AITA for wanting my baby to have my last name?

Charlotte Morse Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy living room, a young couple’s excitement over their soon-to-be-born child takes a sharp turn. Five months pregnant, she dreams of giving her baby her last name, a choice rooted in a childhood marked by absent fathers and a patchwork of surnames. But when she shares this with her boyfriend, his laughter turns to anger, insisting their child must carry his name to honor his family line. What started as a joyful name game spirals into a heated standoff, leaving her questioning her resolve.

This Reddit story captures the sting of clashing values in a relationship, where personal history meets societal norms. It’s a tale of identity, love, and the weight of legacy. Is she unreasonable for holding firm, or is he clinging to outdated traditions? Let’s dive into this naming drama and sort out the emotions.

‘AITA for wanting my baby to have my last name?’

A bit of background- None of me (25F) and my four siblings have the same late name. My mom had really bad taste in men and always went for the same type of guy. Basically she would fall in love, get pregnant, and then be completely shocked when the guy made a run for it and wanted nothing to do with the kid.

Among my siblings only one of us has a good relationship with their dad. My mom gave all of her kids their dads last names despite the guys wanting nothing to do with any of us. I never really liked how none of our last names matched in my family and I always told myself that when I have kids they're going to have my last name.

Now I'm currently five months pregnant with my first. I've been with my boyfriend for two years and hes super excited to be a dad. The other night the topic of names came up and at first it was fine. We were tossing first and middle names around trying to find ones we liked and then I tested out a full name for the baby, using my last name.

That's when things took a turn. My boyfriend kinda froze when I said my last name and then sort of laughed and said 'You mean (his last name)' and I said 'No, I mean (my last name). I want my kid to have my last name.

I told you about that ages ago' and yes, I have told him before about how I want my kids to have my last name some time in our first year of dating. He told me that he didnt think I was serious about that and that our kid needs to have his last name.

I asked him why the baby Needed his last name and he started talking about continuing his family line and got mad when I pointed out that his older brother already did that so that argument shouldnt count. He started arguing that this was his kid too and I said that I never said it wasn't- I just want my kid to have my last name.

It turned into a big arguement and we went to bed angry. This morning I tried to bring it up now that we had both calmed down. I offered a compromise where we hyphenate and the baby will have both of our names but he said that was a stupid idea and he didnt like it.

I told him that Im not changing my mind on this and that if we got married one day I would be willing to change both mine and the babies last name to his. Boy did that p**s him off. He started accusing my of trying to 'trick' him into marriage (I wasnt) and that I'm being unreasonable.

ADVERTISEMENT

I talked about it with some friends and my sister and they all think I'm being ridiculous and should just give the baby my boyfriends last name. My sister says that she gets where I'm coming from but that I should let him have this to keep the peace.

I'm not sure if my insistence at my kid having my last name instead of my boyfriends is coming from old abandonment issues and I really am being ridiculous or if hes overreacting so I'm turning to you guys on reddit.

ADVERTISEMENT

Choosing a baby’s last name can feel like staking a claim on identity, and this woman’s insistence on her surname carries deep personal meaning. Her boyfriend’s resistance, rooted in tradition, reveals a clash of values. Dr. Harriet Lerner, a relationship expert, notes, “Conflict arises when partners assume their perspective is the only valid one” (HarrietLerner.com). Her history of fragmented family names fuels her stance, while he sees his surname as a non-negotiable legacy.

The tension reflects broader shifts in naming norms. A 2023 Pew Research study found 20% of U.S. parents now choose non-traditional surnames for children, especially among unmarried couples (Pew Research). Her offer to hyphenate was a fair compromise, yet his dismissal and accusations of manipulation suggest a need for deeper communication. His reaction may stem from insecurity, as her past highlights unreliable men, which he might fear being grouped with.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Lerner advises “listening to understand, not to win.” The couple could benefit from discussing what each name represents emotionally, perhaps in counseling. She should also secure her naming choice legally, as Reddit users warned, by informing hospital staff.

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit users jumped in with fiery support and a dash of caution, dishing out opinions like a family debate at Thanksgiving. Here’s what they had to say:

ADVERTISEMENT

jemmls4 − NTA. All of that crap about the kid having the dad’s last name is just that...crap. I would say make sure you tell nurses ahead of birth of your decision and that ALL paperwork on baby’s name must be approved by you.

As the baby’s dad they may ask him to fill out the forms while you are laboring. You may be under influence of medication or sleeping etc. and he could try to list his name as baby’s last name. Not saying your boyfriend will do that, but better safe than sorry.

gendr_bendr − NTA. This guy is showing some red flags. Also it’s not your fault he decided you weren’t being serious about the last name thing. You told him. He ignored it.. Offering a hyphenated last name is great compromise because you both “win” so to speak.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. When he can get pregnant and give birth he can give the baby his last name. FR: he needs to learn the art of compromise. Ultimatums lose everything

gen_petra − Yikes. NTA.. Your call in any case, but it's normal for children of unmarried parents to have the mother's last name.

miyuki_m − NTA. It's part of your identity and you want to share it with your child. Your boyfriend has an expectation of doing *the very same thing* and he's expecting to get his way because it's tradition. He's telling you about his character here.

ADVERTISEMENT

And you're setting a precedent for whatever the future of your relationship is. If it were me, I would stand my ground. Btw, changing last names is a pain in the ass. I changed my last name to my husband's when I got married and I wish I hadn't.

jianantonic − NTA. Why does his preference get to trump yours? If you're overreacting, then isn't he, too? The fact that you'd already told him about your preference really solidifies your position, too. He chose not to take you seriously,

probably because a baby was at the time just a hypothetical concept. Don't let him get away with being an entitled dillhole just for the sake of keeping the peace. Compromise, talk it out, get counseling, whatever, but you have the high ground here.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA because you've offered to give the baby his last name if you get married. That is eminently fair and reasonable. the fact that he reacted poorly to that means you should run for the hills and take your baby with you.

HGTAW − NTA - why should his last name matter more? That’s an antiquated idea

Briarrose1021 − NTA. My sister says that she gets where I'm coming from but that I should let him have this to keep the peace. Ummm. No. He's responding so strongly because there is this assumption that children will have their father's last name. However, there is no rule on that.

ADVERTISEMENT

Not only do you have very strong reasons for giving the baby your last name, you TOLD him about it. It's *his* fault that he did not believe you. Your offer of changing your n**e and the baby's name should you get married in the future is a reasonable compromise, and his accusation that you are trying to trap him is disconcerting.

You definitely need to have another discussion on this when he calm down on this so that you can reiterate your position, but do not give in to him just because he continues to be an AH. He is not more entitled to give that baby his last name than you are; indeed, you are *more* entitled as an unmarried mother.

While you *know* the baby is yours, the only way to definitively tell the baby is his is a DNA test. And, *please* don't think I'm accusing you of cheating here, because I'm definitely not, I'm just speaking in generalities. ETA: if he keeps being an AH about it, make sure your doctor and the nurses know of your plans,

ADVERTISEMENT

and you have paperwork situated before you give birth, so he doesn't try to sneak his name onto the birth certificate while you are under the influence of medication or just exhausted after having given birth. Hell, if he's a big enough AH, you can always bar him from the delivery room..... Edit: I fixed some spelling errors.

BDThrills − NTA You are the one pushing this baby out. It is your call.

From cheering her stance to waving red flags about her boyfriend’s attitude, Reddit’s takes are as bold as a new parent’s resolve. Some see her compromise as generous, others urge her to protect her choice at the hospital. Do these comments nail the issue, or do they miss the emotional layers of this naming tug-of-war?

ADVERTISEMENT

This story of a baby’s last name reveals how deeply personal choices can shake a relationship’s foundation. Her desire to break from a painful family past clashes with her boyfriend’s traditional expectations, leaving them at odds. Is she right to stand her ground, or should she bend for peace? Share your thoughts—what would you do if your partner dismissed a deeply personal choice for your child? How do you balance love, legacy, and identity in a name?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *