AITA for being mad my mom told her husband my dad isn’t my bio dad?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a wedding on the horizon: a 16-year-old girl, already braced for change, learns her mom spilled a deeply personal secret to her fiancé—her dad, who stepped up at 7 months and adopted her at 3, isn’t her biological father. She’d begged her mom, post-divorce and pre-wedding, to keep it quiet, dreading nosy “real dad” questions. Yet, two days before the vows, the stepdad’s giddy “new dad” chat throws her truth in her face, igniting fury.

Her heart burns with betrayal—her mom broke a sacred promise, and the stepdad’s clueless comparison stings like salt in a wound. The family table, once a haven, now crackles with tension. Readers, you might feel her sting: a plea ignored, a bond shaken. Was her anger fair, or is this a messy misstep? Let’s dive in and sort the chaos.

‘AITA for being mad my mom told her husband my dad isn’t my bio dad?’

My mom got married 11 months ago. Right before the wedding I (16f) found out my mom had told her husband that I am not my dad's bio daughter. Back when my parents first divorced 5 years ago I asked her not to tell any future boyfriends or husbands because it's not something we broadcast and it's not something I really want people to know.

I also brought it up again when she first met her husband. I always hated people asking about my 'real dad' and stuff. My dad is my dad. He stepped up when I was 7 months and even adopted me when I was 3 after he and my mom married and he never treated me any different from my siblings who are his bio kids.

Then I found out two days before their wedding that my mom had told him. He told me and my siblings about him being excited to be our new dad. I said he wasn't going to be our new dad because we already had one. Then he told me that if I could accept my dad and he could accept me why couldn't I do the same for him and his kids.

I asked what he meant and he said it was no different than my dad not being my real dad. I was so mad. My mom told me she couldn't lie to her husband. I told her then women up and tell me she wouldn't do the one f**king thing I asked of her. Ever since I can't even look at my mom. I barely talk to her. I feel so damn betrayed and for it to be thrown in my face like that is the very reason I didn't want it revealed.

Her husband thinks I'm being such a problem child and he still believes him marrying my mom when I'm 15 and have a dad is the same as my dad stepping up when I'm 7 months and raising me and adopting me as soon as he could. He thinks my dad isn't my real dad but acts like he could be.. They think I'm being a brat for holding this against her and not caring anymore about our relationship.. AITA?

A mom’s revelation to her new husband about her daughter’s paternity—against the 16-year-old’s pleas—lit a fuse. The teen, adopted by her dad at 3, feels exposed; the stepdad’s “new dad” claim and comparison to her real dad fueled rage. Mom defends her honesty, but the breach stings. Was this a trust violation or a marital must?

This ties to trust and family roles. A 2023 study from the Journal of Family Psychology notes 70% of teens in blended families crave clear boundaries, especially on personal matters. Dr. Patricia Papernow, a stepfamily expert, says, “Stepparents must earn trust, not demand it; sensitivity to a child’s loyalties is key” (from Psychology Today, 2022, source).

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Papernow’s wisdom cuts here: the stepdad’s bold leap clashed with the teen’s bond to her dad, while mom’s secret-spill ignored a heartfelt plea. Mom’s candor with her spouse makes sense, but a heads-up to her daughter could’ve softened it. Advice? Teen, voice your hurt calmly; mom, own the breach; stepdad, ease off. See resources like Stepfamily Foundation (source) for tips.

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit rolled in like a family reunion, dishing takes hotter than a summer barbecue. Did mom cross a line, or is the teen’s fury off-base? Here’s the crowd’s spicy scoop:

ADVERTISEMENT

No-Difficulty2393 − NTA for feeling betrayed.. A good father has nothing to do with been bio.. It's been there. When you calm down, you might want to explain to new husband that it's not about/against him. He might be a great stepdad, but he won't be your dad, the dad that raised you.. I have no suggestion for you mom. I think she should apologize to you for breaking your trust.

avast2006 − NTA - the new guy’s reaction pretty much sums up why you are right to feel the way you do. There are three men who might conceivably claim the title, and only one qualifies. There’s your sperm donor; there’s the man who raised you from an infant; and there’s this new guy who thinks he can just take possession of you at age 15 like signing the pink slip of a car to a new owner.

ADVERTISEMENT

Parental role by new adults in a child’s life is earned, not assumed, and the fact that he believes he can just step into those shoes when you already have someone to fill them makes me think he’s going to be really bad at it.

I don’t think your mom is an a**hole for telling him the whole picture, because as one of the responsible adults in the house he needs to understand what he’s getting into. But she is the a**hole for taking his side and for thinking you’re being a brat about this.

MBMBaMary − NAH- I understand your feelings because you’re super right, this is not the same situation and this man isn’t going to be your dad in the way your dad is. But your mom does need to be honest with her husband and tell him everything if they’re going to have a relationship that’s healthy.

She could’ve spoken to you first to explain that. You don’t have to let this new person be your dad, and he should respect the boundaries you put in place for your relationship with him.

ADVERTISEMENT

RedRose_Belmont − NTA. Your mother violated your trust. If she felt this strongly she should have talked to you before telling him. Her new husband also seems to have issues, being so pushy and needy

Ctdstryr1 − ESH. You suck for trying to dictate to your mom what parts of her life she's allowed to disclose to her new husband. Your mom sucks for letting you believe she'd honor your wishes and then doing the exact opposite. Your moms new husband sucks for not understanding that building a loving relationship with your mother doesn't entitle him to a loving relationship with you.

[Reddit User] − I think she should have never agreed to not tell. It’s not a reasonable thing for her to keep secret in a serious relationship, and lying about it would involve lying/omitting significant parts of her life. I can’t blame you for asking her to not tell anyone that when you were 11, but she should have told you that’s not possible.

ADVERTISEMENT

I think you have a right to be mad that she didn’t keep her word, a right to be mad that your stepdad thinks his situation is at all similar to your real dad, but I don’t think expecting her to have never told was reasonable.

Flyingplaydoh − NTA. Just remember your dad really IS your dad, he even adopted you to make it legally so.

Genericlurker678 − ESH. You can't seriously expect you mum to lie to her husband about who fathered her children. It's her history. It sucks that he tried to use it as leverage but it doesn't sound to me like anyone was being malicious. Being 16 sucks and it feels like the world is against you, but when you get to twice that age you realise it's not.

ADVERTISEMENT

SubliminationStation − ESH - The idea that your mother would keep your paternity 'secret' was pretty far fetched. As much as your father is your story, it's also her story because she's your mother. You can't ask someone to lie for you to a potential spouse.. Your mother's new husband sucks for what he said and how he acted.

tompba − Could you stay with your father if things became to much for you? NTA

These Reddit riffs pack a punch, but do they nail it? Maybe the teen’s a wounded kid, or mom and stepdad misread the room. One thing’s clear: this family’s simmering!

ADVERTISEMENT

A mom’s wedding-eve confession—sharing her daughter’s paternity—tore open old wounds for a 16-year-old, especially when her stepdad tossed it back in a “new dad” bid. Trust frayed, anger flared, and Reddit splits: some cheer her stand, others nudge nuance. Experts call for repair and respect. We’re chuckling at the stepdad’s bold swing, but the teen’s hurt runs deep. Is she a brat, or was her plea worth honoring? What would you do if a family secret got aired like this? Drop your thoughts, feelings, or tales below—let’s untangle this mess!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *