Classmate Demands She Break Up Her Best Friend’s Relationship Because Of An Eye Color ‘Eugenics’ Theory

One nineteen-year-old college student was just finishing a routine theatre rehearsal, when a classmate cornered her with a bizarre, racially charged interrogation. Standing in her sweaty rehearsal clothes, she expected a minor critique or some departmental gossip, but instead received a heavy-handed lecture on racial politics and her choice of friends.

The classmate, known for her performative social justice stances, accused the student’s lifelong friend of harboring “white supremacist” tendencies. The evidence? The friend and his girlfriend both had light-colored eyes, which the classmate claimed was a calculated attempt to engage in “eugenics.” She insisted the student had a moral obligation to force a breakup.

It was a jaw-dropping demand that blended performative activism with outright harassment, leaving the student questioning her peer group. As the summer progressed, the situation escalated into a relentless campaign of text messages. The classmate began rallying others in the theatre program, creating an uncomfortable environment of peer pressure. Want the juicy details? Read on to see how this drama unfolded.

Classmate Demands She Break Up Her Best Friend's Relationship Because Of An Eye Color 'Eugenics' Theory

Am i wrong for refusing to break up my friend's relationship because his girlfriend's baby might have blue eyes?

Okay, so I'm a Black girl (19f), and I do musical theatre at my college.

This happened over the past few days, and I still can't believe I have to even ask this, but here we are.

So, there's this white girl in the program.

I'm gonna call her Brenda, because I hate that name and it fits how she acts.

Me and Brenda aren't close, but we're friendly enough; we chat before rehearsals and stuff.

She's one of those people who thinks she's like super "woke" and makes it her whole personality.

You know the type.

The setting was as mundane as a college rehearsal space, yet the incoming accusation was anything but ordinary.

ADVERTISEMENT

So, after rehearsal one day, Brenda pulls me aside looking all serious, like she's about to tell me someone just died.

She says she needs to talk to me about something important, and that she's worried about my character.

I'm standing there in my sweaty rehearsal clothes, just wanting to go home, and she's looking at me like I'm supposed to be scared or something.

ADVERTISEMENT

I ask her what she's talking about, because I haven't done anything wrong.

Then, she drops this bomb that I should be ashamed that I'm friends with someone who's "white supremacist-leaning."

I literally laughed at her.

ADVERTISEMENT

I said, "Girl, what the hell are you talking about? I don't hang out with anyone like that.

I'm Black.

Why the f*** would I be friends with a white supremacist? That makes zero sense."

ADVERTISEMENT

She goes, "Your friend Connor." And I just stare at her.

Connor is this white guy I've known since middle school.

We grew up in the same town, did community theatre together, went to the same high school, and now we're at the same college.

ADVERTISEMENT

He's genuinely one of the kindest people I know.

He's a total theatre nerd like me, and he's always been super supportive of me.

He's been dating this girl Madison for like eight months now, and he's honestly the happiest I've ever seen him.

ADVERTISEMENT

I tell Brenda she's lost her damn mind; Connor is not a white supremacist.

And she explains why she thinks this, and I swear to God I'm not making this up.

An eye color match suddenly became a conspiracy theory of historical proportions.

ADVERTISEMENT

She says the reason Connor is "white supremacist-leaning" is because he's white with dark hair and blue eyes, and Madison is white with supposedly blue eyes.

I say "supposedly" because I've seen Madison's Instagram, and her eyes in pictures look like anything from gray to light blueish-green, depending on the lighting.

Sometimes they look straight up dark brown or hazel.

ADVERTISEMENT

But Brenda insists Madison has blue eyes, and that's the important part, apparently.

Brenda then tells me that if Connor and Madison stay together and have kids, they could have blonde-haired, blue-eyed babies.

And that's "white supremacist-leaning" because they're basically trying to create the "ideal" white race or whatever eugenics Nazi bullshit.

ADVERTISEMENT

She said I need to talk to Connor and make him stop the relationship, because it's my responsibility as his friend to not let him participate in eugenics.

I just stood there, and I think my mouth was hanging wide open.

I asked her if she heard herself talking.

ADVERTISEMENT

Like, did those words really just come out of her mouth? She got all huffy, crossed her arms, and said she thought I would understand because I'm Black and should...

Like she was doing me a favor by telling me this.

I said, "Brenda, you are actually insane.

ADVERTISEMENT

You want me to tell my friend he can't date a girl because she might have blue eyes and they might have kids with blue eyes? Do you hear how...

Here's the thing about Connor, though.

ADVERTISEMENT

I've known him since we were like twelve.

I've seen this man have crushes on all kinds of girls.

He had a huge crush on this Indian girl in eighth grade, and he was too shy to even talk to her.

ADVERTISEMENT

He dated a mixed girl for a few months junior year, and he was so nervous about meeting her parents he made me practice what he was gonna say with...

His first girlfriend in high school was a white girl with brown hair and brown eyes who broke his heart, and he listened to sad music for like two months...

Like, he has never had a type.

ADVERTISEMENT

He just likes who he likes.

Madison just happens to be white with light eyes.

It's not like he's out there with a checklist trying to find some blonde-haired, blue-eyed girl to start a "master race" with.

ADVERTISEMENT

He likes Madison because she's funny and she's also into theatre, and they have the same dumb sense of humor.

I told Brenda all of this.

I said, "You don't know him like I do.

He's not like that.

He's literally dated every race under the sun at this point." She said that doesn't matter because the current relationship is the problem.

I told her she was being ridiculous and walked away.

What started as an absurd backstage conversation quickly transformed into persistent digital harassment.

Now, she's been texting me all summer.

Like, every few days I get a new message.

She said I'm enabling white supremacy by not saying anything to Connor.

She said I'm part of the problem.

She said if I really cared about my community, I would step up.

A couple of other people in the program have heard about it, and some of them actually think Brenda has a point, even if she went about it wrong.

Which is crazy as f*** to me.

I'm not gonna tell my friend to break up with his girlfriend because they both got light eyes and might have light-eyed kids.

That's the dumbest thing I've ever heard in my life.

And I definitely don't think I need to explain his whole dating history like I'm his defense attorney just to prove he's not a white supremacist.

But Brenda keeps saying I'm turning a blind eye to eugenics and I should care more because of my own background, and honestly, I'm tired of trying to explain how...

I really don’t think this is a real problem, man.

Community Opinions

The community was absolutely astounded by the classmate's bizarre logic, with almost everyone urging the author to block and report her immediately.

u/Entire-Tonight-1463
Why not block her and if that’s not enough, report her to the program director?

u/hissyfit64 Reverse this all on her. Ask her if she thinks she can tell you what to do because she's white. Does she think white people have to help Black...

u/InternetRave
Id warn your bro connor, and tell brenda to stay away from you with this race hate sh. 

u/Imaginary-Summer9168 She’s harassing you at this point, and she’s singling you out based on your race with her insistence that it’s your responsibility to stop Connor from dating a white...

u/Shiel009
Brenda wants to date your friend. Tell the director or head of the department about her harassment

u/tinywhisker42
brenda got a weird vibe fr. your friend dont need that mess lol

u/thanto13 Tell here that you talked to Connor and he has agreed to wear brown contacts when he is intimate with his GF and this will prevent a blue eyed...

u/BreathOfLizard Honestly I'd go harder. "Are you seriously expecting me to strip a person of their autonomy because of a superficial feature they can't control? They were born with those...

u/COinAK Maybe she wants Connor for herself and she is trying to break up Connor and his girl because she wants him and is his stalker. Start asking if she...

u/LokiRook Brenda needs medication. That's a wild, bizarre, controlling take. My husband is a biracial Mexican but white passing AF. Like, could be cast in vikings even though he's not...

u/Silent_Foundation_62 this is so funny to me 😭 she sounds like a lot of the girls I knew in high school (ironically, they were all white) and had these huuuge...

u/trekgirl75 So using Brenda’s logic every white person with blue eyes and blond hair must not date/procreate with another blond blue eye white person to avoid being labeled a white...

u/Sitcom_kid
Oh my God she's out of her mind. That's not woke, that's sleep. Her brain is asleep.

u/remykixxx
This is harassment at this point. Block her. Report her to the head of your program.

u/That_Skirt1443
That’s a lot of words.
I think you should stop speaking to Brenda.

A few users also pointed out that the classmate's intense focus on the friend's dating life might point to a secret, unrequited crush.

Navigating the complex social landscape of college is already a demanding task without having to defend a lifelong friend's normal dating choices against extreme and illogical accusations. While standing up for social justice is incredibly important, conflating basic human genetics and eye color with historical prejudice crosses a major boundary into personal harassment.

The author's instinct to protect her friend's privacy and her own mental well-being is entirely correct, and she should not feel guilty for shutting down this bizarre campaign. Do you think the classmate genuinely believes her own extreme theories, or is there a hidden motive, such as a secret crush on the friend, behind her relentless texts? And how would you react if a peer pressured you to interfere in your friend's relationship? Share your hot take!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *