AITAH for telling my dad that I am not his wife?

A 15-year-old girl found herself in a heated car ride when her divorced father declared she wasn’t fulfilling her “duty” in the house. He expected her to cook for “her men”—him and her 14-year-old brother—and keep everything spotless, even adding that if she were his wife, she would comply without question. Shocked by the outdated gender roles, she fired back that she was not his wife, ending the discussion abruptly.

This incident highlights the lingering tensions in a split-custody home where the father lives with his kids half the time, while his girlfriend remains in another country. What started as complaints about gardening help escalated into sexist demands that left the teen questioning her chores and her response. In addition, the situation raises broader issues about fairness, respect, and evolving family dynamics in modern households.

‘AITAH for telling my dad that I am not his wife?’

The family setup involved shared custody after a divorce seven years ago.

For some background my parents got divorced seven years ago and my father has a girlfriend but she doesn't live in the same country as we. So it's basically me,...

So the other day I (15F) was in the car with my dad (49M) and he started complaining that my brother (14M) doesn't help him enough in the garden. I...

(The only chores I do is keeping my room and bathroom clean and doing everything regarding those 2 rooms, empty the dishwasher, set the table, do my laundry and fold...

The father’s complaints escalated into specific expectations about household roles.

Then came the moment that really stuck with me. He said that I wasn't fulfilling my "duty" in the house. I asked what he meant by that. He answered the...

and keeping the house clean for us." Then what REALLY bugged me was when he said "if I was your husband you would" to which I answered "well I am...

Now that I think about it I could do more around the house and I probably shouldn't have talked back to my father but it just seemed so unfair and...

Additional clarifications addressed common concerns and cultural context.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ps: no, my father is not a creep in a sxual way at all (ik the wife comment may sound creepy af) I have never had any problems with him...

[EDIT] To ask common questions:

1. Why is my age different here from my other post: my last post about my aunt was my first post on AITAH. This post had been deleted on other...

ADVERTISEMENT

I wasn't willing to risk my post being deleted for nothing again so I changed my age from 15 to 18. Now that I read the rules of this sub...

2. Note that I am only half of the time at my dad's and that my parent have half custody of my brother and I.

3. For everyone asking, my mother is a wonderful parent and I could live with her if I wanted to but u don't want to loose my relationship with my...

ADVERTISEMENT

4. For everyone wondering if it's a cultural thing or related to where i live, it's not. We live in France and have no culture or religion that enforce any...

Sexist expectations in family chores can erode trust and self-worth, especially for young teens navigating divorce.

The father’s remarks reveal a outdated view where daughters substitute for absent partners in domestic labor, ignoring shared responsibility. Opposing views might argue he simply wants more help amid solo parenting half the time, yet this ignores why the burden falls solely on the girl while her brother escapes similar demands. What makes the story more complicated is the partial custody, limiting his oversight and amplifying frustrations, but it doesn’t justify gender-based assignments.

ADVERTISEMENT

From a broader social perspective, such dynamics perpetuate inequality, teaching kids that household contributions tie to sex rather than fairness or ability. In addition, they risk straining parent-child bonds during vulnerable adolescent years.

As family therapist Dr. Laura Markham notes in her book Peaceful Parent, Happy Kids, “Children thrive when chores are assigned based on capability and family needs, not gender stereotypes, fostering equality and respect” (source: Aha! Parenting website).

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Many social media users rallied behind the teen, stressing equal chore division and rejecting sexist norms.

ADVERTISEMENT

Spiders_Please − You should not be keeping the house clean on your own. Everyone should be responsible for their own private areas (bedrooms, bathrooms, and laundry) and share in taking...

Your brother needs to learn how to cook and clean after himself because that is what adults do. Please do not marry a lazy person who expects you to do...

Starfoxy − "you should be in the kitchen, cooking for your men (meaning him and my brother) and keeping the house clean for us. " Not surprised he's divorced with...

ADVERTISEMENT

Mitten-65 − Why is the house work your job? Why not your brother? Only one year difference in age. He can cook and clean.

A smaller group offered nuance, suggesting practical solutions while acknowledging the father’s potential stress.

Fluffy_Cappuccino − NTA. I dealt with this as a kid of divorced parents. My dad would call me the “galley queen” as a way to get the kitchen cleaned. Him...

ADVERTISEMENT

My brother could clean one night, i could clean the other night. Or if my brother’s chore was to take out the trash I was like I’ll do the trash...

It totally changed the way they looked at the chores and genders and our roles in helping. I’m a middle aged woman now and still think this was the best...

Others injected humor to lighten the mood, focusing on the absurdity without mockery.

ADVERTISEMENT

Monster00km − This was a roller coaster that I loved. I mean, okay, fair enough. I literally cackled. Hilarious. The only chores I do is keeping my room and bathroom...

make sure to leave no mess around the house and cook a small part of every meal like the salad But then you followed it up with a bunch of...

He said that I wasn't fulfilling my "duty" in the house. Then, I got Mad. Bc I knew where this was going. Like wtf. Women are not servants. "if I...

ADVERTISEMENT

You are not. But more accurately, you are not his MOM. These are things Mothers do for their children. Girl. Nta. He is. Women are not servants. If he wants...

Some comments with many different opinions come from readers.

RandomReddit9791 − NTA. Your father's comments were sexist. If more needs to be done around the house, everybody should be pitching in. You being a female should have nothing to...

ADVERTISEMENT

ThatShortchick_1 − Wait how come in your other story about the aunt 38days ago you’re 18 but here your 15?? ?

Scary-Tip9701 − Not to be rude, but I see why your parents split

Echo-Azure − It's absolutely creepy and deeply sexist that he's expecting you to take over all the housework, and demands nothing of your brother, and this from someone who empathizes...

ADVERTISEMENT

Housework sucks, nobody wants to do it, not even housewives. So, tell him you insist on taking over the yard chores, and that if he wants someone to do the...

Candid_Island_5280 − NTA! I had the same comments said to me by my parents! Like what? They wanted me to cook and clean and do their laundry. Keep their house...

ADVERTISEMENT

They wanted me to even take care of their kids. Plus I had to help pay bills. They sucked so bad as parents. I had to do everything around the...

By the time I was 18 I was FED UP! I was kicked out for not having a job🥲. They literally kicked me out without any shoes on and kid...

This was 12 years ago. I’m 30 now and I have my own home (married with kids). But the comments haven’t stopped! My mom has this cousin whose kids helped...

ADVERTISEMENT

My mom has said that she has better kids than her because they pay for their parents to live with them. And I don’t 😂. If only she knew that...

The post centers on a teen’s clash with her father’s sexist chore expectations in a divorced, shared-custody home, where she already handles multiple tasks but faces demands framed around gender. Her sharp retort highlighted the unfairness, though she later reflected on possibly contributing more and avoiding backtalk.

How might families fairly distribute chores in split homes without falling into old stereotypes? What strategies have helped you address similar imbalances with parents or siblings?

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *