AITA for refusing my sister’s offer to be in her bridal party and not giving an explanation?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A family wedding should be all about love and celebration, but for one 26-year-old man, it’s a tangled web of guilt and unspoken truths. When his sister asked him to join her bridal party, he hesitated, then declined without a word of explanation, leaving her fuming. Behind his silence lies a heart-wrenching secret: he fell for her fiancé while caregiving during a tough recovery, a bond that grew too deep, too fast, and now threatens to unravel family ties.

This story is like a quiet storm brewing at a family reunion, where every smile hides a secret. Readers can feel the weight of his choice—loyalty to his sister versus the ache of forbidden feelings. As Reddit dives into the drama, the question looms: is he wrong for keeping his heart under wraps, or is silence the kindest betrayal?

‘AITA for refusing my sister’s offer to be in her bridal party and not giving an explanation?’

I (26m) fell in love with my sister's partner. This began around a year ago when my sister had to travel for work for an extended period of time and her partner got into a pretty bad car accident just a week after she left. Without going into too much detail about his injuries, he needed someone staying with him and helping him get around for a while.

I do freelance work from home to support myself, so they asked me if I could go and stay in their home for a while as her partner's temporary caregiver while he recovered. I immediately agreed, wanting to help in any way I could. Her partner and I were already good friends prior to this situation, but living with someone and being there in some of their most intimate moments obviously strengthens a bond even further.

We bonded over our many shared interests and got to talk about deeper things that were typically off limits in a group setting. By the time I realized my changing feelings, it was too late to distance myself from the situation. I had committed to helping him for the duration of his recovery and a sudden change in my behavior would just tip him off that something was wrong and add unnecessary stress to an already hard time.

He had expressed feeling like a burden more than once. So, I pulled away the little bit I could and we rode out those last few weeks together before he was back on his feet again. To make a long story short, the period that followed was full of guilt from me and confusion from my sister's partner by my quick disappearance following our time together.

He eventually texted me and asked if he had done something wrong during our time together and pissed me off somehow, so we met up and I came clean. The conversation was a brutal one and it eventually ended in both of us agreeing we would limit our time together from now on as there was no hope for an actual future for us - it would simply be too weird given the history.

Fast forward to now. The two of them got engaged somewhat recently and this past Saturday, my sister asked me to be in her wedding as part of her bridal party. I asked her to let me think about it (which already caused some tension)

and finally told her yesterday that I was incredibly grateful for her offer but I had to turn it down. I'm fine attending as a guest, but being in the party just feels too much. She is now furious with me and is demanding I give her an explanation at the very least, something I have refused.. AITA?

Falling for your sister’s partner while nursing him back to health is a plot twist no one expects. This man’s emotional entanglement, born from intimate caregiving, led to a confession and a mutual decision to step back, but his refusal to join the bridal party without explanation has ignited family tension. His sister’s anger is understandable—she senses a rift but lacks the why, while he’s wrestling with guilt and loyalty.

Research shows 30% of people experience unrequited or complicated romantic feelings within family circles, often tied to close proximity (Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 2023). Dr. Esther Perel, a renowned psychotherapist, notes, “Unspoken feelings in families can create a shadow of mistrust, especially when loyalty is questioned” (The Guardian, 2024). Here, the man’s silence protects his sister but denies her clarity, risking further hurt.

ADVERTISEMENT

He’s not wrong for declining the role—his feelings make it untenable—but withholding the truth may deepen the wound. A private, honest conversation with his sister, perhaps with a therapist’s guidance, could foster healing.

Take a look at the comments from fellow users:

Reddit’s got opinions hotter than a wedding toast gone wrong, and they’re not holding back on this emotional quagmire! Here’s what the community had to say:

ADVERTISEMENT

IAmSpellbound - YTA for having an emotional affair with your sisters fiance for sure. Was it just emotional though? Did you sleep together? You already admitted the feelings were reciprocated, why stop now? Your poor sister though. She deserves better than this. Grow a pair and tell her the truth. Don't let her marry someone who doesn't love her back.

[Reddit User] - INFO. So did her partner have feelings for you? Did her tell her about your conversation?

ADVERTISEMENT

Zestyclose-Market858 - Kind of surprised by the vehement response, don't know why though. This is a hard one, maybe above reddit pay grade. I'm no psychologist, so with a grain of salt, but I do believe there are many sorts of bonds that people can form when there's a relationship or dynamic of helpless-helper. I think sometimes that dynamic lead to interdependence which can lead to feelings of attachment, romantic or otherwise.

Maybe you just really like feeling needed, and he likes aspects of being taken care of or nursed in some way. These sorts of bonds can be intense, but often unhealthy.. Overall, nta for developing feelings, as that's outside of your control. As to whether you should inform your sister of this emotional affair you two had is trickier. Probably keeping your distance is a good start, as it seems you've been doing that, and see if the feelings fade.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - NAH. So here's the thing. Florence Nightengale syndrome is a thing, where someone giving care falls in love with their patient. Transference is also a thing, where a patient falls in love with their caregiver. They're all feelings based on the fact that aspects of caring for a person, or being cared for, in a medical situation are, by nature, extremely intimate.

I'm not saying both of your feelings boil down to simply this, but it literally sounds like the classic presentation of both. It's a trope for a reason. 😅 You talked about it like adults, were honest, and you both decided to walk away. You can't help what you feel, but you can help what you do, and you're doing the things socially considered correct. All that said, if you have a therapist, talk to them about this. They'll be able to help you cope.

_Nunya_Biz_ - Wtf did I just read? I'm so confused I can't even make a judgement.. This is a no win situation. You tell her, that would be terrible. You not telling her sucks too.. Good luck. Hope everything works out.

ADVERTISEMENT

coloradomama111 - YTA for the way this is going to play out.. For originally developing feelings? NTA. For admitting them? YTA For then hiding the fact that your sister’s now fiancé admitted to having feelings back, and that y’all met in secret to discuss, and that now you’re just going to let her marry someone who has had an emotional affair? MAJOR AH. Mistakes were made, my dude.

makinbaconCR - Lol YTA in the first sentence I stopped reading Fell in love with their soon to be husband? What are you a love struck 13 year old? Get over it. Your sibling deservs better. If this is real. I hope they find out quick.

saucynoodlelover - Honestly; I think this is the wrong sub for this dilemma, and OP would be better served in r/relationship. It looks to me that OP has tried to make what seemed like the decent choice at each turn—helping out a sibling’s partner, distancing himself when it got emotional, explaining why he was creating distance, and staying away. I don’t think it’s fair to blame OP for the other guy returning OP’s affections,

ADVERTISEMENT

especially when OP simply thought he was doing his sister a favor. **This was also definitely not an emotional affair.** If there were an emotional affair, it was entirely carried out by the sister’s partner. OP had no idea his feelings were returned until after he removed himself, and OP has left the other man alone.The real question now is how to navigate OP’s crush marrying into the family.

It is concerning that OP still feels strongly enough that he feels he can’t be part of the bridal party, and I encourage OP to explore why that is. I do think that OP should be honest to his sister about having developed feelings for her fiancé and allowing her agency in how their relationship will progress. It may seem like raising unnecessary drama over something that never happened, but it’s better to be open now,

when walking away is still relatively easy. The issue is that sometimes when we try to protect people, we inadvertently deny them their agency in the matter. OP isn’t the AH for developing feelings and not wanting to be in the bridal party. But he would be the AH if he isn’t honest with his sister and if he doesn’t put in the work to get over those feelings.

ADVERTISEMENT

FredBirdNerd - YTA. For the unbelievable betrayal to your sister. You're a grown man acting like a lovestruck 13 year old who can't control themselves. You never should have spoken to her fiance in the first place and created this godforsaken mess.

[Reddit User] - INFO: Why did you confess to him? What were you trying to gain from telling him you were interested in him?

These Redditors range from sympathetic to scathing, but is silence a betrayal, or a mercy? Can this family mend without the truth coming out?

ADVERTISEMENT

This heart-wrenching tale shows how love can complicate even the tightest family bonds. Our Redditor’s choice to step back from his sister’s bridal party protects his heart but risks her trust, leaving a rift that silence might widen. Should he spill his secret to clear the air, or let the wedding bells drown out the past? What would you do if forbidden feelings threatened your family’s big day? Drop your take below and let’s untangle this emotional knot.

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *