AITA for not being willing to split my daughter’s education fund with my stepson?

Gregory Houston Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy suburban home, where family photos line the mantel, a storm brews over a college fund. A woman, caught in the tangled web of blended family loyalties, faces a heated demand from her husband: split her daughter’s carefully saved college fund to bail out his son’s looming student debt. The air crackles with tension as she stands her ground, protecting her daughter’s future. Readers, brace yourselves for a tale of financial fairness, family friction, and tough love that’s got Reddit buzzing with opinions.

This saga unfolds with raw emotion, as the woman grapples with her husband’s accusations of favoritism. Can she balance love for her stepson with her duty to her daughter? The Reddit community has plenty to say, and we’re diving into this drama to unpack the clash of expectations and obligations in a modern blended family.

‘AITA for not being willing to split my daughter’s education fund with my stepson?’

My daughter(15F) has a 529 that my ex husband and I set up and have been paying into. She has about 73k in there for her college. My ex husband and I broke up amicably so we still have been contributing jointly. My current husband and I started dating 6 years ago and got married 3 years ago.

His son (18M) is attending college this fall and is paying out of pocket. His ex wife and him apparently didn’t save anything for him son and so he has to take out loans. He brought up the idea of splitting my daughter’s college fund with his son because she is a few years from needing it so he though I could take out half of what I put in to give to him.

I told him I’ve been paying for my daughter way longer than we’ve been together and she knows there’s money set aside for her schooling no one is entitled to it but her. He laughed it off and accused me of being too serious. Last night though he brought it up again,

and got more demanding saying his son is going to be stuck with a ton of debt and Ive known him since he was 12 and I have an obligation to help. I told him he has to help his son and I never agreed to help his son pay for college especially not though my daughter’s fund.

He got angry and accused me of not loving his son otherwise I would be sharing the college fund and drove off. He came back after a few hours and apologized and then this afternoon after work brought up me helping his son with college again which I shot down and he got angry at me for again.

Navigating blended family finances is like walking a tightrope in a windstorm. The woman’s refusal to split her daughter’s 529 college fund with her stepson has sparked a classic clash of loyalty and responsibility. Her husband’s demand overlooks the fund’s purpose, set up years ago with her ex-husband for their daughter’s future. His insistence, laced with accusations of unloving behavior, feels like a pressure cooker ready to pop.

This situation highlights a broader issue: financial planning in blended families. According to a 2023 study by the National Center for Family & Marriage Research, over 40% of remarried couples face disputes over stepchildren’s financial support. Clear boundaries are crucial. Dr. Patricia Papernow, a renowned psychologist specializing in stepfamilies, notes, “Stepparents are not obligated to financially support stepchildren unless explicitly agreed upon” (source: Psychology Today). Her insight underscores the woman’s stance—her daughter’s fund is a prior commitment, not a shared resource.

The husband’s failure to save for his son’s education, while expecting his wife to cover the gap, shifts blame unfairly. Legally, 529 plans are designated for specific beneficiaries, and diverting funds could violate agreements with her ex-husband, risking legal repercussions. The woman’s firm stance protects her daughter’s future while highlighting her husband’s lack of foresight.

For solutions, open communication is key. The couple should discuss financial expectations early, perhaps consulting a financial planner to explore options like scholarships or part-time work for the stepson. Setting boundaries now prevents future resentment. Ultimately, love doesn’t pay tuition—planning does.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit’s hive mind didn’t hold back on this one—here’s the tea, served with a side of wit and wisdom.

lossforcause − NTA His son isn’t entitled to the fund that you and your ex-husband is funding. Your ex-husband isn’t doing that for him, he’s doing it for his daughter. He could ask you to currently help his son out but even then if you say no it’s not fair for him to get mad

confidentialjd − NTA - his poor planning is not your problem. He's had 18 years to plan.

ADVERTISEMENT

Comfortable_Cut_8751 − NTA. And draw a line in the sand, make sure your husband knows that the money will NEVER be going towards his son. AND he should NEVER ask again.. Seriously, draw that line in the sand. I'm mad that he's already brought it up so many times. Good on you for standing your ground.

If your husband won't listen, have your ex-husband spell it out for him clear as day, because he put in money into that too. I'm sure your ex would be livid, your daughter would be livid, and you need to be livid. This has nothing to do about loving your stepson. You can love him with all your heart and still not s**ew over your daughter.

thatsharkchick − NTA. Other people have brought up good moral points, so I'm going to focus on a legal one. If you and your ex created the fund together, he has a say in the dispensation of fund outside of intended purpose (for your daughter). Pulling funds without his approval can get you into serious trouble and may greatly sour your relationship.

ADVERTISEMENT

Unfortunately, when blending families, there are prior arrangements or legal agreements that HAVE to be upheld and respected no different than custody arrangements. If your bf doesn't understand this, he needs to learn quickly, or you'd be better suited moving on.

barbiegirlshelby − His son’s education is not your problem. That’s something he and his son’s mother should have been saving for. They didn’t but it still isn’t your problem. It’s like that expression “poor planning on your part doesn’t constitute an emergency on mine”. Don’t let him do this and if he keeps this harassment up you may want to rethink his place in your life. NTA

[Reddit User] − NTA.. It's on him and his ex if their son has to take loans for college, not on you.

ADVERTISEMENT

AccessibleBeige − NTA. Why in the world didn't he bring this up 3 years ago when you and he got married? And has he been contributing to *your* daughter's college fund? Did he ever even offer? If not then he clearly intended to leave the funding of her education to you and her father, and should have expected to pay for his own kid's education with the help of his son's mother.

BazTheBaptist − NTA not only have you been saving up for longer than you've known him, so has your ex. If not giving his son money for college means you don't love him wtf does it mean that he's had 18 years to do that for his son and hasn't

the_owl_syndicate − I have an obligation to help. His biological parents had an obligation to help him and they failed to do so. That's on them, not you.. accused me of not loving his son. So what's his excuse for not saving for his son's college? Is he admitting he doesnt love his son? Your daughter's fund is hers, you saved it for her. Hubby should have done the same for his son. His emergency is not your responsibility.

ADVERTISEMENT

newbeginingshey − Woahhhh Surely your daughter’s 529 money, as it was valued at the time of the financial settlement, and the handling of the account - whatever its future balance - was spelled out in contractually binding detail in your divorce?? Tell your current husband you’re not risking breach of contract or contempt of court to pick up his son’s very predictable tab that he and his ex failed to plan for.

NTA but wtf? This man got divorced himself. When a random commenter on Reddit doesn’t understand custody, divorce, a child’s right to their parents’ (not step parents’) financial support, I figure “eh, why would they 🤷‍♀️” but this guy??!! He knows. He gets it. He’s just hoping to intimidate you into risking it all for his son anyway. Holy heckin Bob 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

These spicy takes from Reddit cut straight to the chase, but do they hold up in the real world? One thing’s clear: the internet’s got no chill when it comes to family funds!

ADVERTISEMENT

This tale of college funds and clashing loyalties leaves us pondering where duty begins and ends in blended families. The woman’s stand for her daughter’s future sparked a firestorm, but was she right to hold the line? Financial fairness isn’t just about money—it’s about trust and expectations. What would you do if caught in this family feud? Share your thoughts below—have you faced a similar dilemma in a blended family?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *