AITA for not wanting my father-in-law at my honeymoon?

Charlotte Morse Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The turquoise waves of Cancun were supposed to cradle a newlywed couple’s dreamy honeymoon, but an unexpected knock at the door shattered the romance. A bride, basking in the glow of her month-long getaway, opened the door to find her father-in-law beaming with a “surprise!” Her vision of intimate beachside nights fizzled as family boundaries blurred in a home owned by her in-laws.

After just 24 hours of awkward cohabitation, she pushed to relocate to an Airbnb, a move her non-confrontational husband quietly supported. Now, her in-laws brand her rude and overly sensitive, waving off her plea for privacy. Was her escape a bold stand for her marriage, or did she overreact to a well-meaning visit? This tale of sandy shores and family friction dives into the heart of honeymoon etiquette and boundary battles.

‘AITA for not wanting my father-in-law at my honeymoon?’

My husband and I took a month long honeymoon to the Cancun area, where my husband’s parents own a home. While staying in the family home, we heard a knock at the front door and upon opening it, I saw my father-in-law who said “surprise!”

My husband is a very non-confrontational and respectful son so he did not share his feelings on the situation with his father. However, I felt a need to share my opinion, so after spending approximately 24 hours with my FIL in Cancun,

I told my husband that I would like to move our honeymoon to an air bnb (which we were planning to do in a couple of days anyway). My husband agreed and we left. But, I have since had both my FIL and MIL bring up my rudeness in the situation and tell me that I am far too sensitive.

In response, I explained that I believe it is inappropriate to show up to someone else’s honeymoon unannounced regardless of whether you own the property or how long the honeymoon is (their two main arguments). I actually find it worse that he owns the property since I felt that I could not say no.

I should add that this is not the first time that I have felt my in-laws have acted oblivious to what I believe are very basic boundaries. Nor is it the first time they have told me that I am much too sensitive and cause drama. Please tell me, AITA?

Info: Only one week of the month was supposed to be spent at this house. Ended up spending 5 days at the house in total. The rest of the time was spent traveling the area staying at hostels/air bnb.

Honeymoons are sacred, a time for couples to cement their bond—yet a father-in-law’s surprise visit turned this one into a family reunion nobody asked for. The OP’s swift exit to an Airbnb screams boundary violation, amplified by the in-laws’ ownership of the property, which left her feeling trapped. Her in-laws’ dismissal of her as “too sensitive” hints at a pattern of ignoring her limits, a dynamic that’s all too common in family ties.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Healthy marriages thrive on mutual respect for boundaries, especially early on”. The FIL’s unannounced arrival wasn’t just intrusive; it disrupted the couple’s private milestone. The in-laws’ defense—property ownership and the honeymoon’s length—misses the point: privacy trumps logistics. A 2022 survey found 78% of newlyweds prioritize alone time on honeymoons, underscoring the OP’s stance.

ADVERTISEMENT

The real wrinkle? The husband’s silence. His reluctance to confront his parents puts the OP in the hot seat, a setup for future conflicts. Dr. Gottman advises couples to “present a united front” against overbearing family. The OP could gently urge her husband to set firm boundaries, perhaps with a calm but direct talk with his parents. Long-term, couples counseling might help align their approach.

Here’s what the community had to contribute:

Reddit’s hive mind didn’t hold back, serving up a buffet of sass and sympathy. Here’s the scoop from the online peanut gallery:

ADVERTISEMENT

HellaShelle - NTA. Why in the world did he show up during your honeymoon?! (I'm serious, I'm dying to know what reason he gave for this clearly weird ass action)

[Reddit User] - NTA. But your husband needs handle his side of the family, not you.

ADVERTISEMENT

OkSurround6683 - NTA But your husband should have been able to say something about how that was inappropriate.

Fearless_Act_3698 - As I said above in a comment NTA but I wanted to add if you husband does not grow a spine you will deal with this stomping:. 1. The delivery room. 2. Immediately postpartum. 3. Any decision you want to make as a couple. and so on..

ADVERTISEMENT

They will invite themselves over allllthetime to see the graaaandbaby.. I’ve read about these issues sooo often. Your husband needs to nip this pronto.. Glad you were able to get away. Sorry you were considered “rude”. Not rude in the least bit !!

Elizis - NTA: I’d ask if that want to watch you create their grandchild while they’re at it. That a honeymoon is for a couple for privacy. Anyway I’d also would tell you’re husband he needs to start setting up boundaries like this with his parents or you’ll have to start seeing a couples counselor in the future.

floopdoopsalot - NTA. And consider telling your husband that you did not marry his parents. They were not invited to your honeymoon. Them crashing your honeymoon is intrusive and disturbing. You want your privacy as a couple respected, which is reasonable and normal. You were neither rude nor sensitive.

ADVERTISEMENT

Your ILs think you are still children who don't get to set boundaries with parents. WRONG. You married your husband to create a new family of your own and his parents are overstepping. Counseling may be in order so your husband can understand how to stand up for himself and defend you from his parents overbearing behavior.

hashtagidontknow - NTA It’s your HONEYMOON! Family should not be dropping by and staying with you on such an intimate trip, especially uninvited. Big nope.

PilotEnvironmental46 - They label you “to sensitive” or “dramatic” to put you on the defensive and take away from their actions. Your NTA. Anyone with an iota of common sense knows you don’t show up uninvited and without notice on someone’s honeymoon.

ADVERTISEMENT

That said you don’t have an in-law problem. You have a relationship problem. A fundamental basic of marriage is that your spouse needs to be the one having these conversations with his family. From what your stating, your husband isn’t capable of that. That’s going to make life tough for you.

ohyoushiksagoddess - NTA. Buckle up, it's going to be a bumpy ride.

Hadtosignuptofothis - NTA, WTH, your inlaws hanging out on your honeymoon. This is just nuts.... oh wait, yeah no I've actually experienced this when my MIL invited us to join them for our honeymoon, we worked around it, met them after we had some alone time but it still weirds me out.

ADVERTISEMENT

These spicy takes light up the thread, but do they solve the in-law invasion puzzle? Or are they just cheering from the sidelines?

This Cancun caper leaves a salty aftertaste: a bride’s dream honeymoon crashed by an oblivious father-in-law, with family drama hot on its heels. The OP’s dash to an Airbnb was a cry for privacy, but her in-laws’ backlash paints her as the villain. How do you handle family who trample your boundaries, especially when your spouse stays mum? Share your stories or advice—what’s the best way to keep your honeymoon sacred?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *