AITA for kicking my pregnant roommate out?

A quiet house near a bustling college campus became a haven for a 26-year-old homeowner and his lively roommate, Amy, a 21-year-old student. Their easygoing bond, forged over two years, hit a snag when Amy shared she was pregnant, her eyes bright with plans to keep the baby.

Shock turned to tension when Amy assumed her landlord-turned-friend would embrace a crying infant in their shared space. His firm stance—no kids allowed—left her in tears, clinging to a fantasy of co-parenting. Now, as he offers her another apartment, the air grows heavy with hurt and hard choices.

‘AITA for kicking my pregnant roommate out?’

Evicting a pregnant roommate is a gut-punch decision, but the homeowner’s clear boundaries collide with Amy’s rosy assumptions. Her vision of raising a child together suggests a misread of their platonic closeness, while his dislike of kids underscores a lifestyle clash. This isn’t just a roommate spat—it’s a lesson in unaligned expectations.

Pregnancy often amplifies housing stress. A 2023 HUD report notes that 20% of young single mothers face housing instability, often relying on informal arrangements like Amy’s (source). Her emotional plea and offer of intimacy hint at desperation, not manipulation, as she faces motherhood alone.

Dr. Susan Newman, a social psychologist, says, “Unspoken assumptions in close relationships can breed conflict when life changes” (source). Amy’s fantasy of co-parenting reflects this, ignoring his stated boundaries. His offer of an apartment and support until birth is generous, though risky if she clings to false hopes.

To resolve this, he should formalize the move-out timeline, ideally with a lease for the new apartment to avoid legal entanglements. Amy needs support—perhaps he could connect her with local resources for single mothers.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit’s got some spicy takes on this roommate drama—check out the community’s unfiltered reactions:

From cheers for boundaries to raised eyebrows at Amy’s assumptions, these comments stir the pot. But do they miss the emotional undercurrents?

This saga of a baby bump and a bruised friendship exposes the raw edge of personal boundaries versus human compassion. The homeowner’s right to a child-free home clashes with Amy’s vulnerable plea, leaving no easy answers. His apartment offer softens the blow, but her tears linger. What would you do—stand firm or bend for a friend in need? Share your take below and let’s unpack this messy, human moment!