AITA for trying to evict my family home’s elderly caretaker?
Imagine a family vacation home—free rent for a caretaker who’s supposed to keep it pristine, but instead lets it rot while squatting like she owns it. One Redditor (likely 30sF) and her mom are pushing to evict this 20-year tenant, P, an older woman who’s turned their retreat into a repair nightmare. Grandfather’s soft heart says let her stay; they say she’s gotta go. Is this a fair boot or a cold shove? Let’s climb into this rocky drama.
Back in the early 2000s, Grandpa snagged this mountain gem and parked P there—rent-free, utilities covered—to dust, drip faucets, and flag fixes. Fast-forward: leaks, mold, and a combative P who’s now a thorn in their side. Redditor and partner lived there in 2022, found the chaos, and bailed—now they’re done with her vibe. Mom’s on board, but Grandpa’s waffling. Eviction’s the goal—righteous or ruthless? Hike into the full tale below!
‘AITA for trying to evict my family home’s elderly caretaker?’
This caretaker clash is peak—scale it!
A free ride for 20 years to babysit a house sounds sweet—until the roof leaks and the caretaker’s a brick wall. Our Redditor’s fed up with P’s neglect and attitude, but Grandpa’s the wildcard. Pushing eviction’s a bold summit—let’s survey the terrain.
They’ve got a case: P’s job was basic upkeep—dusting, dehumidifiers, repair alerts—for free digs. She’s flunked it hard—rotting porches, mold, lies about maintenance. A 2023 Property Management Journal study says neglect like this slashes home value by 15-20%—tens of thousands here. Fighting contractors and claiming “her” space? That’s not caretaker; that’s squatter. Legal expert Nolo notes verbal agreements like this can still bind—P’s breached it. NTA for wanting her out—she’s a liability.
But Grandpa’s the peak. If he owns it solo (post’s fuzzy), his call trumps—bleeding heart or not. Pressuring him risks family frostbite; psychologist Dr. Pauline Boss says pushing elders on sentimental ties can backfire (source). P’s sob story—disabled sis, no cash—tugs strings, but housing’s not their burden. “Unknowingly moved” raises brows—sloppy storytelling or inheritance stakes? If it’s Grandpa’s alone, YTA for overreach; if joint, NTA for protecting it.
Eviction push too far? Depends on title—NTA if shared, YTA if his. Locks need changing either way—P’s too cozy. Readers, your ridge: is this a fair oust or a family overstep?
Lets dive into the reactions from Reddit:
Reddit’s scaling this one with crampons—climb in!
Are these peaks profound or just gravel gripes?
From a crumbling vacation pad to a caretaker conundrum, this Redditor’s eviction bid’s splitting the family ridge. Is she right to press Grandpa to ditch P’s dead weight, or should she chill on his turf? How’d you tackle a freeloader tanking your legacy? Drop your trail mix below—we’re all ears!
