AITA for threatening to ban my brother from my wedding because he plans on proposing to his girlfriend during the reception?

Picture a bride-to-be, eyes sparkling with wedding dreams, only to be blindsided by tears when her fiancé’s brother announces he’ll propose at their reception. For this 25-year-old groom, December can’t come fast enough to marry his 24-year-old fiancée, but his brother’s plan to steal the spotlight with a ring of his own has turned joy into chaos. Claiming it’s “payback” for a past slight, the brother’s insistence is tearing family ties apart.

When the groom threatens to ban his brother from the wedding, family backlash rains down, calling him heartless. His fiancée, craving harmony, wonders if they should just let it slide. This Reddit tale dives into a whirlwind of sibling rivalry, wedding etiquette, and the fight to keep their day sacred. Will standing firm ruin family bonds, or is it the only way to protect their moment?

‘AITA for threatening to ban my brother from my wedding because he plans on proposing to his girlfriend during the reception?’

A wedding proposal at someone else’s reception? That’s like crashing a party with your own fireworks. The OP’s brother’s plan to propose, framed as “payback,” disregards the couple’s right to their day. His persistence, even after the fiancée’s clear objection, shows a lack of respect, turning a joyful event into a stage for personal vendettas. The family’s backlash only adds pressure to an already stressed couple.

This scenario highlights a broader issue: navigating wedding etiquette in family dynamics. A 2022 survey by The Knot found that 30% of couples face family conflicts during wedding planning, often over attention-grabbing behavior. The brother’s actions risk upstaging the couple, a major breach of wedding etiquette.

Etiquette expert Elaine Swann advises, “Weddings are about the couple, not a free-for-all for announcements. Guests should respect the event’s focus”. The brother’s “payback” excuse doesn’t justify hijacking the day, and his sharing the plan with family manipulates the narrative against the OP.

Advice: The OP should stand firm, clearly restating the boundary to his brother and family, perhaps in writing for clarity. Assigning a trusted friend to monitor the reception could prevent disruptions. Couples facing similar issues can benefit from resources like The Knot’s etiquette guides.

Heres what people had to say to OP:

Reddit didn’t hold back, serving up a feast of opinions hotter than a wedding dance floor. From calling the brother’s plan “tacky” to urging the OP to ban him outright, the community’s takes are crystal clear. Here’s what they said.

These Reddit reactions are fiery, but do they capture the full picture? Is the brother just petty, or is there more to his grudge?

The OP’s threat to ban his brother is a bold stand for his wedding’s sanctity. His brother’s proposal plan isn’t just bad etiquette—it’s a power play that dismisses the couple’s moment. This story reminds us that weddings are for celebrating love, not settling scores. What would you do if a sibling tried to hijack your big day? Share your experiences—have you ever had to enforce a boundary at a major event?