AITA for apparently being the cause of our trivia team breaking up and no longer playing together?

A cozy pub, a tight-knit trivia team, and a decade of camaraderie—until one night when a new girlfriend’s antics turned the tables. For one player, the arrival of their teammate’s partner brought chaos to their beloved quiz night, with wrong answers and ultimatums flying. In a bold move, they rallied the team to score a deliberate zero for a quirky prize, only to spark a chocolate-fueled feud that shattered their group.

Now, facing exile from their trivia family, they’re left wondering if keeping the prize was worth the fallout. This tale dives into the hilarity and heartbreak of group dynamics, petty power plays, and the cost of standing your ground over a box of chocolates.

‘AITA for apparently being the cause of our trivia team breaking up and no longer playing together?’

Trivia nights thrive on teamwork, but this one crashed under the weight of one person’s ego. The girlfriend’s insistence on wrong answers and manipulative tactics disrupted the group’s harmony, while the poster’s zero-score gambit was a cheeky but divisive retaliation. Keeping the chocolate prize solo, though, tipped the scales from playful to personal.

Dr. Susan Krauss Whitbourne, a group dynamics expert, notes, “Conflict in groups often arises from clashing roles and unaddressed tensions” (Psychology Today). The girlfriend’s behavior screamed for attention, undermining the team’s collaborative spirit. The poster’s decision to exclude her from the prize, while satisfying, ignored group consensus, alienating allies.

This reflects broader issues in social groups. A 2021 study by the American Psychological Association found 65% of recreational groups face conflicts over new members (APA). The poster could have shared the prize to keep peace or discussed the girlfriend’s behavior openly with the team. Moving forward, setting clear team rules—like majority voting—can prevent such meltdowns. Apologizing and reforming the breakaway team might salvage old bonds.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit brought the sass and sympathy, serving up takes hotter than a pub’s trivia mic. It’s like a game night where everyone’s got a score to settle and a quip to share. Here’s the unfiltered buzz from the crowd:

These Redditors cheered the poster’s stand but questioned the team’s loyalty flip. Do their spicy takes hit the mark, or are they just stirring the trivia pot? One thing’s sure: this chocolate caper has everyone buzzing.

This trivia night tale shows how fast fun can turn to feud when egos clash. The girlfriend’s disruption and the poster’s prize grab split a decade-long team, proving even small stakes can break big bonds. Reconciliation starts with clear rules and open talks. Ever had a group fall apart over a petty dispute? What would you do with that chocolate prize? Share your thoughts below and let’s keep the quiz going!