usually follow his lead), and we offered to cook a nice dinner for the whole family. My middle brother is a picky eater, but we made foods that are generally pretty well liked by the whole family.

We made fresh homemade pasta and rolls, my fiance made a delicious sauce with lots of veggies, and a big salad. We served the food and everyone agreed that it looked and smelled delicious. Then my brother goes to the fridge and gets a big block of cheese and starts grating it over his pasta.

I asked him if he would please stop, we were trying to make a vegan meal everyone could enjoy, and purposefully hadn't put in any foods he didn't like. He said he doesn't like to eat pasta without cheese (???) I said that since we had put in a lot of effort into cooking and it was disrespectful when we had intentionally made the food to be vegan,

in an attempt to show how good vegan cooking could be. He got huffy and said I was being too controlling. My parents remained neutral and didn't take either side. The mood of dinner was off to a bad start and remained uncomfortable.. AITA for asking my brother to not add cheese to a vegan dish my fiance and I prepared?

Family dietary conflicts can overshadow even the most intimate mealtimes, as this story shows. A woman and her fiancé wanted to share the joys of vegan cuisine, but her brother’s addition of cheese to his meal was a personal preference, not a lack of respect. Asking him to stop, while heartfelt, would have inadvertently imposed her beliefs on others. Both were right: she defended her efforts, he defended his freedom to eat.

Dietary differences often cause family tension, especially when they are tied to personal values. Many people view adding spices or cheese as a way to adjust a dish to their taste, not as a negation of the cook’s hard work. The brother may have felt controlled, making the mealtime atmosphere awkward.

Nutritionists advise that respecting other people’s dietary preferences helps maintain harmony. The woman can express her desire for a vegan meal first, but accepting personal adjustments will avoid conflict. A gentle approach, such as joking that “cheese can wait until next time,” can keep things fun.

ADVERTISEMENT

To resolve the issue, the family should openly discuss expectations before the meal. The woman can invite her brother to try the original vegan dish before adding cheese, creating understanding. Readers in a similar situation can consider being flexible with others’ preferences, keeping the peace. This story emphasizes balancing personal beliefs with respect, so that the meal is fun. Share your thoughts below.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit users largely viewed the woman as overstepping, arguing her brother’s addition of cheese to his own plate was a personal choice, akin to adding salt or hot sauce. They felt her request was controlling, especially since he wasn’t forcing non-vegan food on others, and noted that cheese on pasta is a common preference, not an attack on her vegan effort.

MGDarion − YTA. It’s his food that he has to eat. He’s not vegan. He’s not forcing you to put cheese on your food. Let him live his life.

ADVERTISEMENT

definitelynotborat − YTA. Grating some cheese on his own portion doesnt diminish the dish or the effort your husband put into it, and doesn’t affect you in any meaningful way. And yes, cheese 100% makes any pasta dish better.

comingtogetyoubabs − YTA - Vegan here and I do think you were being controlling. Adding cheese to his own portion is like putting hot sauce or olive oil - a matter of personal taste. Does it suck when people aren't more willing to try vegan food? Sure. But you know they aren't, so you can't hold them up to that standard.

alysou − YTA - let him eat his pasta with cheese! He's not making anyone else eat it. You wanted to make a vegan meal everyone would enjoy - and you wanted him to eat it even though he wouldn't enjoy it.

ADVERTISEMENT

Leaving aside the fact that cheese on pasta is an incredibly common thing (so I don't really get why you're (???) about it), people have different tastes and different things will taste different to them.

Dangerfyeld − YTA. As long as he's not adding it to everyone's food, you don't get to dictate how he eats his food. He isn't vegan and can grate some cheese if he so wishes. He doesn't have to abide by your vegan choice if he doesn't wish to.

[Reddit User] − YTA. To me, this isn’t different than someone adding hot sauce, salt, pepper, whatever else to their portion of food. Your moral imperative isn’t his, and your fiancé being a professional chef doesn’t make him the final authority on taste. If he had brought cheese to your vegan home, then yeah, that’d be an a**hole move,

ADVERTISEMENT

but he was availing himself of ingredients already available at the house. I get that you wanted to show off how great vegan cooking can be (and it definitely can be! I myself eat quite a lot of vegan meals.), but is calling out a bit of cheese really worth an otherwise nice family dinner?

[Reddit User] − Yta for making a big deal over nothing. If you cook for someone and they add salt and pepper to their preferred taste would you br offended? Probably not. Cheese is no different. I doubt he was trying to 'unveganify' it,

probably just make it more appealing for him personally. Everyone said it looked and smelled delicious, he gave the food the sign of approval so you made your point, vegan food is good. So how about you let him enjoy it and if it needs alterations so be it.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − Triple query marks after introducing the concept of pasta married to cheese leads me to believe you don’t know anything about food. (Presumably your professional chef fiance offered no opinion on the subject, otherwise he’s dumb, too.) This is none of your business.

People eat to satisfy a regular bodily need, not obey your self-imposed dietary guidelines or pay homage to your cooking. None of this is about you. Calm down. This is not your house. He is not a guest, and, if he were, you’d be doubly rude for policing his stomach.

You’ve adopted veganism and your brother is a “picky” eater, but somehow you think your choice trumps his habits. You actually planned to use the meal to try to prove his palate and his food preferences are wrong and under-informed. Get over yourself. The bums lost; condolences. YTA.

ADVERTISEMENT

CarpeCyprinidae − YTA. There's a place in hell for people who say 'you can't eat that because of my beliefs' where the that isn't illegal to eat.. Also, clearly, you failed in your stated intent to create a vegan meal everyone would enjoy.

HECKYOUXx − I would say YTA. I understand you are vegan, but if your brother likes cheese on his pasta than let him instead of trying to control what he eats. Unless he’s trying to get you to put cheese on your food it’s alright.

Some empathized with her desire to showcase vegan cooking but urged her to accept differing tastes, especially in her parents’ home. The consensus was that policing his plate soured the meal unnecessarily, suggesting she focus on shared enjoyment rather than enforcing her dietary ideals.

ADVERTISEMENT

This family’s dinner dust-up over a sprinkle of cheese reveals how quickly personal beliefs can stir tension around the table. The woman’s push for a vegan meal clashed with her brother’s simple preference, turning a labor of love into a standoff. As they navigate this rift, their story prompts reflection on balancing ideals with family harmony. How would you handle differing dietary choices at a family meal? Share your experiences or advice below—let’s keep the conversation going.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *