AITA because I’m tired of catering to one daughter?

A mother’s attempt to plan a family visit spirals into frustration when one daughter leaves her hanging for days, while the other responds with enthusiasm. For this mom, coordinating trips to see her adult daughters and grandkids, a 4-hour flight away, feels like a one-sided effort. She’s fed up with vague excuses and last-minute plans, but her husband’s laid-back approach only adds to her irritation. Is she wrong to expect more from her less responsive daughter, or is this a clash of personalities and priorities?

Interestingly, the situation highlights scheduling difficulties and how families deal with different communication styles and expectations. In addition to the mother’s frustration, the story raises questions about flexibility, control, and the emotional toll of family visits. With both daughters leading busy lives, the struggle to connect highlights a common challenge: balancing schedules and relationships.

‘AITA because I’m tired of catering to one daughter?’

Planning a family visit shouldn’t feel like pulling teeth, yet for this mom, it’s exactly that.

Everytime my husband and I make plans to visit our adult girls (2 both married and grandkids and a 4hr flight) I never get a response from 1 for days....

The contrast between the daughters’ responses isn’t the only divide—her husband’s carefree attitude adds another layer of tension.

30 days should be enough notice if we can visit. And there’s other family we visit with also. 7 days before trip and still just lame excuses with no definite...

The pressure of last-minute plans leaves her caught between family obligations and looking unreasonable.

But I like some idea of where and when to visit…… just over feeling rushed for the last minute ‘well, if you can make it’ plans, because then I look...

This mother’s struggle is about scheduling and a deeper conflict of expectations and communication styles.

The OP craves structure, likely driven by a need for control in coordinating complex family visits, while her daughter’s delayed responses suggest a more fluid approach to life. This dynamic isn’t uncommon, as families often grapple with aligning differing personalities. What makes it even more complicated is the husband’s relaxed stance, which may unintentionally dismiss the OP’s need for predictability, leaving her feeling unsupported.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “The success of a relationship doesn’t depend on whether conflicts arise, but on how they are managed” (Gottman Institute, 2020). Here, the OP’s frustration stems from unmet expectations, while her daughter may feel pressured by rigid planning.

ADVERTISEMENT

Alongside this, the daughter’s busy life—likely filled with parenting and work—may limit her ability to commit early. The social lens widens to show how modern families juggle packed schedules, where flexibility can be as vital as planning.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

The online crowd didn’t hold back, offering a mix of support, critique, and practical advice that sheds light on this family drama. From pointing out the OP’s rigid tone to suggesting ways to bridge the communication gap, the comments reflect a spectrum of perspectives—some sharp, some empathetic, and others downright witty.

These commenters weren’t afraid to challenge the OP’s approach, suggesting her expectations might be the real issue. Their takes are direct, urging her to rethink how she plans visits.

ADVERTISEMENT

kittymarch − “Catering to this daughter” when you are the one announcing that you’ll be showing up on a certain date and expecting to be sent a full itinerary of...

I had to laugh here. Guests usually get invited for visits, not just let hosts know when they are showing up.

diminishingpatience − YTA for the tone. "Everyone else caters to me and behaves exactly as I require them to, so why can't she? " is all I can hear.

ADVERTISEMENT

britthood − Are you just springing these travel dates on her before asking her about it beforehand? YTA, if that’s how you are playing it. I would personally be very...

I plan ahead, and have things scheduled months in advance. What if she already had something scheduled? When my mom wants to visit the question is, “I’d like to come...

anneofred − Doesn’t sound to me like she’s asking you to cater to her. In fact it sounds like you’re asking her to cater to you. That’s fine to plan...

ADVERTISEMENT

Sounds like you’re there often, so it’s not a once in a blue moon situation. It also depends on jobs, do they all have a 9-5 or do their scheduled...

Sounds to me like you don’t offer a lot of flexibility without threats to not see her, which wouldn’t really compel me to rearrange our family’s life either. It also...

The reality is your kids are different, function differently, and lead different lives. One may have gotten your plan everything to the minute months ahead of time gene, while your...

ADVERTISEMENT

You’re going to punish her for not being like you? Sounds like she responds to you, she just doesn’t give you the absolutes you demand of her…she’s got a family...

Stop breathing down her neck, it makes no one look forward to you coming. Why not just let go of the need for control and go with the flow a...

Your current mindset IS going to hurt your relationship with your daughter and grandkids. Is having every minute planned more important than that? Maybe try not planning every second for...

ADVERTISEMENT

This group offers a more balanced view, encouraging the OP to stick to her plans while being empathetic to her daughter’s busy life. Their advice is grounded and actionable.

Irrasible − **NAH** \- Some people are organized and some are not. Make plans with the daughter who responds and simply tell the other what your plans are. Then take...

Medusa_7898 − Why don’t you say “on Saturday July 5 I’d like to do xx with you and the kids. Will that work? ” Making the decision for her may...

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − Make your plans, let her know when you’ll be in town and when you have feee time. If she can’t see you, too bad. Don’t break your...

You’re busy too, even if it’s “vacation”. My BIL and SIL come to town and stay with FIL a fair amount. Including this week. It’s always last minute. But when...

Or if when we’re free, they aren’t, we’re not upset when they don’t break their plans. Sure, it’s sucks we don’t see them. But - we’re all adults and this...

ADVERTISEMENT

These commenters sit on the fence, seeking more context or pointing out ambiguities in the story. Their responses add a layer of curiosity to the discussion.

Autumn-987 − This is rather vaguely written and hard to follow.

RPG_Rob − 30 days may not be enough notice, depending upon the daughter's job, her husband's job. OP sounds like she needs the meticulous planning driven by someone with anxiety,

ADVERTISEMENT

because of the way she speaks about her husband being laid back. I wonder if this anxiety is what's affected the relationship with her daughters. I'd hazard a guess that...

Sixforsilver7for − INFO Are you giving her notice of a visit or asking if those dates work for her? With kids activities e. g. hobbies and friends birthday parties 30...

The community’s responses highlight a divide—some see the OP’s rigidity as the core issue, while others empathize with her need for structure, offering practical ways to navigate the situation without escalating family tension.

ADVERTISEMENT

This mother’s frustration reveals a common family struggle: balancing structure with spontaneity when planning visits. Her desire for clear plans clashes with her daughter’s laid-back approach, while her husband’s easygoing attitude adds another layer of complexity. The community’s feedback underscores the need for compromise—clear communication and flexibility could bridge the gap. At the same time, the story reminds us that adult children lead busy lives, and parents may need to adjust expectations to maintain strong bonds.

Have you ever faced a planning clash with family? How do you balance your need for structure with others’ unpredictable schedules? Share your tips for keeping family visits stress-free!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *